Schwegman, Jeffrey (Author)
The French Enlightenment represents a unique episode in the history of post-classical philosophy: a moment, poised between the decline of the medieval university and the rise of the modern academic philosophy department, when philosophical knowledge was produced largely outside specialized and learned intellectual communities. Throughout this period, savants began to seek out audiences beyond the scholarly correspondence networks and societies established in the previous century, tailoring their publications for a general reading public and working to establish themselves within the glittering aristocratic world of the Parisian salons. This dissertation examines how these developments transformed the practice of philosophy as a scholarly enterprise. I explore this general theme through a case study, focusing on the career of the Parisian metaphysician and pedagogue Étienne Bonnot de Condillac (1714-1780). Like so many of his contemporaries, Condillac sought to bring the fruits of his learning to salon sophisticates and the general public, but he also continued to adhere to an older model of philosophy as a technical, scholarly enterprise, demanding a certain amount of expertise. These two ambitions proved difficult to reconcile, and Condillac's publications sometimes provoked harsh criticism from his contemporaries. Throughout his life, therefore, Condillac struggled to adapt to the demands placed upon him by his audiences, while simultaneously seeking to devise ways of training them to become more learned readers of philosophy. Studying these interactions between Condillac and his readers allows me to explore two broader issues. On the one hand, I analyze how the experience of writing philosophy outside of learned communities transformed the cultural identity of the philosopher during this period. In particular, I look at shifting assumptions about the proper scope of philosophy and about the nature and value of philosophical expertise. At the same time, I also examine how these developments shaped eighteenth-century philosophical practices: that is, the scholarly activities central to the philosopher's craft. In particular, I focus on techniques for reading and evaluating texts, taking notes, acquiring knowledge, engaging in disputes, cultivating audiences, crafting written expositions, building theories, and teaching concepts and techniques to others. Historians of philosophy rarely pay much attention to these kinds of practices, but they also have a history, and they often shape the production of philosophical knowledge in profound ways. By focusing on collective identities and practices, rather than on the ideas and doctrines of individuals, this dissertation offers a new kind of cultural approach to the history of Enlightenment philosophy, modeled on the history of science. Each chapter begins with one of Condillac's own practices or texts, or with a controversy in which he was involved, and then builds outwards, reconstructing its place within a larger community of philosophers and readers. Chapters 1 and 2 consider the highly publicized plagiarism dispute that erupted over Condillac's Traité des sensations in 1754, using this episode to explore the shifting cultural identity of the philosopher at mid-century. Chapter 3 focuses on the 1749 Traité des systêmes , and analyzes Condillac's efforts to train lay readers in the art of reading and evaluating philosophical texts. Chapter 4 looks at the pedagogical and writerly strategies employed by Condillac and other eighteenth-century scholars in an effort to manage the reception of their works and considers the epistemological effects of these practices on philosophical theories. Chapter 5 explores the encyclopedic ambitions of eighteenth-century philosopher, and describes some of the shared tools that they developed to facilitate their efforts to theorize about every branch of knowledge.
...MoreDescription Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 69/01 (2008). Pub. no. AAT 3299843.
Chapter
Loveland, Jeff;
(2003)
French Thought in William Smellie's Natural History: A Scottish Reception of Buffon and Condillac
(/isis/citation/CBB000410948/)
Book
Bensaude-Vincent, Bernadette;
Blondel, Christine;
(2008)
Science and Spectacle in the European Enlightenment
(/isis/citation/CBB000850395/)
Article
Schwegman, Jeffrey;
(2010)
The “System” as a Reading Technology: Pedagogy and Philosophical Criticism in Condillac's Traité des Systêmes
(/isis/citation/CBB001030591/)
Book
Giovanni Cristiani;
(2003)
D’Holbach e le rivoluzioni del globo. Scienze della terra e filosofie della natura nell’età dell’Encyclopédie
(/isis/citation/CBB000398171/)
Article
Henry Martyn Lloyd;
(2018)
The French Enlightenment Attempts to Create a Philosophy Without Reason: The Case of Diderot and the Effect of Helvétius
(/isis/citation/CBB756812252/)
Book
Brewer, Daniel;
(2008)
The Enlightenment Past: Reconstructing Eighteenth-Century French Thought
(/isis/citation/CBB000830827/)
Book
Meghan K. Roberts;
(2016)
Sentimental Savants: Philosophical Families in Enlightenment France
(/isis/citation/CBB854090040/)
Book
McMahon, Darrin M.;
(2001)
Enemies of the Enlightenment: The French Counter-Enlightenment and the Making of Modernity
(/isis/citation/CBB000101636/)
Book
Didier Contadini;
(2023)
Julien Offray de La Mettrie: Saggio sulla sua formazione filosofica
(/isis/citation/CBB801766488/)
Chapter
Cheung, Tobias;
(2010)
Embodied Stimuli: Bonnet's Statue of a Sensitive Agent
(/isis/citation/CBB001031897/)
Book
Hays, Julie Candler;
(1999)
Reading the French Enlightenment: System and subversion
(/isis/citation/CBB000081790/)
Article
Roberts, Lissa;
(1992)
Condillac, Lavoisier, and the instrumentalization of science
(/isis/citation/CBB000058766/)
Article
Klein, Daniel;
(1985)
Deductive economic methodology in the French Enlightenment: Condillac and Destutt de Tracy
(/isis/citation/CBB000016618/)
Thesis
Albury, William R.;
(1972)
The logic of Condillac and the structure of French chemical and biological theory, 1780-1801
(/isis/citation/CBB001563473/)
Article
Klein, Daniel;
(1985)
Deductive economic methodology in the French Enlightenment: Condillac and Destutt de Tracy
(/isis/citation/CBB000049686/)
Article
Eltis, Walter;
(1995)
L'Abbé de Condillac and the Physiocrats
(/isis/citation/CBB000046791/)
Article
Guillaume Roux;
(2021)
Le cas de Victor de l’Aveyron au regard de l’acquisition du langage
(/isis/citation/CBB448349528/)
Book
Elizabeth Andrews Bond;
(2021)
The Writing Public: Participatory Knowledge Production in Enlightenment and Revolutionary France
(/isis/citation/CBB275680680/)
Chapter
Jan Golinski;
(2017)
Enlightenment Science
(/isis/citation/CBB923464058/)
Thesis
Kent, Max Louis;
(2007)
The British Enlightenment and the Spirit of the Industrial Revolution: TheSociety for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce (1754--1815)
(/isis/citation/CBB001561313/)
Be the first to comment!