Fairness in the Field: The Ethics of Resource Allocation in Randomized Controlled Field Experiments (2019)
Rayzberg, Margarita S. (Author)
Science, Technology, and Human Values
Volume: 44
Issue: 3
Pages: 371-398
Many in the international development community have embraced the randomized controlled field experiment, akin to a biomedical clinical trial for social interventions, as the new “gold evidential standard” in program impact evaluation. In response, critics have called upon the method’s advocates to consider the moral dimensions of randomization, leading to a debate about the method’s ethics. My research intervenes in this debate by empirically investigating how researchers manage the perception of randomization in the field. Without the possibility of a placebo, researchers rhetorically and materially frame the experiment differently for the control and treatment groups. Three technologies allow for this differential framing: geographic separation, temporal delay, and public randomization ceremonies. Geographic separation is a “technology of opacity” designed to obscure unequal resource distribution by disentangling the intervention and research components of the experiment for the control group. The latter two are technologies of transparency designed to expose the element of randomization but downplay conditions that may affect participant buy in. All three technologies work to preclude collective definitions of fair resource allocation, yet they are not fully successful in preventing modes of confrontation and resistance that lie outside of the experiment’s framing.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Logan D. A. Williams;
(March 2018)
Mapping Superpositionality in Global Ethnography
(/isis/citation/CBB873960993/)
Article
Yoshio Nukaga;
(July 2016)
Ethics Expertise and Public Credibility: A Case Study of the Ethical Principle of Justice
(/isis/citation/CBB610704199/)
Article
Salla Sariola;
(2023)
Mistrust: Community engagement in global health research in coastal Kenya
(/isis/citation/CBB869316828/)
Book
Hargittai, Eszter;
Sandvig, Christian;
(2015)
Digital research confidential: the secrets of studying behavior online
(/isis/citation/CBB570718606/)
Book
Heyes, Cecilia;
Hull, David L.;
(2001)
Selection theory and social construction: The evolutionary naturalistic epistemology of Donald T. Campbell
(/isis/citation/CBB000101408/)
Article
Wendorf, Craig A.;
(2001)
The History of American Morality Research, 1894-1932
(/isis/citation/CBB000100115/)
Article
Radick, Gregory;
(2000)
Morgan's canon, Garner's phonograph, and the evolutionary origins of language and reason
(/isis/citation/CBB000110654/)
Article
Brian Balmer;
(March 2017)
Shadow Values and the Politics of Extrapolation (Special Issue Commentary)
(/isis/citation/CBB819964335/)
Article
Sheldon Krimsky;
(November 2015)
An Illusory Consensus behind GMO Health Assessment
(/isis/citation/CBB119149138/)
Article
Eric Giannella;
(May 2016)
Expert Judgment versus Market Accounting in an Industrial Research Lab
(/isis/citation/CBB650423114/)
Article
Carmen McLeod;
Sarah Hartley;
(July 2018)
Responsibility and Laboratory Animal Research Governance
(/isis/citation/CBB564349730/)
Article
Sky Edith Gross;
Shai Lavi;
Hagai Boas;
(2019)
Medicine, Technology, and Religion Reconsidered: The Case of Brain Death Definition in Israel
(/isis/citation/CBB228629534/)
Article
Beth Greenhough;
Emma Roe;
(July 2018)
Exploring the Role of Animal Technologists in Implementing the 3Rs: An Ethnographic Investigation of the UK University Sector
(/isis/citation/CBB661318783/)
Article
Sampsa Saikkonen;
Esa Väliverronen;
(2022)
The trickle-down of political and economic control: On the organizational suppression of environmental scientists in government science
(/isis/citation/CBB033206075/)
Article
Caitlin Donahue Wylie;
(March 2018)
Trust in Technicians in Paleontology Laboratories
(/isis/citation/CBB439482778/)
Article
Daniel Neyland;
(January 2016)
Bearing Account-able Witness to the Ethical Algorithmic System
(/isis/citation/CBB408589504/)
Article
Harold Mytum;
(2021)
Ethics and Practice in the Excavation, Examination, Analysis, and Preservation of Historical Mummified Human Remains
(/isis/citation/CBB762921346/)
Article
Adam Moe Fejerskov;
(September 2017)
The New Technopolitics of Development and the Global South as a Laboratory of Technological Experimentation
(/isis/citation/CBB190620676/)
Article
Kelly Joslin Holloway;
(September 2015)
Normalizing Complaint: Scientists and the Challenge of Commercialization
(/isis/citation/CBB582502078/)
Book
Alfred Nordmann;
Hans Radder;
Gregor Schiemann;
(2014)
Strukturwandel der Wissenschaft: Positionen zum Epochenbruch
(/isis/citation/CBB949939793/)
Be the first to comment!