IsisCB Explore

Thesis ID: CBB001562766

Mental Health and Ideals of Citizenship: Patient Care at St. Elizabeths Hospital in Washington, D.C., 1903--1962 (2010)

Gambino, Matthew Joseph (Author)

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Publication Date: 2010
Physical Details: 368 pp.
Language: English

Outside Links

Academia.edu

Public health Psychiatric hospitals Mental disorders and diseases Patients 20th century United States

In this thesis, I argue that U.S. psychiatry's cultural project in the first half of the twentieth century was the reconstitution of mentally-distressed men and women for proper citizenship. This enterprise is visible on the wards, in the consulting rooms, and in the outpatient clinics of St. Elizabeths Hospital in Washington, D.C., one of the most widely-respected institutions of the era. Through an intensive analysis of patient care at St. Elizabeths, I identify two fundamental tensions in psychiatry's cultural project. First, while physicians maintained high therapeutic aspirations for their patients, many of the men and women at the hospital received little more than custodial care. Second, despite the concept of citizenship's egalitarian overtones, physicians at St. Elizabeths promoted a highly gendered and racialized vision of American life. By making it their mission to restore patients to a productive role in society, psychiatrists entered a contested terrain in which Americans continually refashioned the moral contours of U.S. citizenship. Originally founded as the Government Hospital for the Insane in 1855, St. Elizabeths embodied nearly all of the aspirations and contradictions of the nineteenth-century asylum. Not long after his arrival in 1903, superintendent William Alanson White articulated an expansive program for psychiatry in which shared values could be interpreted through the lens of mental health and illness. White identified psychological well-being primarily with the male social role, and his evolutionary framework paved the way for representations of black Americans as primitive and culturally atavistic. Patients experienced psychological impairment primarily as a form of civic estrangement, with unfamiliar patterns of thought and behavior undermining their ability to meet the obligations of American citizenship. While treatment at St. Elizabeths ran the gamut from individual psychotherapy to prefrontal lobotomy, most psychiatrists saw little overt tension between psychological and physiological rationales. If physicians could not restore all of the men and women under their care to independence, they hoped that patients would at least become "good institutional citizens," capable of getting along with others and following the rules that governed their existence at the institution. The post-World War II era witnessed important changes in both psychiatrists' vision of U.S. citizenship and the institutional culture at St. Elizabeths. Physicians took an increasingly liberal view of race relations under Winfred Overholser, who succeeded White as superintendent in 1937 and was prompted by national developments to integrate the hospital in 1954. These same psychiatrists promoted a restrictive domestic ideal for their female patients, in spite of the fact that middle-class married women were entering the labor market in unprecedented numbers. Physicians charted a cautious middle path in debates on homosexuality, maintaining that same-sex desires signified deep psychological maladjustment even as they protested policies criminalizing consensual sexual contact between adults. These developments occurred in the context of a general liberalization of institutional culture in the postwar decades. Through their own efforts as well as through innovations in clinical psychiatry, patients in the 1940s and 1950s found new opportunities for self-expression and began to articulate a novel sense of shared identity. By the time the major tranquilizers appeared, the appropriateness of long-term custodial care for psychologically-impaired men and women had already come into question.

...More

Description Cited in ProQuest Diss. & Thes. : doc. no. 3455666.

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001562766/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Smith, Leonard; (2008)
“Your Very Thankful Inmate”: Discovering the Patients of an Early County Lunatic Asylum (/isis/citation/CBB000930664/)

Thesis Okin, Mary Glennon; (2008)
“Madwomen” in Quebec: An Analysis of the Recurring Themes in the Reasons for Women's Committal to Beauport, 1894--1940 (/isis/citation/CBB001561372/)

Article Swartz, Sally; (2010)
The Regulation of British Colonial Lunatic Asylums and the Origins of Colonial Psychiatry, 1860--1864 (/isis/citation/CBB001033693/)

Article Thifault, Marie-Claude; (2010)
Les stéréotypes sexuels de l'enfermement asilaire au Québec, au tournant du 20e siècle (/isis/citation/CBB001024900/)

Article Getz, Lynne M.; (2009)
“A Strong Man of Large Human Sympathy”: Dr. Patrick L. Murphy and the Challenges of Nineteenth-Century Asylum Psychiatry in North Carolina (/isis/citation/CBB001030783/)

Book Wheatley, Thelma; (2013)
“And Neither Have I Wings to Fly”: Labelled and Locked up in Canada's Oldest Institution (/isis/citation/CBB001420282/)

Article Annacarla Valeriano; (2019)
Voci dalle cartelle. Alcune linee di ricerca dall’archivio storico del manicomio Sant’Antonio abate di Teramo (/isis/citation/CBB521766391/)

Article Harris, Margaret; Farquhar, Fiona; Healy, David; Noury, Joanna C. Le; Linden, Stefanie C.; Hughes, J. Andrew; Roberts, Anthony P.; (2013)
The Morbidity and Mortality Linked to Melancholia: Two Cohorts Compared, 1875--1924 and 1995--2005 (/isis/citation/CBB001320319/)

Article Baur, Nicole; (2013)
Family Influence and Psychiatric Care: Physical Treatments in Devon Mental Hospitals, c. 1920 to the 1970s (/isis/citation/CBB001320294/)

Article Elisa Mandelli; (2019)
Lo sguardo e la performance. Le relazioni tra medico, paziente psichiatrico e spettatore dal cinema medicale al museo multimediale (/isis/citation/CBB446259905/)

Article Vera Fusco; Francesca Gollo; Marco Salustri; (2019)
Il Museo Laboratorio della Mente come risorsa per la salute mentale (/isis/citation/CBB096289987/)

Article Segrest, Mab; (2014)
Exalted on the Ward: “Mary Roberts,” the Georgia State Sanitarium, and the Psychiatric “Speciality” of Race (/isis/citation/CBB001201824/)

Article Doyle, Dennis; (2009)
“A Fine New Child”: The Lafargue Mental Hygiene Clinic and Harlem's African American Communities, 1946--1958 (/isis/citation/CBB000930501/)

Book Davide Orsini; (2023)
La lente distorta della società. Malattia, violazione dell'ordine sociale e stigma tra XIX e XXI secolo (/isis/citation/CBB852803265/)

Book Beam, Alex; (2001)
Gracefully Insane: The Rise and the Fall of America's Premier Mental Hospital (/isis/citation/CBB000101156/)

Book John Foot; (2015)
The Man Who Closed the Asylums: Franco Basaglia and the Revolution in Mental Health Care (/isis/citation/CBB264937930/)

Book Monika Ankele; Eva Brinkschulte; (2015)
Arbeitsrhythmus und Anstaltsalltag: Arbeit in der Psychiatrie vom frühen 19. Jahrhundert bis in die NS-Zeit (/isis/citation/CBB139541701/)

Article Summers, Martin; (2010)
“Suitable Care of the African When Afflicted With Insanity”: Race, Madness, and Social Order in Comparative Perspective (/isis/citation/CBB001020993/)

Article Wulf, Stefan; Schmiedebach, Heinz-Peter; (2008)
“Die sprachliche Verständigung ist selbstverständlich recht schwierig.” Die “geisteskranken Rückwanderer” aus Amerika in der Hamburger Irrenanstalt Friedrichsberg 1909 (/isis/citation/CBB001220566/)

Thesis Whitney E. Barringer; (2016)
The Corruption of Promise: The Insane Asylum in Mississippi, 1848-1910 (/isis/citation/CBB642844715/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}