Ratowt, Sylwester Jan (Author)
University of Oklahoma
Barker, Peter
Edition Details: Advisor: Barker, Peter
Physical Details: 263 pp.
Language: English
The history of investigation of the Earth's age during the second half of the 19th and first half of the 20th centuries has been often presented as a narrative of a disciplinary conflict. In this dissertation, I investigate the evidence which supports such accounts as well as evidence contrary to it. I conclude that this disciplinary conflict narrative underestimates the complexity of the historical situation and points to broader inadequacies in understanding of group knowledge and consensus. The larger question I ask is "what does it mean for a group of people to know something?" I argue that we need view the historical actor as composed of (dialogically interacting) multiple subjects: the individual who strives for understanding and multiple community members who strive to communicate. Furthermore, I introduce the concept of an imagined community member, the image that an interlocutor has of an anonymous member of a given community, who represents its knowledge, assumptions, and expectations. Based on an investigation of previously unexamined archival and printed sources, I argue for a new periodization of dialogues on the Earth's age in America. Prior to the 1890s, only isolated American scientists spoke about the topic. After a period of intensified discussion during the years 1892-3, the scientific community started to give a uniform answer to the question about the age of the Earth, which was the disciplinary conflict story. This uniform community response, however, corresponded only to a consensus of response, not a consensus of shared belief. The next period covering the first two decades of the next century, corresponded to the fragmentation of the discussion of the age of the Earth into multiple, non-interacting, largely disciplinary dialogues. A new consensus did not emerge again until around 1930, when a new community emerged and claimed jurisdiction over the question of geological time. In addition to challenging the disciplinary conflict narrative I also argue that the significance of the discipline of chemistry, and of two individuals, Joseph Barrell and Alfred C. Lane, to the dialogues on the Earth's age has been undervalued in current historiography.
...MoreDescription Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 70/04 (2009). Pub. no. AAT 3354927.
Similar Citations
Chapter
Numbers, Ronald L.;
(2004)
Ironic Heresy: How Young-Earth Creationists Came to Embrace Rapid Microevolution by Means of Natural Selection
(/isis/citation/CBB000520040/)
Chapter
Frängsmyr, Tore;
(2007)
Between the Deluge and the Ice Age
(/isis/citation/CBB000775028/)
Article
Greg A. Brick;
(2022)
The far shoals of Neptunism: William H. Keating and the St. Peter Sandstone in the American Midwest
(/isis/citation/CBB784589624/)
Book
Lyle, Louise;
McCallam, David;
(2008)
Histoires de la Terre: Earth Sciences and French Culture, 1740--1940
(/isis/citation/CBB001230862/)
Article
Joseph T. Hannibal;
(2022)
The Newberry-Whittlesey controversy and its protagonists: background, arguments, and outcome of a bitter feud
(/isis/citation/CBB844814529/)
Article
Kutsukake, Toshio;
(2003)
The Controversy Over the Origin of Rocks: Neptunism vs. Vulcanism in the Late 18th-Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000600625/)
Book
Cohen, Claudine;
(2011)
Science, libertinage et clandestinité à l'aube des Lumières. Le transformisme de Telliamed
(/isis/citation/CBB001231914/)
Chapter
Broschart, Kay Richards;
(2005)
An Intellectual Wasteland or Garden of Eden? Sociology in the American South before 1950
(/isis/citation/CBB000931128/)
Article
Young, Cristobal;
(2009)
The Emergence of Sociology from Political Economy in the United States: 1890 to 1940
(/isis/citation/CBB000932847/)
Article
Philippe Fontaine;
(2020)
Calling the Social Sciences Names
(/isis/citation/CBB117012073/)
Chapter
Dean, Dennis R.;
(2009)
Benjamin Franklin and Geology
(/isis/citation/CBB001021048/)
Chapter
Clary, R. M.;
Wandersee, J. H.;
(2007)
Great Expectations: Florence Bascom (1842--1945) and the Education of Early US Women Geologists
(/isis/citation/CBB000953710/)
Article
Alice Kim;
Nicole C. Lautze;
(2021)
Tourists Play with Lava and Volcanic Heat: Kīlauea Volcano's Early Contributions to Hawai'i's Tourism Industry
(/isis/citation/CBB381673259/)
Article
Pietruska, Jamie L.;
(2011)
US Weather Bureau Chief Willis Moore and the Reimagination of Uncertainty in Long-Range Forecasting
(/isis/citation/CBB001231338/)
Chapter
Baker, Victor R.;
(2009)
Charles S. Peirce and the “Light of Nature”
(/isis/citation/CBB001021051/)
Article
Zweihorn, Chaninah L.;
(2003)
Origins of the Extraction Controversy in American Orthodontics (1880--1910)
(/isis/citation/CBB000932364/)
Thesis
Scott Gerard Prinster;
(2021)
Reading the Bible Scientifically: Science and the Rise of Modern Biblical Criticism in the Nineteenth- and Early Twentieth-Century United States
(/isis/citation/CBB558685393/)
Book
Stuart Mathieson;
(2020)
Evangelicals and the Philosophy of Science: The Victoria Institute, 1865-1939
(/isis/citation/CBB676582188/)
Book
Newcomb, Sally;
(2009)
The World in a Crucible: Laboratory Practice and Geological Theory at the Beginning of Geology
(/isis/citation/CBB001021017/)
Book
Palmer, Douglas;
(2005)
Earth Time: Exploring the Deep Past from Victorian England to the Grand Canyon
(/isis/citation/CBB000600027/)
Be the first to comment!