Ethical questions arising from Otfrid Foerster’s use of the Sherrington method to map human dermatomes (2022)
Freeman, Brian (Author)
Carmody, John (Author)
Grace, Damian (Author)
Journal of the History of the Neurosciences
Volume: 31
Issue: 4
Pages: 490-511
Otfrid Foerster (1873–1941) is well known for his maps of human dermatomes. We have examined the history of the development of his protocols for mapping dermatomes by analyzing his lectures and publications from 1908 to 1939, focusing on his Schorstein Memorial Lecture in 1932 and his use of the isolation (Sherrington) method, in which a single dorsal root is spared in a sequence of resections (dorsal rhizotomies). Because of the absence of medical records for Foerster’s patients, we also review eyewitness accounts of his operating technique, his occasional comments on patients, and the issue of consent. There appears to be no medical justification—at that time or currently—for Foerster’s use of the Sherrington method to map dermatomes L1, L5, S1, and S2, and in our view, these results were obtained unethically. Hence, clinicians and researchers who use his maps should acknowledge those whom Foerster exploited in order to produce them.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Czech, Herwig;
Zeidman, Lawrence A.;
(2014)
Walther Birkmayer, Co-describer of L-Dopa, and His Nazi Connections: Victim or Perpetrator?
(/isis/citation/CBB001420781/)
Thesis
Anna Wexler;
(2017)
Sparking Controversy: The Contested Use of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation
(/isis/citation/CBB716280426/)
Article
Douglas J. Lanska;
(2019)
The Development and Evolution of “Cerebral Thermometry”: Clinical Applications of a Nineteenth-Century Approach to Cerebral Localization and Neurological Diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB397620744/)
Book
Kurt Goldstein;
(2012)
Der Aufbau des Organismus: Einführung in die Biologie unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Erfahrungen am kranken Menschen
(/isis/citation/CBB836984519/)
Article
Fabian-Alexander Tietze;
Marcin Orzechowski;
Moritz E. Wigand;
Florian Steger;
(2022)
Historical forerunners of neuropsychiatry: The psychiatric works of Albert W. Adamkiewicz (1850–1921)
(/isis/citation/CBB297040510/)
Article
Douglas J. Lanska;
(2019)
The Development and Evolution of “Cerebral Thermometry”: The Physiology Underlying a Nineteenth-Century Approach to Cerebral Localization and Neurological Diagnosis
(/isis/citation/CBB416833074/)
Book
Jean Clair;
(2018)
Freud: Du regard à l'écoute
(/isis/citation/CBB516323128/)
Book
Larry Sommer McGrath;
(2020)
Making Spirit Matter: Neurology, Psychology, and Selfhood in Modern France
(/isis/citation/CBB587674117/)
Book
Scott, Ann;
Eadie, Mervyn J.;
Lees, Andrew;
(2012)
William Richard Gowers 1845--1915: Exploring the Victorian Brain: A Biography
(/isis/citation/CBB001214599/)
Article
Michael Swash;
(2015)
John Hughlings Jackson (1835–1911): An Adornment to the London Hospital
(/isis/citation/CBB733071565/)
Book
Samuel H. Greenblatt;
(2022)
John Hughlings Jackson: Clinical Neurology, Evolution, and Victorian Brain Science
(/isis/citation/CBB899456675/)
Article
Bonnie Evans;
(2024)
The origins of film, psychology and the neurosciences
(/isis/citation/CBB141382002/)
Book
Stiles, Anne;
(2007)
Neurology and Literature, 1860--1920
(/isis/citation/CBB000774274/)
Book
York, George K.;
Steinberg, David A.;
(2006)
An Introduction to the Life and Work of John Hughlings Jackson with a Catalogue Raisonné of His Writings
(/isis/citation/CBB001022296/)
Article
M. Chirimuuta;
(2019)
Synthesis of contraries: Hughlings Jackson on sensory-motor representation in the brain
(/isis/citation/CBB021785102/)
Article
Bernd Holdorff;
(2021)
Wilhelm Erb (1840–1921), an influential German founder of neurology in the nineteenth century
(/isis/citation/CBB478081921/)
Article
Nadeem Toodayan;
Christopher J. Boes;
(2017)
The Eponymous Legacy of Sir William Richard Gowers (1845–1915): A Revealing Letter
(/isis/citation/CBB629280261/)
Article
Nadeem Toodayan;
(2017)
The Death of Sir Victor Horsley (1857–1916) and His Burial in Amarah
(/isis/citation/CBB338949431/)
Book
Malcolm Macmillan;
(2016)
Snowy Campbell: Australian Pioneer Investigator of the Brain
(/isis/citation/CBB345950156/)
Article
Laurent Fedi;
(2022)
La théorie bergsonienne dans les controverses aphasiologiques, en France, de 1906 à 1950
(/isis/citation/CBB709633313/)
Be the first to comment!