Gender, Passion, and ‘Sticky’ Technology in a Voluntaristically-Organized Technology Makerspace (2023)
Andreas Ottemo (Author)
Maria Berge (Author)
Heather Mendick (Author)
Eva Silfver (Author)
Engineering Studies
Volume: 15
Issue: 2
Pages: 101-121
As ‘open’ and supposedly inclusive informal learning settings that participants visit out of interest and passion, there has been hope that makerspaces will democratize technology and challenge traditional gender patterns in engineering education. Passion for technology has, however, also been shown to be deeply intertwined with the masculinization of engineering. This article explores how this tension manifests among engineering students and other makers at an ‘open’ voluntaristically-organized technology makerspace located at the campus of a Swedish university of technology. It draws on a post-structural understanding of gender and Sara Ahmed’s queer-phenomenological conceptualization of emotions as ‘orienting devices’. Based on ethnographic fieldwork and interviews with makers, we show how passion for technology is articulated as a particularly absorbing emotion that underpins a playful approach to technology and a framing of makers as single-minded and asocial. We demonstrate how passion for technology thereby becomes a homosocial ‘glue’ that makes technology ‘sticky’ for only a select group of techno-passionate men. We conclude that this undermines the potential for ‘making’ to democratize technology and puts into question the degree to which interest-driven, voluntaristic and ‘authentic’ settings for engaging with technology can contribute to pluralizing engineering.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Kacey Beddoes;
(2024)
Taking Stock and Looking Forward: Fifteen Years of Research on Gender, Race, and Power in Engineering Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB374912239/)
Article
Kacey Beddoes;
(2023)
Discursive Boundary Work around Gender, Inclusion, and Exclusion in Engineering and Industrial Design
(/isis/citation/CBB122968666/)
Article
Kristin A. Bartlett;
Stephanie M. Masta;
(2023)
A Glimpse into the Gendered Dynamics in Industrial Design through the Podcast Discourse
(/isis/citation/CBB066756725/)
Article
Shannon K. Gilmartin;
Samantha R. Brunhaver;
Sara Jordan-Bloch;
Gabriela Gall Rosa;
Caroline Simard;
Sheri D. Sheppard;
(2024)
Early-Career Assignments and Workforce Inequality in Engineering
(/isis/citation/CBB418021747/)
Article
Annie Y. Patrick;
Matthew H. Wisnioski;
Lisa McNair;
Desen Sevi Ozkan;
David Reeping;
Thomas L. Martin;
Luke Lester;
Scott Dunning;
Ben Knapp;
Liesl Baum Walker;
Chelsea E. Haines;
(2023)
In it for the Long Haul: The Groundwork of Interdisciplinary Culture Change in Engineering Education Reform
(/isis/citation/CBB239948403/)
Article
Anastasia M. K. Schauer;
Hunter Schaufel;
Katherine Fu;
(2023)
The Makeup of a Makerspace: The Impact of Stereotyping, Self-Efficacy, and Physical Design on Women’s Interactions with an Academic Makerspace
(/isis/citation/CBB232480487/)
Article
Jessica M. Smith;
(2023)
Language Matters: Writing for Engineering Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB211429245/)
Article
Floris van der Marel;
Tua Björklund;
Sheri Sheppard;
(2024)
Moments that Matter: Early-Career Experiences of Diverse Engineers on Different Career Pathways
(/isis/citation/CBB859500078/)
Article
Abigail H. Neely;
Laura A. Meek;
(2024)
African Experiments in Health and Healing: Science from the Home and Homestead
(/isis/citation/CBB357279410/)
Book
Sarah E. Vaughn;
(2022)
Engineering Vulnerability: In Pursuit of Climate Adaptation
(/isis/citation/CBB670658771/)
Book
Ruha Benjamin;
(2019)
Captivating Technology: Race, Carceral Technoscience, and Liberatory Imagination in Everyday Life
(/isis/citation/CBB021638267/)
Article
Edward B. Kang;
Simogne Hudson;
(2024)
Audible Crime Scenes: ShotSpotter as Diagnostic, Policing, and Space-making Infrastructure
(/isis/citation/CBB934050438/)
Article
Theresa Selfa;
Christopher Cummings;
Michael Dahlstrom;
Sonja Lindberg;
David Peters;
Clark Wolf;
Carmen Bain;
(2023)
Gene Editing in Agriculture: Social Concerns, Public Engagement, and Governance
(/isis/citation/CBB164522069/)
Article
Kristin A. Bartlett;
(2024)
The Politics of the Purdue Spatial Visualization Test of Rotations (PSVT:R) and its Use in Engineering Education
(/isis/citation/CBB326076545/)
Article
Ingemar Pettersson;
(2016)
The Technoscientists: A Swedish Construction of Basic Research in World War Ii
(/isis/citation/CBB370392224/)
Article
Göran Eriksson;
Lauren Alex O’Hagan;
(2021)
Selling “Healthy” Radium Products With Science: A Multimodal Analysis of Marketing in Sweden, 1910–1940
(/isis/citation/CBB442776682/)
Article
Kai Lo Andersson;
Catharina Landström;
(2023)
The Sole Engineering Genius: A Professional Identity Not Fit for the Purpose of Gender Equality Projects
(/isis/citation/CBB351777719/)
Book
Venkatesh Narayanamurti;
Jeffrey Y. Tsao;
(2021)
The Genesis of Technoscientific Revolutions: Rethinking the Nature and Nurture of Research
(/isis/citation/CBB200812792/)
Article
Megan E. Tomko;
Robert L. Nagel;
Wendy Newstetter;
Shaunna F. Smith;
Kimberly G. Talley;
Julie Linsey;
(2021)
Making a Makerspace: Identified Practices in the Formation of a University Makerspace
(/isis/citation/CBB410526220/)
Book
Ihde, Don;
Selinger, Evan;
(2003)
Chasing Technoscience: Matrix for Materiality
(/isis/citation/CBB000320213/)
Be the first to comment!