This essay uses the case of the fin-de-siècle Vienna embryologist Samuel Leopold Schenk to analyze the factors at play in allegations of misconduct. In 1898, Schenk published a book titled Theorie Schenk. Einfluss auf das Geschlechtsverhältnis (Schenk’s theory. Influence on the sex ratio). The book argued that, by changing their diet, women trying to conceive could influence egg maturation and consequently select the sex of their offspring. This cross between a scientific monograph and a popular advice book received enormous publicity but also spurred first the Vienna Medical Association and then the Senate of the University of Vienna to accuse Schenk of poor science, self-advertisement, quack medical practice, and wrong publisher choice. Formal proceedings against Schenk ended in 1900 with the unusually harsh punishment of early retirement. Schenk died two years later. I examine the elements of the case, from the science of sex determination and selection, to the growth of print media and advertising within the changing demographic and political landscape of Vienna. I argue that the influence of the public, via the growing media, upon science was the main driver of the case against Schenk, but also that the case would have had a more limited impact were it not for the volatile political moment rife with anti-Semitism, nationalism, and xenophobia. I draw the attention to the importance of setting cases of misconduct in the broader political history and against the key social concerns of the moment.
...More
Article
González-Silva, Matiana;
Herran, Néstor;
(2009)
Ideology, Elitism and Social Commitment: Alternative Images of Science in Two fin de siècle Barcelona Newspapers
(/isis/citation/CBB000932326/)
Article
Bryan E. Denham;
(2021)
Determinants of Attitudes Toward the Scientific Community: Confidence in the Press as a Mediator of Political Party Affiliation
(/isis/citation/CBB703347730/)
Article
Watson, Lindsay R.;
(2013)
Tom Tiddler's Ground: Irregular Medical Practitioners and Male Sexual Problems in New Zealand, 1858--1908
(/isis/citation/CBB001320602/)
Book
Eugenia Tognotti;
(2020)
Vaccinare i bambini tra obbligo e persuasione: Tre secoli di controversie. Il caso dell'Italia
(/isis/citation/CBB142911314/)
Article
Almeida, Maria Antónia Pires de;
(2012)
The Portuguese cholera morbus Epidemic of 1853--56 as Seen by the Press
(/isis/citation/CBB001220430/)
Article
Liv Grjebine;
(2022)
A Darwinian Murder: The Role of the Barré-Lebiez Affair in the Diffusion of Darwinism in Nineteenth-Century France
(/isis/citation/CBB374593926/)
Article
Prüll, Cay-Rüdiger;
(2010)
Ärzte, Journalisten und Patienten als Akteure von Teilöffentlichkeiten in Westdeutschland. Eine Analyse am Beispiel des Nachrichtenmagazins “Der Spiegel” (1947--1955)
(/isis/citation/CBB001220584/)
Article
Ren, Jie;
Peters, Hans Peter;
Allgaier, Joachim;
Lo, Yin-Yueh;
(2014)
Similar Challenges but Different Responses: Media Coverage of Measles Vaccination in the UK and China
(/isis/citation/CBB001420070/)
Thesis
Stein, Melissa Norelle;
(2008)
Embodying Race: Gender, Sex, and the Sciences of Difference, 1830--1934
(/isis/citation/CBB001561139/)
Book
Goschler, Constantin;
(2000)
Wissenschaft und Öffentlichkeit in Berlin, 1870-1930
(/isis/citation/CBB000110622/)
Article
Mukherjee, Sumita;
(2013)
“A Warning against Quack Doctors”: The Old Bailey Trial of Indian Oculists, 1893
(/isis/citation/CBB001213106/)
Book
Coen, Deborah R.;
(2007)
Vienna in the Age of Uncertainty: Science, Liberalism, and Private Life
(/isis/citation/CBB000741787/)
Article
Brewer, Paul R.;
Ley, Barbara L.;
(2011)
Multiple Exposures: Scientific Controversy, the Media, and Public Responses to Bisphenol A
(/isis/citation/CBB001320111/)
Article
Jaspal, Rusi;
Nerlich, Brigitte;
(2014)
Fracking in the UK Press: Threat Dynamics in an Unfolding Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB001420067/)
Book
Massimiano Bucchi;
Luca Ciancio;
Ariane Dröscher;
(2015)
L'esperimento della storia. Saggi in onore di Renato G. Mazzolini
(/isis/citation/CBB236977309/)
Article
Catherine Paradeise;
Ghislaine Filliatreau;
(2021)
Scientific Integrity Matters
(/isis/citation/CBB481223880/)
Book
Mitchell G. Ash;
(2020)
Science in the Metropolis: Vienna in Transnational Context, 1848–1918
(/isis/citation/CBB624112125/)
Book
Stefano Ossicini;
(2019)
L’inganno di Mesmer e la commissione Franklin-Lavoisier: Come la scienza ha imparato ad affrontare le controversie pubbliche
(/isis/citation/CBB285174381/)
Book
Staffan Muller-Wille;
Christina Brandt;
(2016)
Heredity Explored: Between Public Domain and Experimental Science, 1850-1930
(/isis/citation/CBB515030106/)
Article
Verhoeven, Piet;
(2008)
Where Has the Doctor Gone? The Mediazation of Medicine on Dutch Television, 1961--2000
(/isis/citation/CBB000932277/)
Be the first to comment!