Thesis ID: CBB001560733

Science and Conscience: An Ethnography of Stem Cells, Bioethics, and Citizenship in Germany (2006)

unapi

Sperling, Stefan (Author)


Princeton University
Borneman, John


Publication Date: 2006
Edition Details: Advisor: Borneman, John
Physical Details: 552 pp.
Language: English

This dissertation seeks to explain ethnographically the emergence of German bioethics around a national debate on stem cell research. In early 2000, German politicians and scientists seized on the stem cell debate as an opportunity to reinvigorate a nation seen as aging, incapable of innovation, and mired in memories of the past. Yet, in spite of efforts to break free of a paralyzing sense of history, German policy on stem cells, at least to start with, virtually stifled research. To examine this paradox in detail, the dissertation is organized into seven chapters that combine ethnographic observation with explorations of Germany as a site of memory and of history in the making. Following a brief prologue, the first chapter reflects on what it means to be a native anthropologist in a culture that, in consequence of its 20{super}th{/super} century history, desperately strives to be 'not other'. Two subsequent chapters are based on fieldwork in a parliamentary bioethics commission whose primary mandate was to prepare legislators for regulating the perceived rapid progress in the life sciences. These show how a discourse on the definitions of early life and human dignity became interwoven with questions of who can claim to speak legitimately, i.e., _ethically_, about matters of national moral significance. Two succeeding chapters analyze the production of a moral dialogue between state and citizens by tracing both ethnographically and historically the tropes of 'transparency' and 'conscience.' There I show just how the state works at making itself publicly visible to its citizens, while at the same time enforcing a similar 'transparency' from its subjects in matters of private moral reasoning. I demonstrate how questions of visibility are inflected through inherited, culturally specific understandings of public and private reason. A chapter on post-reunification Germany describes the nation's attempts to integrate (or, as I argue, erase) divergent East German traditions of transparency, conscience, and bioethics. I close with an assessment of the criteria of ethical research incorporated into current law and policy on German stem cell research. Besides my ethnographic fieldwork as a participant- observer with a bioethics commission, I conducted numerous interviews with physicians, stem cell researchers, bioethicists and philosophers, and I attended several conferences designed to communicate science to the public. I also observed media reporting of relevant scientific and bioethical developments and several other controversies of public conscience that occurred during that period. In writing up my results, however, I became increasingly convinced of the need to supplement these observations with an inquiry into Germany's ongoing struggle to discipline its own past. My dissertation accordingly is in part about bioethics as a culturally specific site of writing, or rewriting, German history.

...More

Description On the emergence of German bioethics after 2000 when national debate on stem cell research highlighted the tension between the desire to reinvigorate the aging nation and historical policies that stifled research. Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 67/02 (2006): 617. UMI pub. no. 3208898.


Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001560733/

Similar Citations

Article Medeiros, Flavia Natercia da Silva; (2013)
Fora da ordem natural: a natureza nos discursos sobre a clonagem e a pesquisa com células-tronco em jornais brasileiros (/isis/citation/CBB001420696/)

Book Banchoff, Thomas F.; (2011)
Embryo Politics: Ethics and Policy in Atlantic Democracies (/isis/citation/CBB001212716/)

Article Weingart, Peter; Salzmann, Christian; Wörmann, Stefan; (2008)
The Social Embedding of Biomedicine: An Analysis of German Media Debates 1995--2004 (/isis/citation/CBB000930612/)

Book Rose, Hilary; Rose, Steven P. R.; (2012)
Genes, Cells, and Brains: The Promethean Promises of the New Biology (/isis/citation/CBB001551411/)

Article Almeida, Carla; DalCol, Franciane Lovati; Massarani, Luisa; (2013)
Controvérsia científica no telejornalismo brasileiro: um estudo sobre a cobertura das células-tronco no Jornal Nacional (/isis/citation/CBB001420697/)

Book Katrien Devolder; (2015)
The Ethics of Embryonic Stem Cell Research (/isis/citation/CBB814523071/)

Book Sperling, Stefan; (2013)
Reasons of Conscience: The Bioethics Debate in Germany (/isis/citation/CBB001450247/)

Book Ong, Aihwa; Chen, Nancy N.; (2011)
Asian Biotech: Ethics and Communities of Fate (/isis/citation/CBB001023125/)

Book Charis Thompson; (2013)
Good Science: The Ethical Choreography of Stem Cell Research (/isis/citation/CBB157943209/)

Article Maria Rosa Montinari; (2020)
Adult stem cells in cardiovascular medicine: historical overview and ethical issues (/isis/citation/CBB295820660/)

Article Cooper, Melinda; (2003)
Rediscovering the Immortal Hydra: Stem Cells and the Question of Epigenesis (/isis/citation/CBB000500941/)

Book Fagan, Melinda Bonnie; (2013)
Philosophy of Stem Cell Biology: Knowledge in Flesh and Blood (/isis/citation/CBB001420098/)

Thesis Ellison, Brooke Mackenzie; (2012)
Life Lines: Stem Cell Research in a Globalized World (/isis/citation/CBB001562809/)

Article Maehle, Andreas-Holger; (2011)
Ambiguous Cells: The Emergence of the Stem Cell Concept in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries (/isis/citation/CBB001220424/)

Book Eugeniusz Nowak; Brian Hillcoat; (2018)
Biologists in the Age of Totalitarianism (/isis/citation/CBB452565241/)

Book Eugenio Lecaldano; (2021)
Identità personale: Storia e critica di un’idea (/isis/citation/CBB940829141/)

Book Sophia Roosth; (2017)
Synthetic: How Life Got Made (/isis/citation/CBB671229087/)

Authors & Contributors
Mikami, Koichi
Brian Hillcoat
Devolder, Katrien
Montinari, Maria Rosa
Eugeniusz Nowak
Roosth, Sophia
Concepts
Biology and ethics; bioethics
Stem cells
Science and politics
Biology
Medicine and ethics
Biotechnology
Time Periods
21st century
20th century, late
20th century
19th century
Early modern
20th century, early
Places
Germany
South Korea
Singapore
United States
China
Great Britain
Institutions
International Bioethics Committee (UNESCO)
Human Genome Project
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment