IsisCB Explore

Thesis ID: CBB001560814

The Rhetoric of Repugnance: Popular Culture and Unpopular Notions in the Human Cloning Debate (2007)

Virginia Polytechnic Institute
Halfon, Saul E.
Hirsh, Richard F.

Publication Date: 2007
Edition Details: Advisor: Halfon, Saul E.; Richard F. Hirsh
Physical Details: 163 pp.
Language: English

Outside Links

Academia.edu

Cloning of organisms Biotechnology Technology Popular culture Science fiction Technology and ethics 20th century, late

An ethical frame grounded in science fiction literature shaped the discourse on cloning following the announcement of Dolly-the-sheep's birth through nuclear transfer. Using methodologies drawn from the social shaping of technology (SST) and rhetoric of science, my analysis demonstrates how individuals and institutions, including the media, ethicists, policymakers, and legislators, appropriated this ethical frame. In doing so, they employed science-fiction stories as rhetorical tropes, providing the public with a frame for understanding the social issues involved with cloning. However, these institutions used science fiction as a way to simplify and present ethical arguments that silenced dissent rather than encouraged dialog. While ethics discourse can validly make use of literature in debates about technology, such a simplistic view of the literature misrepresents the themes the authors explored in their works and limits discussion. I conclude by offering a deeper analysis and reading of some of these stories, relying on the texts themselves rather than the myths that have evolved around these texts as my primary source material. Such a reading provides a valuable counter-narrative to the on-going debate, one that more adequately explains the effects of technology in a society. In short, this dissertation demonstrates that the reductionist interpretation of works from the science fiction genre had real effects on policy formulation. People utilized their literary-derived perceptions of cloning in political discussions about technology. Thus, policy discussions of the perceived effects of the technology developed much of their meaning and significance from fictional depictions of the technology.

...More

Description Looks at how science fiction stories were utilized as a literary form to simplify ethcial arguments in the cloning debates after the birth of the first cloned sheep. Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 69/01 (2008). Pub. no. AAT 3300053.

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001560814/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Thesis Milburn, Colin Nazhone; (2005)
Nanovision: Engineering the Future (/isis/citation/CBB001561912/)

Article Gomela, Elana; (2011)
Science (Fiction) and Posthuman Ethics: Redefining the Human (/isis/citation/CBB001212424/)

Article Miguel García-Sancho; Dmitriy Myelnikov; (2019)
Between mice and sheep: Biotechnology, agricultural science and animal models in late-twentieth century Edinburgh (/isis/citation/CBB803418234/)

Book Priest, Susanna Hornig; (2001)
A Grain of Truth: The Media, the Public, and Biotechnology (/isis/citation/CBB000631008/)

Article Hellsten, Iina; (2008)
Popular Metaphors of Biosciences: Bridges over Time? (/isis/citation/CBB000932150/)

Article Medeiros, Flavia Natercia da Silva; (2013)
Fora da ordem natural: a natureza nos discursos sobre a clonagem e a pesquisa com células-tronco em jornais brasileiros (/isis/citation/CBB001420696/)

Article Brandt, Christina; (2013)
Hybrid Times: Theses on the Temporalities of Cloning (/isis/citation/CBB001211939/)

Chapter Brandt, Christina; (2007)
Wissenschaft---Literatur---Öffentlichkeit: Die Bedeutung der Science-Fiction in den 1970er Jahren für die öffentliche Debatte zum Klonen (/isis/citation/CBB001023695/)

Article Brandt, Christina; (2009)
Die zwei (und mehr) Kulturen des Klons. Utopie und Fiktion im biowissenschaftlichen Diskurs der Nachkriegszeit (/isis/citation/CBB000933302/)

Article Jensen, Eric; (2008)
The Dao of Human Cloning: Utopian/Dystopian Hype in the British Press and Popular Films (/isis/citation/CBB000831215/)

Article Berne, Rosalyn W.; Schummer, Joachim; (2005)
Teaching Societal and Ethical Implications of Nanotechnology to Engineering Students Through Science Fiction (/isis/citation/CBB000720271/)

Article Yampell, Cat; (2008)
When Science Blurs the Boundaries: The Commodification of the Animal in Young Adult Science Fiction (/isis/citation/CBB001031081/)

Article Kohring, Matthias; Matthes, Jörg; (2002)
The Face(t)s of Biotech in the Nineties: How the German Press Framed Modern Biotechnology (/isis/citation/CBB000200069/)

Article Bowman, Diana M.; Hodge, Graeme A.; Binks, Peter; (2007)
Are We Really the Prey? Nanotechnology as Science and Science Fiction (/isis/citation/CBB000720388/)

Article Schwartz, Matthias; (2013)
How Nauchnaia Fantastika Was Made: The Debates about the Genre of Science Fiction from NEP to High Stalinism (/isis/citation/CBB001201410/)

Book Kripal, Jeffrey J.; (2011)
Mutants and Mystics: Science Fiction, Superhero Comics, and the Paranormal (/isis/citation/CBB001201217/)

Article Sarantakes, Nicholas Evan; (2005)
Cold War Pop Culture and the Image of U.S. Foreign Policy: The Perspective of the Original Star Trek Series (/isis/citation/CBB000670574/)

Article Frank, Scott; (2003)
Reel Reality: Science Consultants in Hollywood (/isis/citation/CBB000640419/)

Article Jessica Dickson; (2016)
Do Cyborgs Desire Their Own Subjection? Thinking Anthropology With Cinematic Science Fiction (/isis/citation/CBB878724770/)

Article Gepper, Alexander C. T.; (2012)
Extraterrestrial Encounters: UFOs, Science and the Quest for Transcendence, 1947--1972 (/isis/citation/CBB001211878/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}