Weber's Disenchantment Thesis Revisited: A Postmodern Possibility of the Religious Significance of Scientific Rationality (2003)
Koshul, Basit Bilal (Author)
Drew University
Maduro, Otto
Edition Details: Advisor: Maduro, Otto
Physical Details: 211 pp.
Language: English
Max Weber's research on the history of Western culture arrived at the conclusion, among others, that this history led from a predominantly enchanted, religious worldview, to an increasingly rationalized, disenchanted, a-religious worldview. Weber's assessment has often been understood as implying the inevitable secularization of all human culture in a near future, with religion being consigned to a diminishing corner of human social life. In fact, the prevailing view of knowledge, reason and science among Western intellectuals, scientists and scholars has fallen prey to such an understanding. At the same time Weber's scholarship as a whole has been interpreted as contributing to the process of secularization and the progressive marginalization of religion in modern times. This interpretation of Weber also sees his methodology of the social sciences as both embodying and promoting the fact/value and subject/object dichotomies, characteristic of modernist, Enlightenment thought. The present investigation attempts to demonstrate that an alternative reading of Weber's work is possible---an interpretation that allows for the possibility of investing knowledge, rationality and the life of the intellect with religious value and meaning in a postmodern society. This alternative reading begins by demonstrating that Weber's methodology of the social sciences marks a clear departure from dichotomous logic of Enlightenment thought and overcomes the fact/value and subject/object dichotomies. The works of Ciaffa (1998), Ringer (1997) and Alexander (1983) are used to illustrate the fact that Weber's methodology of the social sciences posits a reflexive relationality between fact/value and subject/object, in contrast to the dichotomous dualism of Enlightenment thought. The present investigation will look at Weber's methodological and philosophical works in light of the valuations offered by Ciaffa, Ringer and Alexander. Building upon these insights, it will be demonstrated that while Weber the historical sociologist documents the emergence and trajectory of the science/religion divide, Weber the methodologist of the social science offers penetrating insights that easily lend themselves to initiating and/or furthering a rapprochement between religion and science in the postmodern period.
...MoreDescription Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 64 (2003): 1104. UMI order no. 3083315.
Similar Citations
Chapter
Boudon, Raymond;
(2004)
Théorie du choix rationnel ou individualisme méthodologique?
(/isis/citation/CBB000774986/)
Thesis
Vermij, Rienk H.;
(9-9-1991)
Secularisering en natuurwetenschap in de zeventiende en achttiende eeuw: Bernard Nieuwentijt
(/isis/citation/CBB155878646/)
Article
Motzkin, Gabriel;
(2002)
Science, Secularization, and Desecularization at the Turn of the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000202839/)
Article
Miguel De Asúa;
(2020)
Science, Catholicism and Politics in Argentina (1910–1935)
(/isis/citation/CBB237095913/)
Book
Donald A. Yerxa;
(2016)
Religion and Innovation: Antagonists or Partners?
(/isis/citation/CBB363877764/)
Article
Feiner, Shmuel;
(2002)
Seductive Science and the Emergence of the Secular Jewish Intellectual
(/isis/citation/CBB000202836/)
Chapter
Endersby, Jim;
(2014)
Odd Man Out: Was Joseph Hooker an Evolutionary Naturalist?
(/isis/citation/CBB001422050/)
Book
Froese, Paul;
(2008)
The Plot to Kill God: Findings from the Soviet Experiment in Secularization
(/isis/citation/CBB000850363/)
Article
Kosits, Russell D.;
(2004)
Of Faculties, Fallacies, and Freedom: Dilemma and Irony in the Secularization of American Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB000501055/)
Article
Muravchik, Stephanie;
(2012)
“Be the Love of God Rather Than Talk about It”: Ministers Study Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB001210164/)
Article
Jaume Navarro;
(2017)
Promising Redemption. Science at the Service of Secular and Religious Agendas
(/isis/citation/CBB802509283/)
Book
Margaret Jacob;
(2019)
The Secular Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB420323494/)
Book
Numbers, Ronald L.;
(2007)
Science and Christianity in Pulpit and Pew
(/isis/citation/CBB000931076/)
Article
Richards, Joan L.;
(2002)
“In a rational world all radicals would be exterminated”? Mathematics, Logic and Secular Thinking in Augustus De Morgan's England
(/isis/citation/CBB000202840/)
Article
Alexandre Grandjean;
(2021)
Biodynamic Wine-crafting in Switzerland: The Translation and Adaptation of Rudolf Steiner’s Cosmology into Dark Green Agronomies
(/isis/citation/CBB869304402/)
Book
Danneberg, Lutz;
(2003)
Die Anatomie des Text-körpers und Natur-körpers
(/isis/citation/CBB000320217/)
Chapter
Numbers, Ronald L.;
(2007)
Epilogue: Science, Secularization, and Privatization
(/isis/citation/CBB000760660/)
Book
Harrison, Peter;
(2010)
The Cambridge Companion to Science and Religion
(/isis/citation/CBB001031846/)
Article
Heyd, Micheal;
(2002)
Science and Secularization: Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB000202838/)
Article
Geller, Markham J.;
(2011)
Zur Rolle der antiken Astrologie in der Vorbereitung einer säkularen Naturwissenschaft und Medizin
(/isis/citation/CBB001220734/)
Be the first to comment!