From the Logic of Ideas to Active-Matter Materialism: Priestley’s Lockean Problem and Early Neurophilosophy (2020)
Empiricism is a claim about the contents of the mind: its classic slogan is nihil est in intellectu quod non fuerit in sensu, “there is nothing in the mind (intellect, understanding) which is not first in the senses.” As such, it is not a claim about the fundamental nature of the world as material. I focus here on in an instance of what one might term the materialist appropriation of empiricism. One major component in the transition from a purely epistemological claim about the mind and its contents to an ontological claim about the nature of the world is the new focus on brain–mind relations in the eighteenth century. Here I examine a Lockean trajectory as exemplified in Joseph Priestley’s 1777 Disquisitions Relating to Matter and Spirit. However, Locke explicitly ruled out that his inquiry into the logic of ideas amounted to a “physical consideration of the mind.” What does it mean, then, for Priestley to present himself as continuing a Lockean tradition, while presenting mental processes as tightly identified with “an organical structure such as that of the brain” (although he was not making a strict identity claim as we might understand it, post-Smart and Armstrong)? One issue here is that of Priestley’s source of “empirical data” regarding the correlation and indeed identification of mental and cerebral processes. David Hartley’s theory in his 1749 Observations on Man was, as is well known, republished in abridged form by Priestley, but he discards Hartley’s “vibratory neurophysiology” while retaining the associationist framework, although not because he disagreed with the former. Yet Hartley was, at the very least, strongly agnostic about metaphysical issues (and it is difficult to study these authors while bracketing off religious considerations). One could see Locke and Hartley as articulating programs for the study of the mind which were more or less naturalistic (more strongly so in Hartley’s case) while avoiding “materialism” per se; in contrast, Priestley bit the (materialist) bullet. In this paper I examine Priestley’s appropriation and reconstruction of this “micro-tradition,” while emphasizing its problems.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Sascha Salatowsky;
(2020)
Unitarian Materialism. Christoph Stegmann, Joseph Priestley, and Their Concepts of Matter and Soul
(/isis/citation/CBB006782432/)
Chapter
Dybikowski, James;
(2008)
Joseph Priestley, Metaphysician and Philosopher of Religion
(/isis/citation/CBB000760374/)
Article
Paola Rumore;
(2020)
Priestley in Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB683415681/)
Article
Charles T. Wolfe;
Falk Wunderlich;
(2020)
Joseph Priestley: Materialism and the Science of the Mind. Foundations, Controversies, Reception
(/isis/citation/CBB161350544/)
Article
Udo Thiel;
(2020)
Priestley and Kant on Materialism
(/isis/citation/CBB616453784/)
Book
Monod, Paul Kléber;
(2013)
Solomon's Secret Arts: The Occult in the Age of Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB001213599/)
Book
Thomson, Ann;
(2008)
Bodies of Thought: Science, Religion, and the Soul in the Early Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB000952069/)
Chapter
Taylor, Michael W.;
(2014)
Herbert Spencer and the Metaphysical Roots of Evolutionary Naturalism
(/isis/citation/CBB001202316/)
Article
Falk Wunderlich;
(2020)
Priestley on Materialism and the Essence of God
(/isis/citation/CBB064750676/)
Book
Amanda Jo Goldstein;
(2017)
Sweet Science: Romantic Materialism and the New Logics of Life
(/isis/citation/CBB350652099/)
Article
Falk Wunderlich;
(2016)
Materialism in Late Enlightenment Germany: A Neglected Tradition Reconsidered
(/isis/citation/CBB824246743/)
Book
J. R. Milton;
G. A. J. Rogers;
(2021)
John Locke: Drafts for the Essay Concerning Human Understanding: Volume II: Draft C
(/isis/citation/CBB488101486/)
Article
Peter R. Anstey;
(2016)
The Coherence of Cohesion in the Later Leibniz
(/isis/citation/CBB522015706/)
Book
Filippo Sani;
(2022)
La lettera critica sull’educazione di Charles-Marie de La Condamine
(/isis/citation/CBB871805894/)
Chapter
Domski, Mary;
(2012)
Locke's Qualified Embrace of Newton's Principia
(/isis/citation/CBB001500340/)
Chapter
Stephen Gaukroger;
(2014)
Empiricism as a Development of Experimental Natural Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB971325669/)
Book
Johnson, Steven;
(2008)
The Invention of Air: A Story of Science, Faith, Revolution, and the Birth of America
(/isis/citation/CBB000954683/)
Article
Sebastiano Gino;
(2020)
Scottish Common Sense, Association of Ideas and Free Will
(/isis/citation/CBB323976439/)
Article
Giuntini, Chiara;
(1985)
I poteri della natura e la scienza della mente: Joseph Priestley e Erasmus Darwin
(/isis/citation/CBB000058017/)
Article
Candida Carella;
(2013)
Fortunae lancisiane
(/isis/citation/CBB886269709/)
Be the first to comment!