Hall, Deidre Dallas (Author)
During the second half of the nineteenth century, the medical profession in America began to transform itself from a motley group of practitioners--registering remarkably disparate levels of education, expertise, and credibility--into a cohesive and exclusive body, enjoying ever-increasing status and income and solidifying what social historians have termed their "professional sovereignty" within the larger culture. The concomitant appearance of numerous novels and stories preoccupied with the figure and the business of the doctor suggests that these texts from the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries not only documented but also intervened in the professionalization of medicine. Scientific Methods juxtaposes literary texts with non-literary documents and with material culture in order to determine the nature and the extent of these interventions and to delineate competing narratives within the history of medicine. By interrogating a range of professional performances represented in American fiction between 1880 and 1940, Scientific Methods establishes a complementary narrative to accounts of medical professionalization constructed by social historians. Although social historians have managed to destabilize the master narratives of scientific progress elaborated by the physician-historians of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, their investigations into the history of professionalization still center on physicians in conflict with each other and in thrall to science and technology, neglecting public perceptions of the professionalization process. Literary representations of this process, on the other hand, chart the ways in which popular understandings of the figure and the business of the physician arose and circulated, elucidating points of accord and disparity between professional ideologies and lived experience and exposing the dynamics of power between doctors and patients. These fictions of medical professionalization both reflected and produced beliefs; thus they stand as essential tools for understanding the consolidation of authority around doctors. In addition, I utilize a diverse range of archival materials--from hospital records to WPA posters--to complicate my readings of these fictional engagements with the professionalization process and to illuminate the relationship of literature to other cultural domains. I argue that this textual sequence recasts the pursuit of professionalism and the gradual consolidation of cultural authority around doctors as a constant tension between the discipline of self--as the popularity of nineteenth-century "conduct books" for physicians demonstrates--and the discipline of Others. Lacking pervasive cultural authority at the end of the nineteenth century, doctors concentrated upon cultivating professional identity through professional "pantomimes" that simultaneously demonstrated their mastery of specialized knowledge and of middle-class social norms. Eventually, these professional "pantomimes" migrated from the stage of community practice to the arena of eminently consumable, ubiquitous popular entertainments such as radio programs and public art. This movement coordinates with an increasing amount of cultural authority and a decreasing need for individual self-discipline within the profession, and with doctors--a group overwhelmingly white, middle-class, and male--feeling freer than ever to visit spectacular and invasive violence upon the raced, class, and gendered bodies of Others. These disciplinary measures include the exclusion or removal of nonwhite male and white female practitioners from the medical profession, elaborated in Frank Norris's McTeague ; human experimentation by the single-minded "microbe hunters" on southern populations during the interwar period, romanticized in Sinclair Lewis's Arrowsmith ; and eugenic pressure exerted on poor women by the Depression-era discourses of public health, critiqued by Tillie Olsen's Yonnondio and Meridel LeSueur's The Girl. Yet far from reflecting an idealized vision of the medical professional, replete with cultural authority, these narrations of disciplinary events reveal doctors threatened by incursions by nonwhite and female practitioners, defeated by their own experimental protocols, and agitated by the unlimited reproduction of the working class.
...MoreDescription Cited in ProQuest Diss. & Thes. : doc. no. 3418820.
Thesis
Sliter-Hays, Sara Maria;
(2008)
Narratives and Rhetoric: Persuasion in Doctors' Writings about the Summer Complaint, 1883--1939
(/isis/citation/CBB001561173/)
Article
Hansen, Bert;
(2004)
Medical History for the Masses: How American Comic Books Celebrated Heroes of Medicine in the 1940s
(/isis/citation/CBB000630219/)
Book
Horrocks, Thomas A.;
(2008)
Popular Print and Popular Medicine: Almanacs and Health Advice in Early America
(/isis/citation/CBB001032395/)
Thesis
Altschuler, Sari B.;
(2012)
National Physiology: Literature, Medicine, and the Invention of the American Body, 1789--1860
(/isis/citation/CBB001562790/)
Thesis
Dolezal, Joshua A.;
(2005)
The Re-Imagination of the Scientific Physician in American Literature, 1850--1930
(/isis/citation/CBB001561896/)
Thesis
Russo, Sarah L.;
(2008)
Women's Self-Writing and Medical Science: Harriet Martineau, Charlotte Bronte, Harriet Jacobs, and Elizabeth Stoddard
(/isis/citation/CBB001561183/)
Book
Edwige Comoy Fusaro;
(2007)
La nevrosi tra medicina e letteratura
(/isis/citation/CBB385434953/)
Thesis
Mazza, Kate;
(2013)
The Biological Engineers: Health Creation and Promotion in the United States, 1880--1920
(/isis/citation/CBB001562878/)
Thesis
Carroll, Katherine L.;
(2012)
Modernizing the American Medical School, 1893--1940: Architecture, Pedagogy, Professionalization, and Philanthropy
(/isis/citation/CBB001561034/)
Article
Young, Cristobal;
(2009)
The Emergence of Sociology from Political Economy in the United States: 1890 to 1940
(/isis/citation/CBB000932847/)
Article
Tunc, Tanfer Emin;
(2010)
The Mistress, the Midwife, and the Medical Doctor: Pregnancy and Childbirth on the Plantations of the Antebellum American South, 1800--1860
(/isis/citation/CBB001030818/)
Thesis
Westermann-Cicio, Mary Louise;
(2001)
Of Mice and Medical Men: The Medical Profession's Response to the Vivisection Controversy in Turn of the Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB001562385/)
Thesis
Ardalan, Christine;
(2012)
Forging Professional Public Health Nursing in a Southern State: Florida's Public Health Nurses, 1889--1934
(/isis/citation/CBB001561020/)
Thesis
Grafe, Melissa J.;
(2009)
Making “Medical Hall”: Dr. John Archer, Medical Practice, and Apprenticeship in Early America, 1769--1820
(/isis/citation/CBB001561106/)
Book
Bay, Alexander R.;
(2012)
Beriberi in Modern Japan: The Making of a National Disease
(/isis/citation/CBB001213525/)
Book
Claire L. Jones;
(2020)
The Medical Trade Catalogue in Britain, 1870-1914
(/isis/citation/CBB308894843/)
Thesis
Maria Daxenbichler;
(2020)
Knowing the Uterus: The Role of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Abortion in the Professionalization of American Medicine, 1880-1920
(/isis/citation/CBB363078790/)
Article
Sokal, Michael M.;
(2006)
The Origins of the New Psychology in the United States
(/isis/citation/CBB001023627/)
Thesis
Daniels, Brian Isaac;
(2012)
A History of Antiquities Ownership in the United States, 1870--1934
(/isis/citation/CBB001567360/)
Article
Green, Christopher D.;
Feinerer, Ingo;
Burman, Jeremy T.;
(2015)
Searching for the Structure of Early American Psychology: Networking Psychological Review, 1894--1908
(/isis/citation/CBB001550687/)
Be the first to comment!