The Surgical Elimination of Violence? Conflicting Attitudes towards Technology and Science during the Psychosurgery Controversy of the 1970s (2015)
Casey, Brian P. (Author)
Casper, Stephen T. (Author)
Science in Context
Volume: 28, no. 1
Issue: 1
Pages: 99-129
Edition Details: Part of a Series: Of Means and Ends: Mind and Brain Science in the Twentieth Century
Language: English
In the 1970s a public controversy erupted over the proposed use of brain operations to curtail violent behavior. Civil libertarians, civil rights and community activists, leaders of the anti-psychiatry movement, and some U.S. Congressmen charged psychosurgeons and the National Institute of Mental Health, with furthering a political project: the suppression of dissent. Several government-sponsored investigations into psychosurgery rebutted this charge and led to an official qualified endorsement of the practice while calling attention to the need for more "scientific" understanding and better ethical safeguards. This paper argues that the psychosurgery debate of the 1970s was more than a power struggle between members of the public and the psychiatric establishment. The debate represented a clash between a postmodern skepticism about science and renewed focus on ultimate ends, on the one hand, and a modern faith in standards and procedures, a preoccupation with means, on the other. These diverging commitments made the dispute ultimately irresolvable.
...MoreArticle Casper, Stephen T. (2015) Of Means and Ends: Mind and Brain Science in the Twentieth Century. Science in Context (pp. 1-7).
Similar Citations
Article
Weidman, Nadine;
(2011)
Popularizing the Ancestry of Man: Robert Ardrey and the Killer Instinct
(/isis/citation/CBB001034550/)
Thesis
Ethan Czuy Levine;
(2018)
Studying Rape: The Production of Scientific Knowledge about Sexual Violence in the United States and Canada
(/isis/citation/CBB208363097/)
Article
Hissei Imai;
Yusuke Ogawa;
Kiyohito Okumiya;
Kozo Matsubayashi;
(2019)
Amok: a mirror of time and people. A historical review of literature
(/isis/citation/CBB352650465/)
Article
Häberlen, Joachim C;
Spinney, Russell A;
(2014)
Introduction: “Emotions in Protest Movements in Europe since 1917“
(/isis/citation/CBB001550386/)
Book
Courtney E. Thompson;
(2021)
An Organ of Murder: Crime, Violence, and Phrenology in Nineteenth-Century America
(/isis/citation/CBB576199907/)
Book
Elizabeth Suzanne Kassab;
(2019)
Enlightenment on the Eve of Revolution: The Egyptian and Syrian Debates
(/isis/citation/CBB348340319/)
Article
Mennill, Sally;
Strong-Boag, Veronica;
(2008)
Identifying Victims: Child Abuse and Death in Canadian Families
(/isis/citation/CBB000933081/)
Book
Ana Antic;
(2017)
Therapeutic Fascism: Experiencing the Violence of the Nazi New Order
(/isis/citation/CBB586129991/)
Article
Ruberg, Willemijn;
(2013)
Trauma, Body, and Mind: Forensic Medicine in Nineteenth-Century Dutch Rape Cases
(/isis/citation/CBB001200306/)
Book
Susan A. Ashley;
(2018)
“Misfits” in Fin-de-Siècle France and Italy: Anatomies of Difference
(/isis/citation/CBB632805594/)
Article
McCall, Tom;
(2006)
Society---“A Gang of Murderers”: Freud on Hostility and War
(/isis/citation/CBB000641258/)
Article
Antonio Rostagno;
(2019)
Salomania: "Perturbing Detour" or "New Mentality"?
(/isis/citation/CBB389033115/)
Book
Jinee Lokaneeta;
(2020)
The Truth Machines: Policing, Violence, and Scientific Interrogations in India
(/isis/citation/CBB848872389/)
Article
Yannis Gansel;
(2019)
Managing difficult and violent adolescents (adolescents difficiles) in France: a genealogical approach
(/isis/citation/CBB300685754/)
Article
Edward Simpson;
Alice Tilche;
Tommaso Sbriccoli;
Patricia Jeffery;
Tina Otten;
(2018)
A Brief History of Incivility in Rural Postcolonial India: Caste, Religion, and Anthropology
(/isis/citation/CBB401089251/)
Article
Joanna Bourke;
(2018)
Police Surgeons and Victims of Rape: Cultures of Harm and Care
(/isis/citation/CBB575076685/)
Book
Richard E. Tremblay;
(2021)
The Science of Violent Behavior Development and Prevention: Contributions of the Second World War Generation
(/isis/citation/CBB868573613/)
Article
Jiow, Hee Jhee;
Lim, Sun Sun;
(2012)
The Evolution of Video Game Affordances and Implications for Parental Mediation
(/isis/citation/CBB001321152/)
Thesis
Nielsen, Katherine;
(2002)
Knowledge, discovery, violence, and ethics: Technique embodied in martial arts and physics in the nuclear age
(/isis/citation/CBB001562164/)
Article
Ticktin, Miriam;
(2011)
The Gendered Human of Humanitarianism: Medicalising and Politicising Sexual Violence
(/isis/citation/CBB001212656/)
Be the first to comment!