The world of charlatans is a world of constantly shifting borders and redefinitions, a world of crossed lines and pushed boundaries. Can one even speak of “the world” of charlatans in the singular, when the examples we are given to read in this volume reveal such great diversity that they seem to defeat any attempt to define common traits, as Roy Porter (1989) tried to do in his time? Certainly, commercial interests and the lure of a quick and easy profit seem to have motivated some charlatans. Certainly, the universal effects of the nostrum or (psycho)therapeutic procedures were often put forward as a commercial argument. Certainly, many had an itinerant career; but this was not always the case. In fact, these traits are not shared, and the main reason is probably that, aside from a very particular context in early modern Italy, the qualification of charlatan was not claimed by the actors themselves, but was attributed to them by others, be they contemporaries or later historians. These features are therefore only common if we understand them as stigmata attributed to charlatans by those who wish to distinguish themselves from them or to draw a line between orthodoxy and heterodoxy.
...MoreArticle Irina Podgorny; Daniel Gethmann (2020) 'Please, come in.' Being a charlatan, or the question of trustworthy knowledge. Science in Context (pp. 355-361).
Similar Citations
Article
Koen Vermeir;
(2020)
Charlatan epistemology: As illustrated by a study of wonder-working in the late seventeenth-century Dutch Republic
(/isis/citation/CBB516788881/)
Article
Davids, Karel;
(2012)
Gate-Keeping: Who Defined Useful Knowledge in Early Modern Times?
(/isis/citation/CBB001252256/)
Article
Thifault, Marie-Claude;
(2010)
Le nursing psychiatrique à l'École des gardes-malades de l'Hôpital Saint-Jean-de-Dieu: “le côté spirituel en tête du côté technique”
(/isis/citation/CBB001211526/)
Article
Irina Podgorny;
Daniel Gethmann;
(2020)
'Please, come in.' Being a charlatan, or the question of trustworthy knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB012504782/)
Thesis
Alejandro Quintero Mächler;
(2020)
Bleeding Nations: Blood Discourses and the Interpretation of Violence in Mid-Nineteenth Century Spanish America (1838-1870)
(/isis/citation/CBB675465421/)
Article
Min Bae;
(2022)
Locating hygienic medicine within the intellectual history of hygiene: Cases of E. W. Lane and T. R. Allinson
(/isis/citation/CBB492978326/)
Book
Owen Whooley;
(2019)
On the Heels of Ignorance: Psychiatry and the Politics of Not Knowing
(/isis/citation/CBB842410847/)
Book
Johann Christoph Burgel;
Fabian Kas;
(2016)
Ärztliches Leben und Denken im arabischen Mittelalter
(/isis/citation/CBB160568408/)
Article
Andreeva, Anna;
(2014)
Childbirth in Aristocratic Households of Heian Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB001500008/)
Book
Victor Genin;
(2018)
Le laboratoire belge du droit international: Une communauté épistémique et internationale de juristes (1869-1914)
(/isis/citation/CBB640698655/)
Book
Mohr, James C.;
(2013)
Licensed to Practice: The Supreme Court Defines the American Medical Profession
(/isis/citation/CBB001213165/)
Article
Robert A. Buerki;
(2014)
The Effect of Prerequisite Legislation on Pharmaceutical Education and Licensure, 1905–1925
(/isis/citation/CBB495709191/)
Book
David Alan Johnson;
(2018)
Diploma Mill: The Rise and Fall of Dr. John Buchanan and the Eclectic Medical College of Pennsylvania
(/isis/citation/CBB734894658/)
Article
Stanley, Heather;
(2012)
Sairey Gamps, Feminine Nurses and Greedy Monopolists: Discourses of Gender and Professional Identity in the Lancet and the British Medical Journal, 1886--1902
(/isis/citation/CBB001250802/)
Article
Glenn Sonnedecker;
(2016)
Remarks on the Dedication of a Historical Marker Commemorating the First Licensing of Pharmacists in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB581496620/)
Article
James Schlett;
(2022)
When Rollo May’s “little band” of New York psychologists fought back against organized medicine’s attempts to control psychotherapy
(/isis/citation/CBB438968805/)
Chapter
José Alberto Silva;
(2021)
O projecto da Academia Real das Ciências de Lisboa, 1779‑1820
(/isis/citation/CBB669277963/)
Article
Crosland, Maurice;
(2007)
The Financial Support of Men of Science in France c. 1660--c. 1800: A Survey
(/isis/citation/CBB000773216/)
Article
Verdon, Nicola;
(2012)
Business and Pleasure: Middle-Class Women's Work and the Professionalization of Farming in England, 1890--1939
(/isis/citation/CBB001214691/)
Article
Duffin, Jacalyn;
Stuart, Meryn;
(2012)
Feminization of Canadian Medicine: Voices from the Second Wave
(/isis/citation/CBB001250804/)
Be the first to comment!