Health policy counterpublics: Enacting collective resistances to US molecular HIV surveillance and cluster detection and response programs (2024)
Stephen Molldrem (Author)
Anthony K J Smith (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 54
Issue: 3
Pages: 451-477
Health policies and the problems they constitute are deeply shaped by multiple publics. In this article we conceptualize health policy counterpublics: temporally bounded socio-political forms that aim to cultivate particular modes of conduct, generally to resist trajectories set by arms of the state. These counterpublics often emerge from existing social movements and involve varied forms of activism and advocacy. We examine a health policy counterpublic that has arisen in response to new forms of HIV public health surveillance by drawing on public documents and interview data from 2021 with 26 stakeholders who were critical of key policy developments. Since 2018, the national rollout of molecular HIV surveillance (MHS) and cluster detection and response (CDR) programs in the United States has produced sustained controversies among HIV stakeholders, including among organized networks of people living with HIV. This article focuses on how a health policy counterpublic formed around MHS/CDR and how constituents problematized the policy agenda set in motion by federal health agencies, including in relation to data ethics, the meaningful involvement of affected communities, informed consent, the digitization of health systems, and HIV criminalization. Although familiar problems in HIV policymaking, concerns about these issues have been reconfigured in response to the new sociotechnical milieu proffered by MHS/CDR, generating new critical positions aiming to remake public health. Critical attention to the scenes within which health policy controversies play out ought to consider how (counter)publics are made, how problems are constituted, and the broader social movement dynamics and activist resources drawn upon to contest and reimagine policymaking in public life.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Eun-Sung Kim;
(June 2016)
The sensory power of cameras and noise meters for protest surveillance in South Korea
(/isis/citation/CBB108699540/)
Article
Cheryl Higashida;
(2022)
Citizens Band: Surveillance, Dark Sousveillance, and Social Movements
(/isis/citation/CBB195380767/)
Article
Janet Weston;
Virginia Berridge;
(2020)
AIDS Inside and Out: HIV/AIDS and Penal Policy in Ireland and England & Wales in the 1980s and 1990s
(/isis/citation/CBB869671221/)
Book
Alexander Dunst;
(2016)
Madness in Cold War America
(/isis/citation/CBB039375782/)
Book
Carl F. Ameringer;
(2018)
US Health Policy and Health Care Delivery: Doctors, Reformers, and Entrepreneurs
(/isis/citation/CBB462281281/)
Article
Carla Keirns;
(2023)
History of Health Policy: Explaining Complexity through Time
(/isis/citation/CBB284349807/)
Book
Jonathan Engel;
(2018)
Unaffordable: American Healthcare from Johnson to Trump
(/isis/citation/CBB064961709/)
Article
Dishman, Eric;
(Spring 2019)
Supporting Precision Aging: Engineering Health and Lifespan Planning for All of Us
(/isis/citation/CBB071431083/)
Book
Nattrass, Nicoli;
(2012)
The AIDS Conspiracy: Science Fights Back
(/isis/citation/CBB001252724/)
Article
Tasleem J Padamsee;
(2020)
Fighting an Epidemic in Political Context: Thirty-Five Years of HIV/AIDS Policy Making in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB175960205/)
Article
Petty, JuLeigh;
Heimer, Carol A.;
(2011)
Extending the rails: How research reshapes clinics
(/isis/citation/CBB060848255/)
Book
Ana Muñiz;
(2022)
Borderland Circuitry: Immigration Surveillance in the United States and Beyond
(/isis/citation/CBB304288480/)
Chapter
Jeremy Milloy;
(2021)
Chapter 7. High Priority: Business's War on Drugs and the Expansion of Surveillance in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB834799320/)
Book
Mary F. E. Ebeling;
(2022)
Afterlives of Data: Life and Debt under Capitalist Surveillance
(/isis/citation/CBB663965321/)
Article
Philip Olson;
Christine Labuski;
(August 2018)
‘There’s always a [white] man in the loop’: The gendered and racialized politics of civilian drones
(/isis/citation/CBB568832607/)
Article
Rebecca J. Hester;
(2020)
Bioveillance: A Techno-security Infrastructure to Preempt the Dangers of Informationalised Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB548068287/)
Article
Whitney, Kristoffer;
(2014)
Domesticating Nature? Surveillance and Conservation of Migratory Shorebirds in the “Atlantic Flyway”
(/isis/citation/CBB001420087/)
Book
Brian Hochman;
(2022)
The Listeners: A History of Wiretapping in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB775086796/)
Thesis
Kim, Richard S.Y.;
(2010)
Cyber-Surveillance: A Case Study in Policy and Development
(/isis/citation/CBB001567169/)
Book
Iván Chaar López;
(2024)
The Cybernetic Border: Drones, Technology, and Intrusion
(/isis/citation/CBB407005585/)
Be the first to comment!