“A Hot-Bed of the Anti-Vaccine Heresy”: Opposition to Compulsory Vaccination in Boston and Cambridge, 1890--1905 (2007)
Walloch, Karen L. (Author)
University of Wisconsin at Madison
Leavitt, Judith Walzer
Edition Details: Advisor: Leavitt, Judith Walzer
Physical Details: 467 pp.
Language: English
My dissertation explores the historical context of controversy about vaccination behind Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905), a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding state police power to compel vaccination. Despite enthusiastic support for vaccination among leading physicians and public health officers, the persistence of smallpox epidemics during the nineteenth century indicates that Americans did not vaccinate sufficiently. Data from Massachusetts show that many people viewed vaccination with suspicion and only reluctantly accepted it as a necessary evil forced upon them by their employers or the law. Parents waited until their children reached school age and rarely sought second vaccinations for them at adolescence. Even during epidemics, a significant portion of the population avoided vaccination. Many Americans feared vaccination for good reasons. It induced mild to severe discomfort and occasionally led to severe, even fatal infections. Lymph came from a variety of sources, with no assurance as to either quality or safety. Bovine lymph, adopted in the 1870s to obviate the possibility of syphilis transmission through vaccination, was easily contaminated with disease-causing organisms if producers and distributors got careless. Controversy over vaccination created public anxiety during the 1901-02 smallpox epidemic in Boston and Cambridge that formed the context for Jacobson. Although most residents submitted to vaccination, many did so grudgingly and enough avoided it to force both cities to order compulsory vaccination for everyone. A few individuals defied the order and antivaccinationists organized to support their resistance and oppose the law. Neither anti-scientific nor anti- government cranks, these antivaccinationists, like their nineteenth-century predecessors, pointed out inconsistencies in the medical science behind vaccination and questioned evidence used to promote it. They believed vaccination too dangerous to compel upon the unwilling. Even though they lost their case, their arguments dampened public acceptance of vaccination so much that few states passed similar compulsory vaccination laws in the wake of Jacobson.
...MoreDescription Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 68/12 (2008). Pub. no. AAT 3294105.
Similar Citations
Book
Willrich, Michael;
(2011)
Pox: An American History
(/isis/citation/CBB001212485/)
Article
Hackett, Paul;
(2004)
Averting Disaster: The Hudson's Bay Company and Smallpox in Western Canada during the Late Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries
(/isis/citation/CBB000630233/)
Article
Jannetta, Ann;
(2009)
Jennerian Vaccination and the Creation of a National Public Health Agenda in Japan, 1850--1900
(/isis/citation/CBB000932123/)
Article
Sarah Rafferty;
Matthew R. Smallman-Raynor;
Andrew D. Cliff;
(2018)
Variola minor in England and Wales: The geographical course of a smallpox epidemic and the impediments to effective disease control, 1920–1935
(/isis/citation/CBB204012556/)
Article
Junaidi;
(2023)
Smallpox vaccination in Nias Island, Indonesia, 1854-1915
(/isis/citation/CBB724936721/)
Article
Oliveira, Eliézer Cardoso de;
(2013)
A epidemia de varíola e o medo da vacina em Goiás
(/isis/citation/CBB001420672/)
Thesis
Thomas Hurford, Christianna Elrene;
(2010)
“In His Arm the Scar”: Medicine, Race, and the Social Implications of the 1721 Inoculation Controversy on Boston
(/isis/citation/CBB001567177/)
Thesis
Davies, Linda Margaret;
(2007)
The Conquest of Infant Mortality: The Case of Hemsworth, 1871--1911
(/isis/citation/CBB001561517/)
Article
Jeongeun Jo;
(2020)
Smallpox Vaccine and Resident Responses in Modern Shanghai: Focusing on Regional and Cultural Comparison
(/isis/citation/CBB875185916/)
Article
Minsky, Lauren;
(2009)
Pursuing Protection from Disease: The Making of Smallpox Prophylactic Practice in Colonial Punjab
(/isis/citation/CBB000932125/)
Thesis
Naono, Atsuko;
(2005)
The State of Vaccination: British Doctors, Indigenous Cooperation, and theFight against Smallpox in Colonial Burma
(/isis/citation/CBB001561575/)
Article
Colgrove, James;
(2004)
Between Persuasion and Compulsion: Smallpox Control in Brooklyn and New York, 1894--1902
(/isis/citation/CBB000630223/)
Book
Jones, Greta;
Malcolm, Elizabeth;
(1999)
Medicine, disease, and the State in Ireland, 1650-1940
(/isis/citation/CBB000110599/)
Article
Palmer, Steven;
Hochman, Gilberto;
Arbex, Danieli;
(2010)
Smallpox Eradication, Laboratory Visits, and a Touch of Tourism: Travel Notes of a Canadian Scientist in Brazil
(/isis/citation/CBB001420472/)
Article
Jensen, Niklas Thode;
(2009)
Safeguarding Slaves: Smallpox, Vaccination, and Governmental Health Policies among the Enslaved Population in the Danish West Indies, 1803--1848
(/isis/citation/CBB000932122/)
Book
Fanning, Patricia J.;
(2010)
Influenza and Inequality: One Town's Tragic Response to the Great Epidemic of 1918
(/isis/citation/CBB001212737/)
Thesis
Gonzalez, Stephanie;
(2014)
The Double-Edged Sword: Smallpox Vaccination and the Politics of Public Health in Cuba
(/isis/citation/CBB001567634/)
Article
Hyon Ju Lee;
(2020)
Rethinking the History of Smallpox in the Early Twentieth Century: The SS Korea and Uncertainty Surrounding the Diagnosis of Smallpox
(/isis/citation/CBB150111874/)
Article
Moon, Mira;
(2014)
A Comparative Study on Koii (Public Doctor) System and Its Effect on Public Health in Colonial Taiwan and Korea
(/isis/citation/CBB001422420/)
Article
Teigen, Philip M.;
(2007)
Legislating Fear and the Public Health in Gilded Age Massachusetts
(/isis/citation/CBB000774460/)
Be the first to comment!