Descartes's Teleomechanics in Medical Context: Approaches to Integrating Mechanics and Teleology in Hieronymus Fabricius ab Aquapendente, William Harvey, and Rene Descartes (2013)
Distelzweig, Peter M. (Author)
Machamer, Peter K.
University of Pittsburgh
Lennox, James
Bertoloni Meli, Domenico
Gardber, Daniel
Palmieri, Paolo
Lennox, James G.
Bertoloni Meli, Domenico
Palmieri, Paolo
Edition Details: Advisor: Lennox, James, Machamer, Peter; Committee Members: Bertoloni Meli, Domenico, Gardber, Daniel, Palmieri, Paolo.
Physical Details: 249 pp.
Language: English
In this dissertation, I examine the relation between mechanism and teleology in Descartes's physiology, placing his views in a wider medical and anatomical context. I show that in this context we find distinctively Galeno-Aristotelian approaches to integrating mechanics and teleology in the work of anatomists Hieronymus Fabricius ab Aquapendente and his more famous student, William Harvey. I provide an interpretation of teleology and mechanism in Descartes by exploring the historical and conceptual relationships between his approach and those exhibited by these anatomists. First, I show that Fabricius and Harvey articulate creative, teleological, non-reductive approaches to mechanizing the animal precisely by developing Aristotelian and Galenic resources. They propose that mathematical mechanics, understood as an Aristotelian subordinate science, should be employed to articulate the way the functions of the locomotive organs explain (as final causes) certain features of their anatomy, rendering them hypothetically necessary. They articulate these explanations using the Galenic concepts actio and usus . Employing the resources developed in my analysis of Fabricius and Harvey, I then provide a new interpretation of the relation of mechanism and teleology in Descartes and clarify its significance. Although he explicitly rejects final causes in natural philosophy, Descartes still appeals in physiology to apparently teleological concepts like functio and usus . By focusing on the medical context of these concepts, I show that Descartes intends to and primarily does employ these concepts in mechanical explanations. Descartes' explanations are meant to replace the metaphysically more extravagant but still material-efficient (not final-causal) explanations present in the medical tradition. I then argue that Descartes at times does in fact employ final-causal explanations similar to those in Fabricius's and Harvey's work. However, Descartes is hard-pressed to ground these explanations while still rejecting both divine purposes and non-mechanical principles in natural philosophy.
...MoreDescription Cited in Dissertation Abstracts International-A 75/06(E), Dec 2014. Proquest Document ID: 1512222040.
Similar Citations
Article
Presti, Roberto Lo;
(2014)
The Theory of the Circulation of Blood and (Different) Paths of Aristotelianism. Girolamo Franzosi's De motu cordis et sanguinis in animalibus pro Aristotele et Galeno adversus anatomicos neotericos libri duo: Teleology versus Mechanism?
(/isis/citation/CBB001451907/)
Chapter
Peter Distelzweig;
(2016)
“Mechanics” and Mechanism in William Harvey’s Anatomy: Varieties and Limits
(/isis/citation/CBB530151678/)
Thesis
Goldberg, Benjamin Isaac;
(2012)
William Harvey, Soul Searcher: Telelogy and Philosophical Anatomy
(/isis/citation/CBB001567394/)
Chapter
Bitbol-Hespériès, Annie;
(2007)
Médecine et méthode chez Descartes
(/isis/citation/CBB001022502/)
Article
Smith, C. U. M.;
(2013)
Cardiocentric Neurophysiology: The Persistence of a Delusion
(/isis/citation/CBB001211264/)
Article
Roberto Lo Presti;
(2014)
Wissenschaftliche Revolution und Embryologie: Ablehnung oder Transformation der Antike? Ein Vergleich zwischen den Zeugungslehren Cesare Cremoninis, William Harveys und René Descartes
(/isis/citation/CBB324939224/)
Chapter
Fabio Zampieri;
(2021)
The University of Padua Medical School from the Origins to the Early Modern Time: A Historical Overview
(/isis/citation/CBB530598396/)
Article
Stefano Gensini;
(2017)
"E io in Napoli vidi un cane polacco…": ancora sui linguaggi animali, da Gesner a Campanella
(/isis/citation/CBB435419422/)
Article
Distelzweig, Peter;
(2014)
“Meam de motu & usu cordis, & circuitu sanguinis sententiam”: Teleology in William Harvey's De motu cordis
(/isis/citation/CBB001451906/)
Book
Enrico Crivellato;
(2022)
Sul moto del cuore e del sangue. L'apparato cardiocircolatorio dall'antichità alla rivoluzione scientifica
(/isis/citation/CBB558600925/)
Thesis
Ekholm, Karin Jori;
(2011)
Generation and Its Problems: Harvey, Highmore and Their Contemporaries
(/isis/citation/CBB001560837/)
Thesis
Tombs, George;
(2003)
Man the Machine: A History of a Metaphor from Leonardo da Vinci to H. G. Wells
(/isis/citation/CBB001562093/)
Book
Fuchs, Thomas;
(2001)
The Mechanization of the Heart: Harvey and Descartes
(/isis/citation/CBB000320365/)
Thesis
Alex Benjamin Shillito;
(2019)
How the Heart Became Muscle: From René Descartes to Nicolas Steno
(/isis/citation/CBB933754293/)
Article
Mario Vegetti;
(2017)
Galeno contro Erasistrato (e Aristotele): Il caso della Milza
(/isis/citation/CBB482059515/)
Book
Whitmarsh, Tim;
Wilkins, John;
Gill, Christopher;
(2009)
Galen and the World of Knowledge
(/isis/citation/CBB001032949/)
Article
Gary Hatfield;
(2017)
Descartes: New Thoughts on the Senses
(/isis/citation/CBB088587028/)
Article
Rodolfo Garau;
(2016)
Springs, Nitre, and Conatus. The Role of the Heart in Hobbes's Physiology and Animal Locomotion
(/isis/citation/CBB028109372/)
Chapter
Fabrizio Baldassarri;
(2021)
Elements of Descartes’ Medical Scientia: Books, Medical Schools, and Collaborations
(/isis/citation/CBB030659484/)
Book
Fabrizio Baldassarri;
(2021)
Il metodo al tavolo anatomico: Descartes e la medicina
(/isis/citation/CBB773621333/)
Be the first to comment!