Thesis ID: CBB001567510

Solid Foundations: Structuring American Solid State Physics, 1939--1993 (2013)

unapi

Martin, Joseph D. (Author)


Kohlstedt, Sally Gregory
Waters, C. Kenneth
University of Minnesota
Wimsatt, William C.
Waters, C. Kenneth
Seidel, Robert W.
Love, Alan Christopher
Janssen, Michel
Wimsatt, William C.
Seidel, Robert W.
Love, Alan Christopher


Publication Date: 2013
Edition Details: Advisor: Janssen, Michel, Kohlstedt, Sally Gregory; Committee Members: Wimsatt, William C., Waters, C. Kenneth, Seidel, Robert W., Love, Alan C.
Physical Details: 381 pp.
Language: English

When solid state physics formed in 1940s America, it was unusual. It violated the longstanding convention that physics should only be subdivided according to natural classes of research problems or consistent sets of techniques. Instead, solid state incorporated a wide range of concepts and methodological approaches that had only the most superficial similarities. The unifying force behind the field was the explicit professional goal of bringing academic and industrial researchers into closer dialogue. The non-traditional manner in which solid state formed was symptomatic of a sea change in the American physics community as some physicists in the 1940s began thinking about professional and institutional structures as tools with which they could actively define and maintain the scope and mission of physics. This shift had consequences both for solid state, and for American physics as a whole. Solid state was initially defined in terms of 1940s professional challenges, and so was forced to continually reimagine itself as the context changed around it. Eventually, it fractured into subgroups with divergent perspectives about the field's goals and how best to address them. One of these, condensed matter physics, has typically been understood as a simple renaming of solid state physics. A close examination of the process by which condensed matter emerged, however, indicates that it represented an intentional return to defining a sub-disciplinary on the basis of natural phenomena and investigatory techniques. Condensed matter physics grew from pointed reactions against the segment of solid state that was closely aligned with industry. It crafted an identity that emphasized the intellectual puzzles physical studies of complex systems could address. As broadly conceived fields like solid state physics established themselves and grew, both in population and in influence, physics as a whole became a broader enterprise. Research areas that might otherwise have branched off into engineering or become independent specialties were offered a place in sub-disciplines like solid state physics. Additionally, other elements of the physics community adopted solid state's mode of discipline formation, making the definition of "physics" more fluid and responsive to contemporary professional pressures. The evolution of solid state physics was guided throughout by a philosophical debate over the nature of fundamental knowledge. The disagreement persisted mostly between solid state physicists, who advocated the stance that fundamental knowledge could be found at any level of complexity, and high energy physicists, who restricted fundamental knowledge to the theories and concepts that governed the smallest constituents of matter and energy. The progress of this debate was driven by professional concerns about funding and intellectual prestige, and the philosophical positions physicists developed helped, in turn, to shape the field's professional infrastructure.

...More

Description Cited in Dissertation Abstracts International-A 74/10(E), Apr 2014. Proquest Document ID: 1420349281.


Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001567510/

Similar Citations

Chapter Townes, Charles H.; (2002)
Resistance to Change and New Ideas in Physics (/isis/citation/CBB000202416/)

Article Bensaude-Vincent, Bernadette; (2001)
The construction of a discipline: Materials science in the United States (/isis/citation/CBB000100456/)

Article Indrajit G. Roy; (2023)
Hundred years of geophysics (1834–1933) (/isis/citation/CBB875589696/)

Thesis Christensen, Terry M.; (2009)
John Archibald Wheeler: A Study of Mentoring in Modern Physics (/isis/citation/CBB001560756/)

Article Johnston, Sean F.; (2009)
Implanting a Discipline: The Academic Trajectory of Nuclear Engineering in the USA and UK (/isis/citation/CBB000932243/)

Thesis Thorpe, Charles Robert; (2001)
J. Robert Oppenheimer and the transformation of the scientific vocation (/isis/citation/CBB001562643/)

Book Joseph D. Martin; (2018)
Solid State Insurrection: How the Science of Substance Made American Physics Matter (/isis/citation/CBB940348567/)

Book John G. Weisend II; George Terence Meaden; (2021)
Going for Cold: A Biography of a Great Physicist, Kurt Mendelssohn (/isis/citation/CBB718600541/)

Article Crompton, R. W.; Dracoulis, G. D.; Lewis, B. R.; McCracken, K. G.; Williams, J. S.; (2011)
John Henry Carver 1926--2004 (/isis/citation/CBB001033727/)

Article Kleint, Christian; (1998)
Julius Edgar Lilienfeld: Life and Profession (/isis/citation/CBB000742114/)

Article Joseph D. Martin; Michel Janssen; (2015)
Beyond the Crystal Maze: Twentieth-Century Physics from the Vantage Point of Solid State Physics (/isis/citation/CBB040810974/)

Book Glynn Custred; (2016)
A History of Anthropology as a Holistic Science (/isis/citation/CBB463038781/)

Article Lunteren, Frans van; (2013)
Het ontstaan van het systeem van bètadisciplines: de natuurkunde (/isis/citation/CBB001321079/)

Article Green, Christopher D.; Feinerer, Ingo; Burman, Jeremy T.; (2015)
Searching for the Structure of Early American Psychology: Networking Psychological Review, 1894--1908 (/isis/citation/CBB001550687/)

Article Frercks, Jan; (2005)
Rezeption und Selbstverständnis: Naturlehre/Physik um 1800 (/isis/citation/CBB000701032/)

Article Marcin Krasnodębski; (2022)
Lost Green Chemistries: History of Forgotten Environmental Trajectories (/isis/citation/CBB872447698/)

Article Young, Cristobal; (2009)
The Emergence of Sociology from Political Economy in the United States: 1890 to 1940 (/isis/citation/CBB000932847/)

Book Khaled Furani; (2019)
Redeeming Anthropology: A Theological Critique of a Modern Science (/isis/citation/CBB286484093/)

Authors & Contributors
Martin, Joseph D.
Meaden, George Terence
Weisend, John G., II
Custred, Glynn
Indrajit G. Roy
Furani, Khaled
Concepts
Physics
Discipline formation
Professions and professionalization
Development of science; change in science
Molecular and solid state physics
Biographies
Time Periods
20th century
19th century
20th century, early
20th century, late
Modern
21st century
Places
United States
Great Britain
Germany
France
Oxford (England)
Japan
Institutions
American Sociological Association
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment