L’article revient sur les enquêtes officielles qui ont conduit à la condamnation du magnétisme animal en 1784. Il s’attache principalement à étudier comment ont été constituées les deux commissions chargées d’enquêter, la commission royale et la commission de la Société royale de médecine, comment se sont déroulées les enquêtes elles-mêmes, sous forme d’observations dans la clinique du docteur Deslon, un disciple de Mesmer, puis sous forme d’expériences sur des sujets isolés (certaines en simple aveugle), et, enfin, comment les rapports ont été préparés et rédigés. L’objectif est de montrer, à partir des nombreux documents produits à cette occasion, la complexité et les contradictions des enquêtes, les divisions entre les enquêteurs et, finalement, la fragilité des conclusions auxquelles ils sont parvenus. L’article illustre ainsi, sur un cas célèbre, la difficulté d’arriver à des certitudes quand il s’agit d’évaluer des traitements médicaux. This article rereads the official inquiries that led to the condemnation of animal magnetism in 1784. It focuses on how the two investigating committees, the Royal Commission and the Commission of the Royal Society of Medicine, were constituted; how the investigations themselves were carried out, in the form of observations in the clinic of Dr Deslon, a disciple of Mesmer, and then in the form of experiments on isolated subjects (some of them for placebo effect); and finally how the reports were prepared and written. The aim is to show, on the basis of the numerous documents produced on this occasion, the complexity and contradictions of the investigations, the divisions between the investigators, and the fragility of the conclusions they reached. Using this famous case, the article thus illustrates the difficulty of arriving at certainties when it comes to evaluating medical treatments.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Scottie Hale Buehler;
(2021)
Aborted Dreams and Contested Labors: The Société Royale de Médecine’s 1786 Survey of Midwives
Article
Roche, Daniel;
(1977)
Talents, raison, et sacrifice: L'image du médecin des Lumières d'après les èloges de la Société royale de médecine (1776-1789)
Chapter
Mendelsohn, J. Andrew;
(2010)
The World on a Page: Making a General Observation in the Eighteenth Century
Book
Stefano Ossicini;
(2019)
L’inganno di Mesmer e la commissione Franklin-Lavoisier: Come la scienza ha imparato ad affrontare le controversie pubbliche
Article
Heather Wolffram;
Andreas-Holger Maehle;
(2017)
History of Hypnotism in Europe and the Significance of Place
Thesis
Hannaway, Caroline C.;
(1974)
Medicine, public welfare and the state in 18th century France: The Société Royale de Médecine of Paris (1776-1793)
Article
Alembert, Jean Le Rond d';
(1976)
D'Alembert, le traitement de la rage, et la Société Royale de Médecine: Cinq lettres inédites. [Présentation par] Théodoridès, Jean
Article
José Ramón Bertomeu Sánchez;
(2021)
Lead Poisoning in France around 1840: Managing Proofs and Uncertainties in Laboratories, Courtrooms, and Workplaces
Article
Adam Crabtree;
Eberhard Bauer;
(2022)
On why history is never finished: Puységur, animal magnetism, and the importance of collective scholarship
Article
Giampietro Gobo;
Barbara Sena;
(2022)
Questioning and Disputing Vaccination Policies. Scientists and Experts in the Italian Public Debate
Article
Arnaud Parent;
(2020)
From Vitalism to Animal Magnetism: The Mesmerist Experiments of Dr Jean-Emmanuel Gilibert (1741–1814)
Book
Haller, John S.;
(2010)
Swedenborg, Mesmer, and the Mind/Body Connection: The Roots of Complementary Medicine
Article
Thomas Apel;
(2020)
‘Revolutions, Philosophical as Well as Civil’: French Chemistry and American Science in Samuel Latham Mitchill’s Medical Repository
Article
Guerrini, Anita;
(2003)
Duverney's Skeletons
Book
Gordon David Lyle Bates;
(2023)
The Uncanny Rise of Medical Hypnotism, 1888–1914: Between Imagination and Suggestion
Article
Armel Cornu;
(2023)
Senses and Utility in the New Chemistry
Book
E. Claire Cage;
(2022)
The Science of Proof: Forensic Medicine in Modern France
Book
Monroe, John Warne;
(2008)
Laboratories of Faith: Mesmerism, Spiritism, and Occultism in Modern France
Article
Carlos S Alvarado;
(2019)
Jules Bernard Luys on magnetic pathology
Article
Alexander Wragge-Morley;
(2022)
Taste, intersubjectivity and medical expertise: the correspondence of George Cheyne, Selina Hastings and their patients
Acta Baltica historiae et philosophiae scientiarum
Annales, économies, sociétés, civilisations
Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology
Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society
Bulletin of the History of Medicine
Be the first to comment!