Article ID: CBB005462295

Reconstructing Thomist Astrology: Robert Bellarmine and the Papal Bull coeli et terrae (2020)

unapi

Historians have portrayed the papal bull Coeli et terrae (1586) as a significant turning point in the history of the Catholic Church’s censorship of astrology. They argue that this bull was intended to prohibit the idea that the stars could naturally incline humans towards future actions, but also had the effect of preventing the discussion of other forms of natural astrology including those useful to medicine, agriculture, and navigation. The bull, therefore, threatened to overturn principles established by Thomas Aquinas, which not only justified long-standing astrological practices, but also informed the Roman Inquisition’s attitude towards this art. The promulgation of the bull has been attributed to the ‘rigour’ of the incumbent pope, Sixtus V. In this article I revise our understanding of this bull in two ways. First, I reconsider the Inquisition’s attitude towards astrology in the mid-sixteenth century, arguing that its members promoted a limited form of Thomist astrology that did not permit the doctrine of inclination. Second, using Robert Bellarmine’s unpublished lectures discussing Aquinas’s views of astrology, I suggest that this attitude was common during the sixteenth century, and may have been caused by the crisis of Renaissance astrology precipitated by the work of Giovanni Pico.

...More
Included in

Article Francisco Malta Romeiras (2020) The Inquisition and the Censorship of Science in Early Modern Europe: Introduction. Annals of Science: The History of Science and Technology (pp. 1-9). unapi

Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB005462295/

Similar Citations

Article Francisco Malta Romeiras; (2020)
Putting the Indices into Practice: Censoring Science in Early Modern Portugal (/isis/citation/CBB223674544/)

Article Luís Campos Ribeiro; (2020)
The Bounded Heavens: Defining the Limits of Astrological Practice in the Iberian Indices (/isis/citation/CBB478312733/)

Article Tarrant, Neil; (2014)
Censoring Science in Sixteenth-Century Italy: Recent (and Not-So-Recent) Research (/isis/citation/CBB001420237/)

Book Fragnito, Gigliola; (2001)
Church, Censorship, and Culture in Early Modern Italy (/isis/citation/CBB000100783/)

Book Clizia Carminati; (2008)
Giovan Battista Marino tra inquisizione e censura (/isis/citation/CBB099790160/)

Article Helena Avelar de Carvalho; (2020)
Preludes to the Inquisition: Self-Censorship in Medieval Astrological Discourse (/isis/citation/CBB950440979/)

Article Poppi, Antonino; (2003)
On Trial for Astral Fatalism: Galileo Faces the Inquistion (/isis/citation/CBB000411074/)

Article Peter Andersen; (2014)
De la devise de Bruno à la mort de Tycho Brahe (/isis/citation/CBB757868142/)

Article Leen Spruit; (2016)
Roman Censorship of Science and Natural Philosophy: 16th–17th Centuries (/isis/citation/CBB513454885/)

Article Michel-Pierre Lerner; (2004)
Copernic suspendu et corrigé : sur deux décrets de la Congrégation romaine de l'Index, 1616-1620 (/isis/citation/CBB583560633/)

Article Tayra M. C. Lanuza-Navarro; (2017)
Astrology in Court: The Spanish Inquisition, Authority, and Expertise (/isis/citation/CBB916769431/)

Book Dougherty, M. V.; (2007)
Pico della Mirandola: New Essays (/isis/citation/CBB000830114/)

Chapter Franco Bacchelli; (2012)
Appunti sulla prima fortuna basileese e francese dello "Zodiacus vitae" del Palingenio (/isis/citation/CBB655068651/)

Article Pietro Redondi; (2004)
Fede lincea e teologia tridentina (/isis/citation/CBB841483681/)

Article Vincenzo Lavenia; (2004)
"Contes des bonnes femmes". La medicina legale italiana, Naudé e la stregoneria (/isis/citation/CBB607439909/)

Essay Review Roberta Ferro; (2010)
Novità dagli archivi: Marino e l'Inquisizione (/isis/citation/CBB795941908/)

Article Harries, Karsten; (2004)
Truth and Value Today: Galileo contra Bellarmine (/isis/citation/CBB000500058/)

Authors & Contributors
Tarrant, Neil
Spruit, Leen
Clizia Carminati
Carvalho, Helena Avelar de
Lavenia, Vincenzo
Roberta Ferro
Concepts
Inquisitions
Censorship
Science and religion
Roman Catholic Church
Astrology
Natural philosophy
Time Periods
17th century
16th century
Renaissance
Early modern
Medieval
18th century
Places
Italy
Europe
Spain
Portugal
France
Denmark
Institutions
Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei (Rome)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment