Feil, Kiersten (Author)
This is a mostly historical project in which I ask first, what is the origin and nature of evolutionary thought in medicine? The answer is in the late nineteenth century neurosciences, where it helped to explain clinical phenomena that indicated pathology was more an intricate process than an anatomical fact. This view of pathology was grounded in evolutionary theory, and was theoretically elaborated by the philosopher Georges Canguilhem in the mid-twentieth century. He was greatly influenced by the neurologists that preceded him in his perspective, but Canguilhem has a distinctly Darwinian angle. In the second part of the dissertation, I introduce examples from contemporary Evolutionary-Developmental Biology (Evo-Devo) to argue that a modern definition of disorder that is based on a notion of normality as an implicit 'ideal' proves inadequate given new discoveries about how adaptation and variation are inextricably linked to the developmental phenomena Evo-Devo explores. The historical precedent of thinking about normality and pathology as linked with evolutionary processes proves apt once again, given recent emphasis in evolutionary biology on the relationship between individual development and evolutionary change. The developmental perspective possesses a significance that is appropriately captured by a diagram most recently elaborated by Randolph Nesse (2000) in which he identifies the nature of biological questions as based on four intersecting elements. The two objects of explanation are the Single Form, and the Developmental/Historical; the two kinds of questions are Proximate and Evolutionary. There is much precedent in medicine for proximate questions about the Single Form object of explanation: how does this (organ, system, part) work, and how can it be described? Nesse himself, and George Williams spearheaded the evolutionary questioning of the Single Form in Darwinian Medicine. The fact that there is another object of explanation (Developmental/Historical) recognized in biology is reason to inquire about its status in medicine. It is the aim of this dissertation to do that. Specifically, I will narrow the topic by looking through the lens of medicine's most visible distinction, that between pathology and normality, to see where and how the developmental perspective gets involved.
...MoreDescription Explains how evolutionary ideas entered medicine first in the late 19th century via the neurosciences and later via developmental biology. Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 67/09 (2007). UMI pub. no. 3231392.
Book
Robinson, Joseph D.;
(2001)
Mechanisms of Synaptic Transmission: Bridging the Gap (1890-1990)
(/isis/citation/CBB000102087/)
Article
Park, Hyung Wook;
(2015)
Programming Cell Death in the 1960s: Developmental Biology beyond Dichotomy
(/isis/citation/CBB001553557/)
Chapter
Alessandro Minelli;
(2015)
I limiti temporali e la periodizzazione dello sviluppo
(/isis/citation/CBB017623140/)
Article
Guralnick, Robert;
(2002)
A Recapitulation of the Rise and Fall of the Cell Lineage Research Program: The Evolutionary-Developmental Relationship of Cleavage to Homology, Body Plans and Life History
(/isis/citation/CBB000300873/)
Article
Kuratani, Shigeru;
(2003)
Evolutionary Developmental Biology and Vertebrate Head Segmentation: A Perspective from Developmental Constraint
(/isis/citation/CBB000430238/)
Article
Douglas J. Lanska;
(2016)
The Dercum-Muybridge Collaboration and the Study of Pathologic Gaits Using Sequential Photography
(/isis/citation/CBB097576322/)
Article
Minelli, Alessandro;
(2003)
L'omologia rivisitata
(/isis/citation/CBB000340720/)
Article
Levit, Georgy S.;
Hossfeld, Uwe;
Olsson, Lennart;
(2015)
Alexei Sewertzoff and Adolf Naef: Revising Haeckel's Biogenetic Law
(/isis/citation/CBB001510261/)
Chapter
Aldo Fasolo;
Davide Lovisolo;
(2015)
"The Cell in Development and Inheritance", centoventi anni dopo. E.B. Wilson, la teoria cellulare e il tassello mancante: la membrana plasmatica
(/isis/citation/CBB288072174/)
Book
Creath, Richard;
Maienschein, Jane;
(2000)
Biology and epistemology
(/isis/citation/CBB000110573/)
Book
Egerton, Frank N.;
(2003)
Hewett Cottrell Watson: Victorian Plant Ecologist and Evolutionist
(/isis/citation/CBB000301766/)
Book
Amundson, Ronald;
(2005)
The Changing Role of the Embryo in Evolutionary Thought: Roots of Evo-Devo
(/isis/citation/CBB000550706/)
Book
Perlman, Robert L;
(2013)
Evolution and Medicine
(/isis/citation/CBB001421084/)
Chapter
Hopwood, Nick;
(2002)
Embryonen “auf dem Altar der Wissenschaft zu opfern”: Entwicklungsreihen im späten neunzehnten Jahrhundert
(/isis/citation/CBB000320316/)
Article
Andy Byford;
(2017)
The Imperfect Child in Early Twentieth-century Russia
(/isis/citation/CBB055501257/)
Article
Élodie Giroux;
(2021)
Can populations be healthy? Perspectives from Georges Canguilhem and Geoffrey Rose
(/isis/citation/CBB887442116/)
Article
Ivan Moya Diez;
(2018)
Canguilhem avec Goldstein: De la normativité de la vie à la normativité de la connaissance
(/isis/citation/CBB403533464/)
Article
Tulodziecki, Dana;
(2011)
A Case Study in Explanatory Power: John Snow's Conclusions about the Pathology and Transmission of Cholera
(/isis/citation/CBB001024016/)
Chapter
Debru, Claude;
(2007)
Les classifications et l'inclassable: le cas des leucémies
(/isis/citation/CBB001022515/)
Article
Lellouch, Alain;
(2006)
De “L'anatomie pathologique première” à “L'anatomie médicale de structure”: Continuité ou points de rupture épistémologiques?
(/isis/citation/CBB000932458/)
Be the first to comment!