O'Donnell, Sean Tath (Author)
Harvard University
Harrington, Anne
Edition Details: Advisor: Harrington, Anne
Physical Details: 430 pp.
Language: English
This thesis presents a social history of the most cited case in the American field of law and science-- Frye v. U.S. (1923). This case set the standard of "general acceptance" for the admission of novel scientific evidence and denied admission of the Martson deception test--a lie detector test. The thesis draws from various areas of research: the history of psychology and physiology; sociology of science; critical legal history; science studies; and critical race theory--in order to reclaim and contextualize the history of Frye. Chapter 1 covers the technologies of the common law that prepared Frye for legal consumption and its subsequent seventy-year trajectory through American law. The Second Part (Ch. 2-6) re-embeds the story of Frye into the local communities from which it emerged. First, Frye is situated in the divided streets of Washington D.C. amidst the race and class struggles that heightened after the Great War and the Great Migration. Second, Marston's science is situated in the nascent fields of the New Psychology and legal psychology and located within Hugo Münsterberg's Harvard Psychological Laboratory, where his work was enlisted during the Red Scare to analyze its first black subjects. Third, it follows the case and Marston's science into the local courts where several crises in racial politics ignited simultaneously: the Red Summer of 1919; the enforcement of Jim Crow; restrictive covenants; and issues of racial identity in physical anthropology. Concurrently, the thesis tracks the triangulation of law-science-race, as Marston challenged the law's legitimacy by confronting the truth-telling technologies of the law: the judge; jury; cross-examination; and evidence law. Simultaneously, the thesis traces the instantiation of fear (racial/social/political) through multiple sites: the psychological body and mind; laboratory; courtroom and state. The thesis concludes by comparing the disparate treatment of scientific evidence in a case decided on the same day as Frye, Laney v. U.S. (1923). Accordingly, the thesis asserts that Frye was a "tradeoff" in the racial politics of the court and, in turn, notes the ease with which the court constructed scientific standards to meet its own social and political needs.
...MoreDescription “Frye v. U.S. (1923) ... set the standard of `general acceptance' for the admission of novel scientific evidence and denied admission of the Martson deception test---a lie detector test.” (from the abstract) Cited in Diss. Abstr. Int. A 68/10 (2008). Pub. no. AAT 3285520.
Similar Citations
Book
Kaye, David H.;
(2010)
The Double Helix and the Law of Evidence
(/isis/citation/CBB001020026/)
Book
Clarke, George;
(2007)
Justice and Science: Trials and Triumphs of DNA Evidence
(/isis/citation/CBB000950223/)
Book
Aronson, Jay D.;
(2007)
Genetic Witness: Science, Law, and Controversy in the Making of DNA Profiling
(/isis/citation/CBB000950221/)
Article
Alder, Ken;
(2007)
America's Two Gadgets: Of Bombs and Polygraphs
(/isis/citation/CBB000741721/)
Book
Williams, Chris A.;
(2011)
Police and Policing in the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB001213013/)
Article
Alder, Ken;
(2002)
A social history of untruth: Lie detectors and trust in twentieth-century America
(/isis/citation/CBB001180838/)
Article
Dewsbury, Donald A.;
(2002)
The Role of Evidence in Interpretations of the Scientific Work of Karl Lashley
(/isis/citation/CBB000202773/)
Book
Achinstein, Peter;
(2005)
Scientific Evidence: Philosophical Theories and Applications
(/isis/citation/CBB000550211/)
Article
Hammack, Phillip L.;
Windell, Eric P.;
(2011)
Psychology and the Politics of Same-Sex Desire in the United States: An Analysis of Three Cases
(/isis/citation/CBB001220665/)
Article
Pickersgill, Martyn;
(February 2013)
How personality became treatable: The mutual constitution of clinical knowledge and mental health law
(/isis/citation/CBB252103230/)
Book
Bunn, Geoffrey C.;
(2012)
The Truth Machine: A Social History of the Lie Detector
(/isis/citation/CBB001210071/)
Book
Rembis, Michael A.;
(2011)
Defining Deviance: Sex, Science, and Delinquent Girls, 1890--1960
(/isis/citation/CBB001212457/)
Article
Peres, Maria Fernanda Tourinho;
Nery Filho, Antônio;
(2002)
A doença mental no direito penal brasileiro: inimputabilidade, irresponsabilidade, periculosidade e medida de segurança
(/isis/citation/CBB000300946/)
Article
Shapiro, Barbara J.;
(2002)
Testimony in Seventeenth-Century English Natural Philosophy: Legal Origins and Early Development
(/isis/citation/CBB000202876/)
Book
Bell, Andrew;
Swenson-Wright, John;
Tybjerg, Karin;
(2008)
Evidence
(/isis/citation/CBB000951992/)
Book
Darr, Orna Alyagon;
(2011)
Marks of an Absolute Witch: Evidentiary Dilemmas in Early Modern England
(/isis/citation/CBB001201901/)
Article
Annemarie Kinzelbach;
J. Andrew Mendelsohn;
(2017)
Common Knowledge: Bodies, Evidence, and Expertise in Early Modern Germany
(/isis/citation/CBB656064450/)
Article
Karallus, Christine;
(2005)
Zwischen Kriminalistik und Justiz. Zur Konjunktur der Fotografie als Evindenzstrategie
(/isis/citation/CBB000670819/)
Article
Malin, Brenton J.;
(2009)
Mediating Emotion: Technology, Social Science, and Emotion in the Payne Fund Motion-Picture Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB000951928/)
Book
Faigman, David L.;
(2004)
Laboratory of Justice: The Supreme Court's 200-Year Struggle to Integrate Science and the Law
(/isis/citation/CBB000641661/)
Be the first to comment!