In this paper, I examine Cicero's oft-neglected De Divinatione, a dialogue investigating the legitimacy of the practice of divination. First, I offer a novel analysis of the main arguments for divination given by Quintus, highlighting the fact that he employs two logically distinct argument forms. Next, I turn to the first of the main arguments against divination given by Marcus. Here I show, with the help of modern probabilistic tools, that Marcus' skeptical response is far from the decisive, proto-naturalistic assault on superstition that it is sometimes portrayed to be. Then, I offer an extended analysis of the second of the main arguments against divination given by Marcus. Inspired by Marcus' second main argument, I formulate, explicate, and defend a substantive principle of scientific methodology that I call the “Ciceronian Causal-Nomological Requirement” (CCR). Roughly, this principle states that causal knowledge is essential for relying on correlations in predictive inference. Although I go on to argue that Marcus' application of the CCR in his debate with Quintus is dialectically inadequate, I conclude that De Divinatione deserves its place in Cicero's philosophical corpus, and that ultimately, its significance for the history and philosophy of science ought to be recognized.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Chapter
Fantham, Elaine;
(2011)
More Sentiment than Science: Roman Stargazing before and after Manilius
(/isis/citation/CBB001201028/)
Chapter
Green, Steven J.;
(2011)
Arduum ad astra: The Poetics and Politics of Horoscopic Failure in Manilius' Astronomica
(/isis/citation/CBB001201031/)
Article
Andree Hahmann;
(2019)
Cicero Defining the Stoic Science of Divination
(/isis/citation/CBB152808236/)
Article
Acerbi, Fabio;
(2000)
Le fonti del mito platonico di Galileo
(/isis/citation/CBB000110292/)
Book
Koch-Westenholz, Ulla;
(2000)
Babylonian Liver Omens: The Chapters Manzazu, Padanu and Pan Takalti of the Babylonian Extispicy Series Mainly from Assurbanipal's Library
(/isis/citation/CBB000102172/)
Book
Beck, Roger;
(2007)
A Brief History of Ancient Astrology
(/isis/citation/CBB000773325/)
Article
Cullen, Christopher;
(2011)
Understanding the Planets in Ancient China: Prediction and Divination in the Wu xing zhan
(/isis/citation/CBB001034169/)
Article
Wynne, J. P. F.;
(2012)
God's Indifferents: Why Cicero's Stoic Jupiter Made the World
(/isis/citation/CBB001251238/)
Article
Cuomo, Serafina;
(2012)
Exploring Ancient Greek and Roman Numeracy
(/isis/citation/CBB001210323/)
Article
Asmis, Elizabeth;
(2008)
Cicero on Natural Law and the Laws of the State
(/isis/citation/CBB001035046/)
Book
Lehrich, Christopher I.;
(2007)
The Occult Mind: Magic in Theory and Practice
(/isis/citation/CBB000774186/)
Article
(2000)
Experiment and Conceptual Change: Evidence, Data Generation, and Scientific Practice: Toward a Reliabilist Philosophy of Experiment
(/isis/citation/CBB000110595/)
Book
Taper, Mark L.;
Lele, Subhash R.;
(2004)
The Nature of Scientific Evidence: Statistical, Philosophical, and Empirical Considerations
(/isis/citation/CBB000750947/)
Book
Bonk, Thomas;
(2008)
Underdetermination: An Essay on Evidence and the Limits of Natural Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB000951767/)
Book
Groff, Ruth;
(2004)
Critical Realism, Post-Positivism, and the Possibility of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB000401064/)
Book
Horstmanshoff, H. F. J.;
Stol, Marten;
Tilburg, C. R. van;
(2004)
Magic and Rationality in Ancient Near Eastern and Graeco-Roman Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB000651720/)
Article
Stefano Canali;
(2020)
Making evidential claims in epidemiology: Three strategies for the study of the exposome
(/isis/citation/CBB477913919/)
Book
Achinstein, Peter;
(2010)
Evidence, Explanation, and Realism: Essays in Philosophy of Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001023128/)
Chapter
Vanderburgh, William L.;
(2009)
Theory Choice in the Historical Sciences: Geology as a Philosophical Case Study
(/isis/citation/CBB001021052/)
Article
Gimbel, Steven;
(2004)
Restoring Ambiguity to Achinstein's Account of Evidence
(/isis/citation/CBB000410757/)
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences
Physis: Rivista Internazionale di Storia della Scienza
Philosophy of Science
Early Science and Medicine: A Journal for the Study of Science, Technology and Medicine in the Pre-modern Period
Classical Antiquity
Be the first to comment!