Field Theory and Interdisciplinarity: History and Sociology in Germany and France during the Twentieth Century (2017)
Steinmetz, George (Author)
Comparative Studies in Society and History
Volume: 59
Issue: 2
Pages: 477-514
This article develops a theory of interdisciplinarity and examines relations between historians and sociologists in Germany and France over the course of the twentieth century, focusing in on several key moments of interdisciplinary activity. Interdisciplinary engagements are motivated by scholarly problems, field-specific interests and battles, and pressures and inducements coming from states, businesses, and scientific institutions. Analysis of the most productive moments of cross-disciplinary interaction suggests that they occur when disciplines are equal in power and when scholars are motivated by scholarly problems and disciplinary conflicts to move beyond their disciplines. More generative forms of interdisciplinarity are dialogic and processual, characterized by a fusion of perspectives; less productive forms are externally induced, involve asymmetrical partners, and are organized around division of disciplinary labor rather than an interpenetration of perspectives. The most productive interdisciplinary conjunctures result from serendipitous resonances and contingent synchronicities between subfields of semi-autonomous disciplines. It is thus impossible to produce the most fruitful forms of interdisciplinarity deliberately. The article examines three cases of symmetrical, processual interdisciplinarity involving sociology and history. Two of these cases were located in the French academic field, first between the wars, and then again after 1980. The other case of dialogic collaboration between historians and sociologists begins in Nazi Germany and continues after 1945 into the 1960s, leading to the formation of West German Historische Sozialwissenschaft. Examples of unbalanced interdisciplinarity include German “History-Sociology” during the Weimar Republic, in which sociologists’ opening to history was not reciprocated by professional historians and Historische Sozialwissenschaft after 1970.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Verdes-Leroux, Jeannine;
(2001)
Deconstructing Pierre Bourdieu: Against Sociological Terrorism from the Left
(/isis/citation/CBB000102151/)
Article
Mark D. Hersey;
Jeremy Vetter;
(2019)
Shared Ground: Between Environmental History and the History of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB491265753/)
Book
McCarthy, George E.;
(2001)
Objectivity and the silence of reason: Weber, Habermas, and the Methodological disputes in German Sociology
(/isis/citation/CBB000101784/)
Article
Kerstin Hofmann;
(2015)
(Post)Moderne Raumkonzepte und die Erforschung des Altertums
(/isis/citation/CBB835916334/)
Book
Gierl, Martin;
(2012)
Geschichte als präzisierte Wissenschaft: Johann Christoph Gatterer und die Historiographie des 18. Jahrhunderts im ganzen Umfang
(/isis/citation/CBB001214209/)
Chapter
Johannes F.K. Schmidt;
(2016)
Niklas Luhmann’s Card Index: Thinking Tool, Communication Partner, Publication Machine
(/isis/citation/CBB470964502/)
Book
Graham, John T.;
(2001)
The Social Thought of Ortega y Gasset: A Systematic Synthesis in Postmodernism and Interdisciplinarity
(/isis/citation/CBB000102299/)
Book
D'Lane Compton;
Tey Meadow;
Kristen Schilt;
(2018)
Other, Please Specify: Queer Methods in Sociology
(/isis/citation/CBB983630314/)
Article
Jim Berryman;
(2022)
Frederick Antal and the Marxist challenge to art history
(/isis/citation/CBB866460053/)
Book
Barriga Villanueva, Rebeca;
Martín Butragueño, Pedro;
(2010)
Historia sociolingüística de México
(/isis/citation/CBB001211997/)
Article
Godin, Benoît;
(2012)
“Innovation Studies”: The Invention of a Specialty
(/isis/citation/CBB001211966/)
Book
Lisa Paravan;
(2023)
Due culture? Riflessioni su multi-, inter- e trans- disciplinarità
(/isis/citation/CBB533163182/)
Article
Frijhoff, Willem;
(2013)
Honderd jaar universiteitsgeschiedenis in Nederland
(/isis/citation/CBB001321086/)
Thesis
Rotabi, Karen Smith;
(2005)
Theory Bridging between Sociology, Social Work and Ecology. DynamicInterchanges and Cross-Fertilizations: The Intellectual Legacy of the OdumFamily
(/isis/citation/CBB001561899/)
Book
Jason A. Josephson-Storm;
(2017)
The Myth of Disenchantment: Magic, Modernity, and the Birth of the Human Sciences
(/isis/citation/CBB538974745/)
Book
Edwards, David;
(2008)
Artscience: Creativity in the Post-Google Generation
(/isis/citation/CBB001020029/)
Article
Andrew Linklater;
(2023)
Religion and civilization in the sociology of Norbert Elias: Fantasy–reality balances in long-term perspective
(/isis/citation/CBB969460125/)
Chapter
Gerhardt, Uta;
Arnold, Alexia;
(2006)
Von Chicago nach Darmstadt. Das Verhältnis zwischen der Chicago-Soziologie und der Darmstadt-Studie. Zur Kontinuität und Diskontinuität der Gesellschaftskonzeption(en) im Blickfeld der Stadt-Land-Thematik
(/isis/citation/CBB000953818/)
Article
Marieke M. A. Hendriksen;
(2020)
Rethinking Performative Methods in the History of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB043624615/)
Article
FLORIAN BRUNS;
(2020)
Identität durch Geschichte - Building Identity through history: Zur Erinnerungskultur der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Geschichte der Medizin, Naturwissenschaft und Technik (DGGMNT) 1926–1951
(/isis/citation/CBB808649222/)
Be the first to comment!