One of the primary tasks in building a quantum theory of gravity is discovering how to save spatiotemporal phenomena using a theory which, putatively, does not include spacetime. Some have taken this task a step further and argue for the actual emergence of spacetime from a non-spatiotemporal ontology in the low-energy regime. In this paper, it is argued that the account of spacetime emergence presented in Huggett and Wüthrich(2013) and then assumed in Baron (2019), Crowther (2016), Wüthrich (2017), and Wüthrich and Lam (2018) fails to accomplish the task to which it is set. There is a prima facie contradiction between the scale-independent ontology of spacetime in GR and the scale-dependent account of emergence proposed by this literature. One can avoid this contradiction but only at the cost of changing the target of emergence and by endorsing a perspectival theory of ontology – a view I call “ontic-perspectivism”. Though this paper explicitly addresses spacetime emergence, many of the following arguments are applicable to other accounts where objects of ontology, or their properties, are claimed to emerge in the low-energy regime.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Petkov, Vesselin;
(2010)
Minkowski Spacetime: A Hundred Years Later
(/isis/citation/CBB001032084/)
Book
Shan Gao;
(2017)
The Meaning of the Wave Function: In Search of the Ontology of Quantum Mechanics
(/isis/citation/CBB078217999/)
Book
Davide Romano;
(2024)
Filosofia della meccanica quantistica. L'interpretazione standard
(/isis/citation/CBB735842401/)
Article
Enrico Cinti;
Vincenzo Fano;
(2021)
Careful with those scissors, Eugene! Against the observational indistinguishability of spacetimes
(/isis/citation/CBB952356420/)
Article
José Luis Jaramillo;
Vincent Lam;
(2021)
Counterfactuals in the Initial Value Formulation of General Relativity
(/isis/citation/CBB686526622/)
Article
Monton, Bradley;
(2004)
The Problem of Ontology for Spontaneous Collapse Theories
(/isis/citation/CBB000471125/)
Article
Ferrero, M.;
Pin, V. Gómez;
Salgado, D.;
Sánchez-Gómez, J. L.;
(2013)
A Further Review of the Incompatibility between Classical Principles and Quantum Postulates
(/isis/citation/CBB001252717/)
Article
Arenhart, Jonas R. B.;
(2012)
Ontological Frameworks for Scientific Theories
(/isis/citation/CBB001252712/)
Thesis
Baker, David John;
(2008)
An Ontological Study of Quantum Fields and Their Symmetries
(/isis/citation/CBB001561228/)
Book
Callender, Craig;
Huggett, Nick;
(2001)
Physics Meets Philosophy at the Planck Scale: Contemporary Theories in Quantum Gravity
(/isis/citation/CBB000102413/)
Chapter
Rickles, Dean;
(2012)
Quantum Gravity Meets &HPS
(/isis/citation/CBB001500249/)
Article
Dean Rickles;
(2018)
Geon Wheeler: from nuclear to spacetime physicist
(/isis/citation/CBB971617296/)
Article
Elliott D. Chen;
(2023)
Newtonian gravitation in Maxwell spacetime
(/isis/citation/CBB782117192/)
Book
Michael Epperson;
Elias Zafiris;
(2013)
Foundations of Relational Realism: A Topological Approach to Quantum Mechanics and the Philosophy of Nature
(/isis/citation/CBB523456771/)
Book
Michael Esfeld;
Dirk-Andre Deckert;
(2017)
A Minimalist Ontology of the Natural World
(/isis/citation/CBB709304434/)
Book
Päs, Heinrich;
(2014)
The Perfect Wave: With Neutrinos at the Boundary of Space and Time
(/isis/citation/CBB001422070/)
Book
Arntzenius, Frank;
Dorr, Cian Seán;
(2012)
Space, Time, & Stuff
(/isis/citation/CBB001553231/)
Article
Robyn Yucel;
(2018)
Scientists’ Ontological and Epistemological Views about Science from the Perspective of Critical Realism
(/isis/citation/CBB219306053/)
Article
Michael Fry;
(2020)
Ontologically Simple Theories Do Not Indicate the True Nature of Complex Biological Systems: Three Test Cases
(/isis/citation/CBB515852529/)
Article
van Heur, Bas;
Leydesdorff, Loet;
Wyatt, Sally;
(June 2013)
Turning to ontology in STS? Turning to STS through ‘ontology’
(/isis/citation/CBB199076323/)
Be the first to comment!