This paper discusses some philosophical aspects related to the recent publication of the experimental results of the 2017 black hole experiment, namely the first image of the supermassive black hole at the center of galaxy M87. In this paper I present a philosophical analysis of the 2017 Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) black hole experiment. I first present Hacking's philosophy of experimentation. Hacking gives his taxonomy of elements of laboratory science and distinguishes a list of elements. I show that the EHT experiment conforms to major elements from Hacking's list. I then describe with the help of Galison's Philosophy of the Shadow how the EHT Collaboration created the famous black hole image. Galison outlines three stages for the reconstruction of the black hole image: Socio-Epistemology, Mechanical Objectivity, after which there is an additional Socio-Epistemology stage. I subsequently present my own interpretation of the reconstruction of the black hole image and I discuss model fitting to data. I suggest that the main method used by the EHT Collaboration to assure trust in the results of the EHT experiment is what philosophers call the Argument from Coincidence. I show that using this method for the above purpose is problematic. I present two versions of the Argument from Coincidence: Hacking's Coincidence and Cartwright's Reproducibility by which I analyse the EHT experiment. The same estimation of the mass of the black hole is reproduced in four different procedures. The EHT Collaboration concludes: the value we have converged upon is robust. I analyse the mass measurements of the black hole with the help of Cartwright's notion of robustness. I show that the EHT Collaboration construe Coincidence/Reproducibility as Technological Agnosticism and I contrast this interpretation with van Fraassen's scientific agnosticism.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Galina Weinstein;
(2021)
Is the EHT black hole experiment a new experiment in the guise of an old experiment?
(/isis/citation/CBB675564388/)
Article
Wayne Orchiston;
(2022)
Govind Swarup, Potts Hill and the Kalyan Array: India's first radio telescope
(/isis/citation/CBB478495888/)
Article
Philip Kao;
Sebastien Vasey;
(2020)
Our Human Quest with the Black Hole
(/isis/citation/CBB184684664/)
Article
Oana Matei;
(2020)
Experimenting with Matter in the Works of Gabriel Plattes
(/isis/citation/CBB611095719/)
Book
Ofer Lahav;
Lucy Calder;
Julian Mayers;
(2020)
The Dark Energy Survey: The Story of a Cosmological Experiment
(/isis/citation/CBB966761620/)
Article
Richter, Peter H.;
(2012)
Gedanken zur Zeit
(/isis/citation/CBB001421053/)
Book
Hartmann, Stephan;
(2008)
Nancy Cartwright's Philosophy of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB000951976/)
Book
Dario Generali;
(2016)
Le Radici della Razionalità Critica: Saperi, Pratiche, Teleologie. Studi offerti a Fabio Minazzi
(/isis/citation/CBB605863308/)
Article
Juan Manuel Garrido Wainer;
Juan Felipe Espinosa;
Natalia Hirmas;
Nicolás Trujillo;
(2020)
Free-viewing as experimental system to test the Temporal Correlation Hypothesis: A case of theory-generative experimental practice
(/isis/citation/CBB253993764/)
Book
Collins, H. M;
(2011)
Gravity's Ghost: Scientific Discovery in the Twenty-First Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001033347/)
Book
Otávio Bueno;
Ruey-Lin Chen;
Melinda Bonnie Fagan;
(2018)
Individuation, Process, and Scientific Practices
(/isis/citation/CBB334934609/)
Book
Steel, Daniel;
Guala, Francesco;
(2011)
The Philosophy of Social Science Reader
(/isis/citation/CBB001450891/)
Book
Fagan, Melinda Bonnie;
(2013)
Philosophy of Stem Cell Biology: Knowledge in Flesh and Blood
(/isis/citation/CBB001420098/)
Thesis
Mayo, Lee Allen;
(2011)
Simulation without Replication: How Some Digital Computer Simulations Serve as Scientific Experiments
(/isis/citation/CBB001567307/)
Article
Sharrock, Wes;
Leudar, Ivan;
(2002)
Indeterminacy in the Past?
(/isis/citation/CBB000202402/)
Article
A. Venegas-Li;
H. Solís-Sánchez;
M. Quirós-Rojas;
M. Guevara-Bertsch;
K. Chaves-Cruz;
E. Boza-Oviedo;
S. Vargas-Hernández;
M. Ortega-Rodríguez;
(2017)
The Early Scientific Contributions of J. Robert Oppenheimer: Why Did the Scientific Community Miss the Black Hole Opportunity?
(/isis/citation/CBB236768493/)
Book
Dario Generali;
(2016)
Le Radici della Razionalità Critica: Saperi, Pratiche, Teleologie. Studi offerti a Fabio Minazzi
(/isis/citation/CBB543052276/)
Article
Enrico Cinti;
Vincenzo Fano;
(2021)
Careful with those scissors, Eugene! Against the observational indistinguishability of spacetimes
(/isis/citation/CBB952356420/)
Article
Kragh, Helge;
(2009)
Contemporary History of Cosmology and the Controversy over the Multiverse
(/isis/citation/CBB001021548/)
Article
Kragh, Helge;
(2013)
“The Most Philosophically Important of All the Sciences”: Karl Popper and Physical Cosmology
(/isis/citation/CBB001320398/)
Be the first to comment!