Throughout the late 1840s and the early 1850s, Harvard botanist Asa Gray (1810–1888) and his close friend George Engelmann (1809–1884) of St. Louis engaged themselves with recruiting men who sought to make a living by natural history collecting, sending these men into the field, searching for institutions and individuals who would subscribe to incoming collections, compiling catalogs, and collecting subscription fees. Although several botanists have noted Gray and Engelmann’s bold experiment as having introduced America to a mode by which European naturalists had devised to organize scientific expeditions, historians of science have not taken the “subscription mode” seriously. I argue that it was specifically by undertaking the labor of cataloging species and charging subscription fees for the cataloged species that Gray established himself as a metropolitan botanist. One crucial consequence of Gray’s rising profile was that he acquired sufficient “cataloging power” to secure his status as an authoritative cataloger of species, and as a kind of “mint” or “storehouse” (McOuat in Br J Hist Sci 34(1):1–28, 2001a) who produced well-pruned lists of American species to enable transactions between American and European botanists. But this essay is not focused on the Europeanization of American taxonomy. Drawing on work by scholars who place emphasis on how new forms of knowledge get produced when knowledge travels, my focus here is the evolution of the subscription mode when Gray and Engelmann adapted it to American natural history. My conclusion examines what historian of science Vanessa Heggie (Isis 105(2):318–334, 2014) identifies as the “danger of category dominance” in today’s historiography of science and shows how a kind of “assemblage thinking” may help historians cope with this danger.
...More
Article
Lucas, A. M.;
Lucas, P. J.;
(2014)
Natural History “Collectors”: Exploring the Ambiguities
(/isis/citation/CBB001321122/)
Article
Parsons, Christopher M.;
Murphy, Kathleen S.;
(2012)
Ecosystems under Sail: Specimen Transport in the Eighteenth-Century French and British Atlantics
(/isis/citation/CBB001200577/)
Article
Philip Stone;
(2020)
Robert McCormick's geological collections from Antarctica and the Southern Ocean, 1839–1843
(/isis/citation/CBB979398368/)
Article
Adelman, Juliana;
(2012)
An Insight into Commercial Natural History: Richard Glennon, William Hinchy and the Nineteenth-Century Trade in Giant Irish Deer Remains
(/isis/citation/CBB001220853/)
Book
Robert McCracken Peck;
Rosamond Purcell;
(2018)
Specimens of Hair: The Curious Collection of Peter A. Browne
(/isis/citation/CBB864486797/)
Article
Gaetano Pazienza;
Luigi Forte;
Viviana Cavallaro;
(2023)
Alfonso Palanza (1851–1899): A late nineteenth-century Italian botanist and his herbaria
(/isis/citation/CBB965460692/)
Article
Simon Ville;
Claire Wright;
Jude Philp;
(2020)
Macleay’s Choice: Transacting the Natural History Trade in the Nineteenth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB456527142/)
Article
Laubacher, Matthew;
(2012)
Fullerton Baird and Specimen Collection in the Hudson's Bay Territory
(/isis/citation/CBB001210161/)
Article
Grouw, H. Van;
Bloch, D.;
(2015)
History of the Extant Museum Specimens of the Faroese White-Speckled Raven
(/isis/citation/CBB001500435/)
Article
Dominik Hünniger;
(2021)
Visible Labour? Productive Forces and Imaginaries of Participation in European Insect Studies, ca. 1680–1810
(/isis/citation/CBB509322382/)
Chapter
Sanders, Dawn;
(2011)
The Death and Life of the Plant Specimen
(/isis/citation/CBB001024419/)
Article
Samuel Gicquel;
(2019)
Hector Léveillé, missionnaire et botaniste (1863-1918)
(/isis/citation/CBB223429106/)
Book
Newell, Jennifer;
(2010)
Trading Nature: Tahitians, Europeans, and Ecological Exchange
(/isis/citation/CBB001230901/)
Book
Nisbet, Jack;
(2009)
The Collector: David Douglas and the Natural History of the Northwest
(/isis/citation/CBB001210333/)
Book
Ellis, Elizabeth;
(2010)
Rare and Curious: The Secret History of Governor Macquarie's Collectors' Chest
(/isis/citation/CBB001033605/)
Article
Bregman, Leigh Davin;
(2006)
“For Sale”: Botanists and the Commercial Trade in Botanical Specimens at the Cape of Good Hope, 1750-1850
(/isis/citation/CBB000771791/)
Book
Morton-Evans, Christine;
Morton-Evans, Michael;
(2009)
The Flower Hunter: The Remarkable Life of Ellis Rowan
(/isis/citation/CBB001033609/)
Article
Cicuzza, Daniele;
(2014)
A Rediscovery of Alfred Russel Wallace's Fern Collection from Borneo at the Cambridge University Herbarium
(/isis/citation/CBB001421534/)
Article
Noltie, H. J.;
(2011)
A Botanical Group in Lahore, 1864
(/isis/citation/CBB001230618/)
Article
Beckman, Jenny;
(2011)
Collecting Standards: Teaching Botanical Skills in Sweden, 1850--1950
(/isis/citation/CBB001034616/)
Be the first to comment!