Thesis ID: CBB005507248

Laboratories of Consent: Vaccine Science in the Spanish Atlantic World, 1779-1840 (2020)


This dissertation examines the colonial history of medical rights in Latin America through a study of the world’s first vaccine. The Spanish introduced the smallpox vaccine to their empire in 1804, along with royal orders that vaccination be voluntary and medical consent a natural right ceded to parents. Yet, the vaccine first arrived there incubated in the bodies of two enslaved girls. Doctors would continue to rely on enslaved, indigenous, and other dispossessed bodies to conserve the vaccine for those otherwise accorded this ostensibly universal right. Their doing so prompted profound questions about individual liberty, embedding vaccination into struggles over the abolition of slavery, parental rights, and the preservation of colonial rule. By analyzing the politicization of preventative health, the dissertation follows the vaccine through the Spanish Caribbean and Mexico to ask why imperial—and later, national—authorities protected voluntary vaccination, what this choice meant for parents and patients, and what this story can tell us about the meaning and value of consent in an era of both race and rights-making. To understand how consent operated, I trace the vaccine through the bodies that sustained it, examining the gendered and racialized claims to medical authority that legitimized the vaccine, the state’s patriarchal formulation of consent to it, and the responses and rejections of colonized subjects to both. Medical texts, newspapers, legal codes, orphanage records, plantation guides, and government reports related to the vaccine reveal that recognition of medical rights was inconsistent and often determined by elite assumptions about reason and bodily difference. Racial and sexual politics informed decisions about which bodies were best suited to incubate and test the vaccine, whose knowledge was deemed a threat to public health campaigns, and ultimately, who should be recognized as a parent, worthy of rights and capable of informed consent. Amidst political and social unrest, I argue that these articulations worked to uphold colonial structures of power, as healthcare became woven into the fractional freedoms accorded to and claimed by subjects and citizens. Medical consent, as it was envisioned and employed in vaccination policies, helped to reinforce these hierarchies even after independence. Mexico retained voluntary vaccination, but the medical rights of women and men, particularly those of indigenous and African descent, remained restricted by assumptions about culture and competence. By tracing the vaccine through the postcolonial era, my project addresses the enduring effects of colonialism across political discourses of liberalism and access to resources and care. Such historicization suggests the limits of consent and prompts a more ethical conceptualization of "informed refusal" that embraces and respects indigenous and other cultural articulations of bodily autonomy.

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Book Cañizares-Esguerra, Jorge; (2006)
Nature, Empire, and Nation: Explorations of the History of Science in the Iberian World (/isis/citation/CBB000741903/) unapi

Article Mark, Catherine; Rigau-Pérez, José G.; (2009)
The World's First Immunization Campaign: The Spanish Smallpox Vaccine Expedition, 1803--1813 (/isis/citation/CBB000932121/) unapi

Book MacLeod, Roy; (2000)
Nature and Empire: Science and the Colonial Enterprise (/isis/citation/CBB000110572/) unapi

Chapter Cristina Munno; (2018)
La lotta al vaiolo e le pratiche antivaiolose nel Settecento e nell’Ottocento veneto (/isis/citation/CBB610612636/) unapi

Chapter Irina Podgorny; (2021)
Change and Continuity: The Bureaucracy of Knowledge in South America (/isis/citation/CBB085445692/) unapi

Book Bleichmar, Daniela; (2012)
Visible Empire: Botanical Expeditions and Visual Culture in the Hispanic Enlightenment (/isis/citation/CBB001212583/) unapi

Chapter Velamazán Gimeno, María Angeles; (2011)
Ciencia y milicia entre dos siglos (/isis/citation/CBB001221491/) unapi

Book Cowie, Helen; (2011)
Conquering Nature in Spain and Its Empire, 1750--1850 (/isis/citation/CBB001251392/) unapi

Book Michael J. Bennett; (2020)
The War Against Smallpox: Edward Jenner and the Global Spread of Vaccination (/isis/citation/CBB765954016/) unapi

Book Jones, Greta; Malcolm, Elizabeth; (1999)
Medicine, disease, and the State in Ireland, 1650-1940 (/isis/citation/CBB000110599/) unapi

Article Sebastián Molina-Betancur; (2019)
José Celestino Mutis and the Defence of the Copernican system in the Viceroyalty of New Granada (/isis/citation/CBB797544385/) unapi

Chapter Stefanie Gänger; (2021)
The Secrets of Indians: Native Knowers in Enlightenment Natural Histories of the Southern Americas (/isis/citation/CBB027840169/) unapi

Book Silva, Ignacio Alberto; (2014)
Latin American Perspectives on Science and Religion (/isis/citation/CBB001422634/) unapi

Book Eugenia Tognotti; (2020)
Vaccinare i bambini tra obbligo e persuasione: Tre secoli di controversie. Il caso dell'Italia (/isis/citation/CBB142911314/) unapi

Book Cristina Munno; Elena Iorio; (2018)
Vaccini e paure. Salute pubblica, resistenze popolari (/isis/citation/CBB068311554/) unapi

Authors & Contributors
MacLeod, Roy M.
Podgorny, Irina
Jones, Greta
Malcolm, Elizabeth
Munno, Cristina
Iorio, Elena
Bulletin of the History of Medicine
British Journal for the History of Science
Eighteenth Century: Theory and Interpretation
Galilæana: Journal of Galilean Studies
Cierre edizioni
Univ. Chicago Press
International Specialized Book Services
Muñoz Moya Editores Extremeños
Stanford University Press
Spain, colonies
Vaccines; vaccination
Medicine and society
Wilde, Robert Willis
Delhuyar, Juan José
Río, Andrés Manuel del
Ulloa, Antonio de
Delhuyar, Fausto
Balmis, Francisco Xavier de
Latin America
19th century
18th century
17th century
20th century
21st century
16th century
Royal Belfast Academical Institution
Catholic University of Ireland (Dublin)
Jesuits (Society of Jesus)

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment