Procedures of Leibnizian infinitesimal calculus: an account in three modern frameworks (2021)
Bair, Jacques (Author)
Błaszczyk, Piotr (Author)
Ely, Robert (Author)
Katz, Mikhail G. (Author)
Kuhlemann, Karl (Author)
British Journal for the History of Mathematics
Volume: 36
Issue: 3
Pages: 170-209
Recent Leibniz scholarship has sought to gauge which foundational framework provides the most successful account of the procedures of the Leibnizian calculus (LC). While many scholars (e.g. Ishiguro, Levey) opt for a default Weierstrassian framework, Arthur compares LC to a non-Archimedean framework SIA (Smooth Infinitesimal Analysis) of Lawvere–Kock–Bell. We analyze Arthur's comparison and find it rife with equivocations and misunderstandings on issues including the non-punctiform nature of the continuum, infinite-sided polygons, and the fictionality of infinitesimals. Rabouin and Arthur claim that Leibniz considers infinities as contradictory, and that Leibniz' definition of incomparables should be understood as nominal rather than as semantic. However, such claims hinge upon a conflation of Leibnizian notions of bounded infinity and unbounded infinity, a distinction emphasized by early Knobloch. The most faithful account of LC is arguably provided by Robinson's framework for infinitesimal analysis. We exploit an axiomatic framework for infinitesimal analysis SPOT to formalize LC.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Arthur, Richard T. W.;
(2013)
Leibniz's Syncategorematic Infinitesimals
(/isis/citation/CBB001211764/)
Article
Katz, Mikhail G.;
Sherry, David M.;
(2012)
Leibniz's Laws of Continuity and Homogeneity
(/isis/citation/CBB001211734/)
Article
Sweeney, David John;
(2014)
Chunk and Permeate: The Infinitesimals of Isaac Newton
(/isis/citation/CBB001213925/)
Book
Davide Gullotto;
(2023)
La Repubblica dei Matematici. Storia dell’analisi matematica nell’età di Euler e Leibniz
(/isis/citation/CBB269641386/)
Book
Goldenbaum, Ursula;
Jesseph, Douglas;
(2008)
Infinitesimal Differences: Controversies between Leibniz and His Contemporaries
(/isis/citation/CBB000950297/)
Book
Cirino, Raffaele;
(2006)
Dal movimento alla forza: Leibniz, l'infinitesimo tra logica e metafisica
(/isis/citation/CBB000953010/)
Article
Oscar M. Esquisabel;
Federico Raffo Quintana;
(2021)
Fiction, possibility and impossibility: three kinds of mathematical fictions in Leibniz’s work
(/isis/citation/CBB813371353/)
Article
Alexander, Amir R.;
(2001)
Exploration Mathematics: The Rhetoric of Discovery and the Rise of Infinitesimal Methods
(/isis/citation/CBB000100520/)
Book
Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm;
Mayer, Uwe;
Probst, Siegmund;
Sefrin-Weis, Heike;
(2008)
Mathematische Schriften. Band 5: 1674-1676. Infinitesimalmathematik
(/isis/citation/CBB000951705/)
Article
Knobloch, Eberhard;
(2002)
Leibniz's Rigorous Foundation of Infinitesimal Geometry by Means of Riemannian Sums
(/isis/citation/CBB000300359/)
Article
David Rabouin;
Richard T. W. Arthur;
(2020)
Leibniz’s syncategorematic infinitesimals II: their existence, their use and their role in the justification of the differential calculus
(/isis/citation/CBB320925047/)
Book
Grabiner, Judith V.;
(2010)
A Historian Looks Back: The Calculus as Algebra and Selected Writings
(/isis/citation/CBB001033182/)
Article
Magnani, Lorenzo;
Dossena, Riccardo;
(2005)
Perceiving the Infinite and the Infinitesimal World: Unveiling and Optical Diagrams in Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB000640123/)
Article
Scott Edgar;
(2020)
Hermann Cohen’s Principle of the Infinitesimal Method: A Defense
(/isis/citation/CBB672281990/)
Article
Michael Raugh;
Siegmund Probst;
(2019)
The Leibniz Catenary and Approximation of e — an Analysis of His Unpublished Calculations
(/isis/citation/CBB083430421/)
Article
Sun, Xiao-li;
(2006)
Leibniz and the debate of inventor's right of calculus
(/isis/citation/CBB000780273/)
Article
Parmentier, Marc;
(2001)
Démonstration et infiniment petits dans la Quadratura arithmetica de Leibniz
(/isis/citation/CBB000770921/)
Article
Blåsjö, Viktor;
(2012)
The Rectification of Quadratures as a Central Foundational Problem for the Early Leibnizian Calculus
(/isis/citation/CBB001251213/)
Book
Wardhaugh, Benjamin;
(2012)
The History of the History of Mathematics: Case Studies for the Seventeenth, Eighteenth, and Nineteenth Centuries
(/isis/citation/CBB001251196/)
Chapter
Serfati, Michel;
(2008)
Symbolic Inventiveness and “Irrationalist” Practices in Leibniz's Mathematics
(/isis/citation/CBB001023822/)
Be the first to comment!