This paper analyses the buildings, spaces and interiors of Bangour Village public asylum for the insane, near Edinburgh, and compares these with an English asylum, Whalley, near Preston, of similar early-twentieth-century date. The village asylum, which developed from a European tradition of rendering the poor productive through ‘colonisation’, was more enthusiastically and completely adopted in Scotland than in England, perhaps due to differences in asylum culture within the two jurisdictions. ‘Liberty’ and ‘individuality’, in particular, were highly valued within Scottish asylum discourses, arguably shaping material provision for the insane poor from the scale of the buildings to the quality of the furnishings. The English example shows, by contrast, a greater concern with security and hygiene. These two differing interpretations show a degree of flexibility within the internationalized asylum model which is seldom recognized in the literature.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Sarah Ann Pinto;
(2018)
Lunatic Asylums in Colonial Bombay: Shackled Bodies, Unchained Minds
(/isis/citation/CBB126077328/)
Article
Gillian Allmond;
(2017)
The First Garden City? Environment and utopianism in an Edwardian institution for the insane poor
(/isis/citation/CBB768765059/)
Article
O'Connor, Maree;
(2015)
Mobilizing Clouston in the Colonies? General Paralysis of the Insane at the Auckland Mental Hospital, 1868--1899
(/isis/citation/CBB001551428/)
Book
Topp, Leslie Elizabeth;
Moran, James E.;
Andrews, Jonathan;
(2007)
Madness, Architecture and the Built Environment: Psychiatric Spaces in Historical Context
(/isis/citation/CBB000773995/)
Article
Cheryl McGeachan;
(2017)
‘The Head Carver’: Art Extraordinary and the Small Spaces of Asylum
(/isis/citation/CBB911123773/)
Article
Hutchison, Iain;
(2011)
Institutionalization of Mentally-Impaired Children in Scotland, c.1855--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB001232201/)
Article
Morrison, Hazel;
(2013)
Conversing with the Psychiatrist: Patient Narratives within Glasgow's Royal Asylum, 1921--1929
(/isis/citation/CBB001320813/)
Article
Ritter, Hans Jakob;
Roelcke, Volker;
(2005)
Psychiatric Genetics in Munich and Basel between 1925 and 1945: Programs - Practices - Comparative Arrangements
(/isis/citation/CBB000610607/)
Book
Jane Freebody;
(2023)
Work and Occupation in French and English Mental Hospitals, c.1918-1939
(/isis/citation/CBB236489700/)
Book
Leslie Topp;
(2017)
Freedom and the Cage: Modern Architecture and Psychiatry in Central Europe, 1890–1914
(/isis/citation/CBB565460951/)
Article
Lauren Farquharson;
(2017)
A ‘Scottish Poor Law of Lunacy’? Poor Law, Lunacy Law and Scotland’s parochial asylums
(/isis/citation/CBB713442536/)
Article
McCarthy, Angela;
(2012)
Connections and Divergences: Lunatic Asylums in New Zealand and the Homelands before 1910
(/isis/citation/CBB001200710/)
Book
Melling, Joseph;
Forsythe, Bill;
(2006)
The Politics of Madness: The State, Insanity and Society in England, 1845--1914
(/isis/citation/CBB000774000/)
Article
Wallis, Jennifer;
(2013)
The Bones of the Insane
(/isis/citation/CBB001320330/)
Article
Motlatsi Thabane;
(2021)
Public mental health care in colonial Lesotho: themes emerging from archival material, 1918–35
(/isis/citation/CBB263655708/)
Article
Egidio Priani;
(2017)
‘Shrouded in a dark fog’: comparison of the diagnosis of pellagra in Venice and general paralysis of the insane in the United Kingdom, 1840–1900
(/isis/citation/CBB044149316/)
Article
Magne Brekke Rabben;
Øyvind Thomassen;
(2019)
Humane treatment versus means of control: coercive measures in Norwegian high-security psychiatry, 1895–1978
(/isis/citation/CBB458667420/)
Article
Thalassis, Nafsika;
(2007)
Soldiers in Psychiatric Therapy: The Case of Northfield Military Hospital 1942--1946
(/isis/citation/CBB000772507/)
Thesis
Edington, Claire Ellen;
(2013)
Beyond the Asylum: Colonial Psychiatry in French Indochina, 1880--1940
(/isis/citation/CBB001567481/)
Book
Annie Bartlett;
(2016)
Secure Lives: The Meaning and Importance of Culture in Secure Hospital Care
(/isis/citation/CBB835568937/)
Be the first to comment!