Nicolai, Roel (Author)
Isis: International Review Devoted to the History of Science and Its Cultural Influences
Volume: 106, no. 3
Issue: 3
Pages: 517-543
Portolan charts are highly realistic medieval charts that show remarkably accurate coastlines of the Mediterranean and the Black Sea. They emerged suddenly, without any predecessors or a clear developmental path, in Italy during the thirteenth century. There is broad scholarly agreement that these charts are original creations of European medieval culture. However, corroborating evidence is lacking, and a convincing explanation of the method of their construction has so far not been provided. In this essay it is demonstrated by means of geodetic analysis that the overall shape of the coastlines corresponds closely to that on a modern map based on the Mercator projection. It is further demonstrated that this correspondence cannot possibly be due to chance. Consequently, the existence of a Mercator or Mercator-like map projection on portolan charts is incompatible with the assumed medieval origin of these charts. Portolan charts are far more sophisticated than has hitherto been recognized. Their construction was well beyond the capabilities of cartographers from either medieval Europe or the Arabic-Islamic world. This conclusion serves to reopen the question of the origins of the geometric data and the construction methods that until now have appeared to underlie medieval portolan charts.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Book
Tarek Kahlaoui;
(2018)
Creating the Mediterranean: Maps and the Islamic Imagination
(/isis/citation/CBB188888427/)
Chapter
Emilie Savage-Smith;
(2014)
Cartography
(/isis/citation/CBB538584160/)
Chapter
Patricia Seed;
(2015)
Unpasted: A Guide to Surviving Prints of Mercator’s Nautical Chart of 1569
(/isis/citation/CBB098106728/)
Book
Roel Nicolai;
(2016)
The Enigma of the Origin of Portolan Charts: A Geodetic Analysis of the Hypothesis of a Medieval Origin
(/isis/citation/CBB372996128/)
Article
Ingrid Houssaye Michienzi;
Emmanuelle Vagnon;
(2019)
Commissioning and Use of Charts Made in Majorca c.1400: New Evidence from a Tuscan Merchant’s Archive
(/isis/citation/CBB089270825/)
Article
Joaquim Alves Gaspar;
(2019)
The Liber de existencia riveriarum (c.1200) and the Birth of Nautical Cartography
(/isis/citation/CBB771662230/)
Article
Roel Nicolai;
(2021)
The Map Projection of Portolan Charts
(/isis/citation/CBB065271041/)
Book
Yossef Rapoport;
(2020)
Islamic Maps
(/isis/citation/CBB678112778/)
Article
Paul Fermon;
(2018)
The Traditions of Geometrical Representation and the Rise of Local Mapmaking in the Pontifical City of Avignon (14th-15th Centuries)
(/isis/citation/CBB793995750/)
Chapter
Peter van der Krogt;
(2015)
Gerhard Mercator and his Cosmography: How the “Atlas” became an Atlas
(/isis/citation/CBB487622403/)
Chapter
Jan de Graeve;
(2015)
The Scientific Library of Gerhard Mercator
(/isis/citation/CBB758557171/)
Article
Jakub Niedźwiedź;
(2019)
Mercator's Lithuanian–Russian Borderlands: Russiae pars amplificata (1595) and Its Polish Sources
(/isis/citation/CBB669501474/)
Chapter
Marica Milanesi;
(2015)
“Intentio Totius Cosmographiae”
(/isis/citation/CBB711427460/)
Book
Gerhard Holzer;
Valerie Newby;
Petra Svatek;
George Zotti;
(2015)
A World of Innovation: Cartography in the Time of Gerhard Mercator
(/isis/citation/CBB535808156/)
Book
Horst, Thomas;
(2012)
Die Welt als Buch - Gerhard Mercator und der erste Weltatlas Bildband anlässlich der Faksimilierung des Mercatoratlas von 1595 der Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin - Preußischer Kulturbesitz
(/isis/citation/CBB001551642/)
Thesis
Michele D. Abee;
(2019)
The Mercator Projection: Its Uses, Misuses, and Its Association with Scientific Information and the Rise of Scientific Societies
(/isis/citation/CBB047660442/)
Article
Michele Abee;
(2021)
The Spread of the Mercator Projection in Western European and United States Cartography
(/isis/citation/CBB170496665/)
Book
d'Hollander, Raymond;
(2005)
Loxodromie et projection de Mercator
(/isis/citation/CBB000772068/)
Article
Zuber, Mike A.;
(2011)
The Armchair Discovery of the Unknown Southern Continent: Gerardus Mercator, Philosophical Pretensions and a Competitive Trade
(/isis/citation/CBB001220183/)
Chapter
Helga Hühnel;
(2015)
“Geographica” from the First Half of the 16th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB780036402/)
Be the first to comment!