In his 1785-review of the Ideen zur Philosophie der Geschichte der Menschheit, Kant objects to Herder's conception of nature as being imbued with active forces. This attack is usually evaluated against the background of Kant's critical project and his epistemological concern to caution against the “metaphysical excess” of attributing immanent properties to matter. In this paper I explore a slightly different reading by investigating Kant's pre-critical account of creation and generation. The aim of this is to show that Kant's struggle with the forces of matter has a long history and revolves around one central problem: that of how to distinguish between the non-purposive forces of nature and the intentional powers of the mind. Given this history, the epistemic stricture that Kant's critical project imposes on him no longer appears to be the primary reason for his attack on Herder. It merely aggravates a problem that Kant has been battling with since his earliest writings.
...MoreArticle Gaukroger, Stephen W.; Dalia Nassar (2016) Introduction: Kant and the Empirical Sciences. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (pp. 55-56).
Similar Citations
Thesis
Carlos Zorrilla Piña;
(2021)
Back to the Darkest of All Things: Philosophical Lessons on the Dynamics of Matter and Ground, from Leibniz to Schelling
Book
Mensch, Jennifer;
(2013)
Kant's Organicism: Epigenesis and the Development of Critical Philosophy
Article
Andrew Cooper;
(2019)
Living natural products in Kant's physical geography
Article
Michael Bennett McNulty;
(2022)
A science for gods, a science for humans: Kant on teleological speculations in natural history
Article
Daniela Helbig;
Dalia Nassar;
(2016)
The Metaphor of Epigenesis: Kant, Blumenbach and Herder
Article
Zeuch, Ulrike;
(1998)
Sentio, ergo sum: Herder's concept of “feeling” versus Kant's concept of “consciousness”
Article
Zammito, John H.;
(1998)
“Method” versus “Manner”? Kant's critique of Herder's Ideen in the light of the epoch of science, 1790-1820
Chapter
Da Costa Gomes, Paolo Cesar;
(1997)
Les deux pôles épistémologiques de la modernité: Une lecture des fondements de la géographie chez Kant et Herder
Book
Zammito, John H.;
(2002)
Kant, Herder, and the Birth of Anthropology
Article
Niezen, Ronald;
(2009)
The Aufklärung's Human Discipline: Comparative Anthropology According to Kant, Herder and Wilhelm von Humboldt
Chapter
Watkins, Eric;
(2001)
Kant on Extension and Force: Critical Appropriations of Leibniz and Newton
Article
John H. Eddy;
(2023)
Buffon, Species and the Forces of Reproduction
Article
Daniel Garber;
(2019)
La dynamique de Leibniz est-elle compatible avec sa monadologie ?
Chapter
Garber, Daniel;
(2012)
Leibniz, Newton and Force
Book
Michael Punter;
(2024)
The Mysterious and the Occult from Newton to the Victorians: Strange Powers
Book
(1994)
Philosophie des Organischen in der Goethezeit: Studien zu Werk und Wirkung des Naturforschers Carl Friedrich Kielmeyer (1765-1844)
Article
Riedel, Manfred;
(1980)
Historizismus und Kritizismus: Kants Streit mit G. Forster und J. G. Herder
Article
Pross, Wolfgang;
(1997)
“Ein Reich unsichtbarer Kräfte”: Was kritisiert Kant an Herder?
Book
Brain, Robert Michael;
Cohen, R. S.;
Knudsen, Ole;
(2007)
Hans Christian Ørsted and the Romantic Legacy in Science: Ideas, Disciplines, Practices
Article
van Groesen, Michiel;
(2011-12)
America Abridged: Matthaeus Merian, Johann Ludwig Gottfried, and the Apotheosis of the De Bry Collection of Voyages
Be the first to comment!