Thesis ID: CBB001561963

Thresholds of Uncertainty: Radiation and Responsibility in the Fallout Controversy (2004)

unapi

Jolly, J. Christopher (Author)


Oregon State University
Nye, Mary Jo


Publication Date: 2004
Edition Details: Advisor: Nye, Mary Jo
Physical Details: 591 pp.
Language: English

The public controversy over possible health hazards from radioactive fallout from atomic bomb testing began in 1954, shortly after a thermonuclear test by the United States spread fallout world wide. In the dissertation, I address two of the fundamental questions of the fallout controversy: Was there a threshold of radiation exposure below which there would be no significant injury? What was the role of a responsible scientist in a public scientific debate? Genetics and medicine were the scientific fields most directly involved in the debate over the biological effects of radiation. Geneticists' prewar experiences with radiation led them to believe that there was no safe level of radiation exposure and that any amount of radiation would cause a proportional amount of genetic injury. In contrast to geneticists, physicians and medical researchers generally believed that there was a threshold for somatic injury from radiation. One theme of the dissertation is an examination of how different scientific conceptual and methodological approaches affected how geneticists and medical researchers evaluated the possible health effects of fallout. Geneticists and physicians differed not only in their evaluations of radiation hazards, but also in their views of how the debate over fallout should be conducted. A central question of the fallout debate was how a responsible scientist should act in a public policy controversy involving scientific issues upon which the scientific community had not yet reached a consensus. Based on their assumption that any increase in radiation exposure was harmful, most geneticists believed that they had a responsibility to speak out publicly about the deleterious effects of radiation. Physicians, who believed in the likelihood of a threshold for significant radiation-induced injury, generally adopted the opposite view. They believed that public discussion of possible, but improbable, radiation hazards was irresponsible because it risked creating irrational public fear of radiation exposure. In my dissertation, I examine how the different positions of geneticists and physicians over what constituted responsible public scientific debate affected the rhetoric of the controversy, as well as the implications of the debate in matters of politics and policy.

...More

Description Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 64 (2004): 4600. UMI order no. 3115467.


Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001561963/

Similar Citations

Book Hamblin, Jacob Darwin; (2008)
Poison in the Well: Radioactive Waste in the Oceans at the Dawn of the Nuclear Age (/isis/citation/CBB000774692/)

Book Robert A. Jacobs; (2022)
Nuclear Bodies: The Global Hibakusha (/isis/citation/CBB596228330/)

Book Edelstein, Michael R.; Makofske, William J.; (1998)
Radon's Deadly Daughters: Science, Environmental Policy, and the Politics of Risk (/isis/citation/CBB000320516/)

Article Lisa Ruth Rand; (January 2019)
Falling Cosmos: Nuclear Reentry and the Environmental History of Earth Orbit (/isis/citation/CBB208189412/)

Article Rothschild, Rachel; (2013)
Environmental Awareness in the Atomic Age: Radioecologists and Nuclear Technology (/isis/citation/CBB001213269/)

Article Hiroshi Ichikawa; (2015)
Radiation Studies and the Soviet Scientists in the Second Half of the 1950's (/isis/citation/CBB611418704/)

Article Petryna, Adriana; (2004)
Biological Citizenship: The Science and Politics of Chernobyl-Exposed Populations (/isis/citation/CBB000750331/)

Book Larry C. Johns; Alan R. Johns; (2017)
The Baneberry Disaster: A Generation of Atomic Fallout (/isis/citation/CBB760417809/)

Article Boudia, Soraya; (2007)
Global Regulation: Controlling and Accepting Radioactivity Risks (/isis/citation/CBB000850042/)

Article Sumiko Hatakeyama; (2021)
Let Chromosomes Speak: The Cytogenetics Project at the Atomic Bomb Casualty Commission (ABCC) (/isis/citation/CBB161117781/)

Book Largent, Mark A.; (2012)
Vaccine: The Debate in Modern America (/isis/citation/CBB001213531/)

Book Fox, Sarah Alisabeth; (2014)
Downwind: A People's History of the Nuclear West (/isis/citation/CBB001422378/)

Authors & Contributors
Candela, Andrea
Rand, Lisa Ruth
Celso, Baldivieso, Jr.
Johns, Alan R.
Ichikawa, Hiroshi
Hatakeyama, Sumiko
Concepts
Nuclear and radioactive waste
Pollution, radioactive
Public health
Radiation sickness; radiation toxicology; Acute Radiation Syndrome (ARS)
Nuclear testing
Nuclear power; atomic energy
Time Periods
20th century, late
21st century
20th century
Places
United States
Soviet Union
Puerto Rico
Ukraine
Nevada (U.S.)
Latin America
Institutions
U.S. Atomic Energy Commission
Nuclear Test Ban Treaty; Partial Test Ban Treaty; Limited Test Ban Treaty (1963)
Atomic Bomb Casualty Commission
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment