On a Not So Chance Encounter of Neurophilosophy and Science Studies in a Sleep Laboratory (2015)
This article was inspired by participant observation of a contemporary collaboration between empirically oriented philosophers of mind and neuroscientists. An encounter between this anthropologist of science and neurophilosophers in a Finnish sleep laboratory led to the following philosophical exploration of the intellectual space shared by neurophilosophy and science studies. Since these fields emerged in the 1970s, scholars from both sides have been visiting brain research facilities, but engaged with neuroscientists very differently and passionately fought with each other over the reduction of mind to brain. As a case in point, this article looks at the philosophical controversy over the dreaming brain. It serves as a window on the problem space opened up by the demise of positivist conceptions of science, now inhabited by both neurophilosophy and science studies. Both fields face the problem of how to bridge the gap between empirical research and conceptual work. At a time when ontological speculation has made a comeback in these areas of research, studies on how epistemic objects manifest themselves in the material culture of neuroscience could help neurophilosophers to become better materialists. In the sleep laboratory, however, the materiality of dreams continues to be elusive. In dreaming science studies and neurophilosophy encounter a phenomenon that -- at least in 2015 -- still invites a positivist rather than a materialist attitude.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Siemsen, Hayo;
(2011)
Ernst Mach and the Epistemological Ideas Specific for Finnish Science Education
(/isis/citation/CBB001032750/)
Article
Youjung Shin;
(2022)
The transnational move of interdisciplinarity: Ginseng and the beginning of neuroscience in South Korea, 1970–1990s
(/isis/citation/CBB101505766/)
Article
Youjung Shin;
(2023)
For or against the molecularization of brain science?: Cybernetics, interdisciplinarity, and the unprogrammed beginning of the Neurosciences Research Program at MIT
(/isis/citation/CBB401335998/)
Article
Hunt, Lynn;
(2014)
The Self and Its History
(/isis/citation/CBB001452056/)
Book
Kevin Christopher Elliott;
(2017)
A Tapestry of Values: An Introduction to Values in Science
(/isis/citation/CBB011160599/)
Article
Brooke, John L.;
Larsen, Clark Spencer;
(2014)
The Nurture of Nature: Genetics, Epigenetics, and Environment in Human Biohistory
(/isis/citation/CBB001452051/)
Article
Christophe Schinckus;
(2021)
The Santa Fe Institute and Econophysics: A Possible Genealogy?
(/isis/citation/CBB226941870/)
Article
Daniela K. Helbig;
Maureen A. O’Malley;
(2022)
‘The border problems of science and philosophy’: Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider and post-World War 2 science in Australian academia and society
(/isis/citation/CBB564803300/)
Article
Robert Markley;
(2018)
As If: The Alternative Histories of Literature and Science
(/isis/citation/CBB461733199/)
Book
Peter Harrison;
Paul Tyson;
(2022)
New Directions in Theology and Science: Beyond Dialogue
(/isis/citation/CBB716991718/)
Article
Henrik Thorén;
Line Breian;
(2016)
Stepping stone or stumbling block? Mode 2 knowledge production in sustainability science
(/isis/citation/CBB657683298/)
Book
Sebastian Vehlken;
(2019)
Zootechnologies: A Media History of Swarm Research
(/isis/citation/CBB504746255/)
Article
Baird, Davis;
Schummer, Joachim;
(2004)
Editorial
(/isis/citation/CBB000600063/)
Book
Wright, Edmond Leo;
(2008)
The Case for Qualia
(/isis/citation/CBB000951781/)
Article
Virues-Ortega, Javier;
Hurtado-Parrado, Camilo;
Martin, Toby L.;
Julio, Flávia;
(2012)
Psycho-neural Identity as the Basis for Empirical Research and Theorization in Psychology: An Interview with Mario A. Bunge
(/isis/citation/CBB001252233/)
Article
Scerri, Eric R.;
(2000)
Philosophy of chemistry--a new interdisciplinary field?
(/isis/citation/CBB000110183/)
Book
Globus, Gordon G.;
(2003)
Quantum Closures and Disclosures: Thinking-Together Postphenomenology and Quantum Brain Dynamics
(/isis/citation/CBB000320266/)
Thesis
Tschaepe, Mark Dietrich;
(2008)
Mechanistic Explanations at Work: Accounting for Pragmatic Considerations in Science and Philosophy
(/isis/citation/CBB001560820/)
Article
Cory Wright;
Matteo Colombo;
Alexander Beard;
(2017)
HIT and brain reward function: A case of mistaken identity (theory)
(/isis/citation/CBB272128790/)
Chapter
Dinis, Alfredo;
(2008)
Has Neuroscience Any Theological Consequences?
(/isis/citation/CBB000951671/)
Be the first to comment!