[Controversy on the Safety Examination of the Tokai Nuclear Power Plant: Focusing on the Issue of Major Accidents] 東海発電所の安全審査をめぐる論争: 原子力災害を中心に (2020)
Yōko 陽子 Yokota 横田 (Author)
科学史研究 Kagakusi Kenkyu (History of Science)
Volume: 59
Issue: 293
Pages: 1-17
This paper examines controversy during the safety examination of the first commercial nuclear power plant (NPP) in Japan, the Tokai Nuclear Power Plant, focusing on the issue of major accidents. Politicians, bureaucrats, business leaders, and engineers generally pushed for the plantʼs construction, while scientists -- mainly physicists -- opposed it. At the time, nuclear power technology was a rapidly growing field, with the knowledge of its safety yet to be established. The controversy revolved around four key issues: 1) how to develop NPP technology; 2) how to mitigate the risk of a major accident; 3) how to estimate the potential effects of such an accident on people; and 4) how to determine the “safety” of NPPs. In addressing these issues, scientists consistently upheld the three basic principles on nuclear research and development in Japan, namely democracy, independence, and public disclosure, emphasizing the importance of free discussion and rigorous scientific standards. By contrast, advocates of power plants opposed such an approach and supported the approval of the construction plan on the basis of administrative procedures. In this way, the knowledge on reactor and radiation safety offered by scientists was intentionally and politically disregarded.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Creager, Angela N. H.;
(2009)
Radioisotopes as Political Instruments, 1946--1953
(/isis/citation/CBB000931750/)
Chapter
Giulio Maltese;
(2009)
Enrico Fermi e il suo ruolo nella scienza, in Italia e in America
(/isis/citation/CBB953079691/)
Article
Tolliday, Steven;
(2012)
Crumbling Dream: Japan's Nuclear Quest, 1954--2011
(/isis/citation/CBB001211687/)
Article
Sahm, Astrid;
(2013)
Atomenergie in Ost- und Westeuropa: Reaktionen auf Tschernobyl und Fukushima
(/isis/citation/CBB001200600/)
Book
Rodney P. Carlisle;
Joan M. Zenzen;
(1996)
Supplying the Nuclear Arsenal: American Production-reactors, 1942-1992
(/isis/citation/CBB967814772/)
Book
Ana Romero de Pablos;
(2019)
Las primeras centrales nucleares españolas: Actores, políticas y tecnologías.
(/isis/citation/CBB801831424/)
Chapter
Yuko Fujigaki;
(2015)
The Processes Through Which Nuclear Power Plants Are Embedded in Political, Economic, and Social Contexts in Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB230765575/)
Chapter
Daniel P. Aldrich;
(2013)
Postcrisis Japanese Nuclear Policy
(/isis/citation/CBB068758484/)
Book
Susanne Bauer;
Tanja Penter;
(2022)
Tracing the Atom: Nuclear Legacies in Russia and Central Asia
(/isis/citation/CBB363250490/)
Article
Johnston, Sean F.;
(2011)
Making the Invisible Engineer Visible: DuPont and the Recognition of Nuclear Expertise
(/isis/citation/CBB001230737/)
Book
Gregory B. Jaczko;
(2019)
Confessions of a Rogue Nuclear Regulator
(/isis/citation/CBB130164448/)
Article
Simone Turchetti;
(2020)
The Unflinching Mr. Smith and the Nuclear Age
(/isis/citation/CBB663303797/)
Article
Oatsvall, Neil;
(2014)
Atomic Agriculture: Policymaking, Food Production, and Nuclear Technologies in the United States, 1945--1960
(/isis/citation/CBB001421774/)
Article
Takahisa 高久 Amemiya 雨宮;
(2019)
[On the Drafting and Postponing of the B-plan by the Special Panel on Nuclear Fusion Research] 核融合専門部会によるb計画の立案と先送り
(/isis/citation/CBB618502010/)
Article
Pritchard, Sara B.;
(2012)
An Envirotechnical Disaster: Nature, Technology, and Politics at Fukushima
(/isis/citation/CBB001232549/)
Article
Uekoetter, Frank;
(2012)
Fukushima, Europe, and the Authoritarian Nature of Nuclear Technology
(/isis/citation/CBB001232551/)
Article
Kelly, Dominic;
(2015)
Ideology, Society, and the Origins of Nuclear Power in Japan
(/isis/citation/CBB001550710/)
Book
Eckart Conze;
Martin Klimke;
Jeremy Varon;
(2016)
Nuclear Threats, Nuclear Fear and the Cold War of the 1980s
(/isis/citation/CBB924250158/)
Article
Tatiana Kasperski;
(2019)
Children, Nation and Reactors: Imagining and Promoting Nuclear Power in Contemporary Ukraine
(/isis/citation/CBB123644988/)
Book
Sidorenko, Viktor;
(2001-2003)
Istoriia atomnoi energetiki Sovetskogo Soiuza i Rossii
(/isis/citation/CBB000321016/)
Be the first to comment!