Article ID: CBB040310171

Saphaeae and Hayʾāt: The Debate between Instrumentalism and Realism in Al-Andalus (2017)

unapi

The article explores several texts written in al-Andalus between the twelfth and the early fourteenth centuries that mention Ibn al-Zarqālluh (al-Zarqālī) or the “Toledan astronomers.” These texts, contained in the works of physicians and philosophers, express scholarly reactions to the contributions of the circle of astronomers of eleventh-century Toledo, sponsored by the judge Ṣāʿid al-Andalusī. The textual evidence reveals attitudes ranging from a somewhat naïve admiration to harsh criticism. The article deals with the idealised image of the Toledan circle, due to a great extent to the significance of their work but also to external factors such as the innovative instruments and devices that these astronomers made. The texts suggest that some of the contributions of the Toledan circle were debated during the twelfth century, and that the echoes of this debate were felt in the following centuries. The discussion centred on the instrumentalism of Toledan astronomy, which was criticised by scholars who discussed the compatibility of Ptolemy’s mathematical astronomy and Aristotle’s natural philosophy. The “revolt against Ptolemy” that characterises this debate is reconsidered in the light of both the texts under study and the findings of recent research.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB040310171/

Similar Citations

Book Josep Chabàs; (2019)
Computational Astronomy in the Middle Ages: Sets of Astronomical Tables in Latin

Article Ilana Wartenberg; (2020)
A Non-Linear Transmission of Euclid's Elements in a Medieval Hebrew Calendrical Treatise

Article Bernard R. Goldstein; José Chabás; (2017)
The Astronomical Tables of Isaac ben Joseph Israeli of Toledo

Article Ana Laura Alonso Martín; Fernando Serrano Larráyoz; (2024)
"De la esleçión del ayre conveniente a la natura e hedat del sennor [...]": el aire en los consejos de salud de Estéfano de Sevilla destinados a Pedro (de Toledo), arzobispo de Sevilla (Ca. 1381)

Article Azucena Hernández; (2017)
Astrolabes for the King: The Astrolabe of Petrus Raimundi of Barcelona

Article Zammuli al-Tuhami; (2015)
Risalat al-Wadi Ashi wa-handasat al-qiyas bi-l-Andalus khilal al-qarnayn al-thalith "ashar wa l-rabi" "ashar al-miladiyayn"

Book Julio Samsó; (2020)
On Both Sides of the Strait of Gibraltar: Studies in the History of Medieval Astronomy in the Iberian Peninsula and the Maghrib

Article Chabás, José; (2012)
The Toledan Tables in Castilian: Excerpts of the Planetary Equations

Book Violet Moller; (2020)
The Map of Knowledge: A Thousand-Year History of How Classical Ideas Were Lost and Found

Chapter Fernando Valdés Fernández; (2019)
The Impact of the Arab Conquest on the Planning of the Iberian Cities: Toledo inside Walls

Chapter Matthias Maser; (2019)
Conquered Cities: Continuity and Transformation of Urban Structures in the Castilian “Reconquista” Territories (11th–14th Centuries)—Toledo and Seville

Book José Martínez Gázquez; (2016)
The Attitude of the Medieval Latin Translators Towards the Arabic Sciences

Article Baughman, Davis L.; (Winter 2007)
High Tech from the Dark Ages

Book Jufre García, Francesc Xavier; (2009)
El artificio de Juanelo Turriano para elevar agua al Alcázar de Toledo

Book Jean-Louis Bosc; (2016)
Montpellier et la Medecine Andalouse au Moyen Age

Article Eneko López Martínez de Marigorta; (2015)
Acuñaciones monetarias de al-Andalus en la primera mitad del siglo V/XI: fin de un modelo, consolidación de las emisiones regionales

Article Cabo-González, Ana M.; (2014)
The Study of the Evolution of Fruits Preservation Techniques in the Iberian Peninsula throughout the Agronomic Andalusian Works, their Roman Antecedents and Posterior Footprint in the Renaissance

Book Sarah Stroumsa; (2019)
Andalus and Sefarad : on philosophy and its history in Islamic Spain

Article Emilia Calvo; Montse Díaz-Fajardo; (2023)
The Tanbīh al-anām ῾alā mā yaḥduthu fī ayyām al-῾ām (Warning to humanity about what happens during the days of the year) by ῾Abdu᾽ l-Raḥmān al-Jādirī (777/1375–818/1416)

Chapter Rafael Ramón Guerrero; (2012)
De Bagdad a Córdoba. Sobre las fuentes de la lógica de Ibn Hazm

Authors & Contributors
Chabás, José
Cabo-González, Ana M.
Calvo, Emilia
Chabàs, Josep
Díaz-Fajardo, Montse
Goldstein, Bernard R.
Journals
Suhayl: Journal for the History of the Exact and Natural Sciences in Islamic Civilisation
al-Qanṭara
Aleph: Historical Studies in Science and Judaism
American Heritage of Invention and Technology
Arabic Sciences and Philosophy
Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology
Publishers
Brill
Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas
Anchor
Milenio
Princeton University Press
SISMEL edizioni del Galluzzo
Concepts
Arab/Islamic world, civilization and culture
Astronomy
Cross-cultural interaction; cultural influence
Transmission of texts
Translations
Tables; catalogs; lists
People
Euclid
Ptolemy, Claudius
al-Battānī, Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muḥammad ibn Jābir
al-Khwārizmī, Muḥammad ibn Mūsā
al-Zarqali, Abu Ishaq
Aristotle
Time Periods
Medieval
14th century
11th century
Renaissance
10th century
13th century
Places
Toledo (Spain)
Andalusia (Spain)
Spain
Europe
Castille (Spain)
Al-Andalus
Institutions
Université de Montpellier
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment