Article ID: CBB001551787

Historical and Epistemological Reflections on the Culture of Machines around the Renaissance: Machines, Machineries and Perpetual Motion (2015)

unapi

This paper is the second part of our recent paper `Historical and Epistemological Reflections on the Culture of Machines around the Renaissance: How Science and Technique Work' (Pisano & Bussotti 2014a). In the first paper---which discussed some aspects of the relations between science and technology from Antiquity to the Renaissance---we highlighted the differences between the Aristotelian/Euclidean tradition and the Archimedean tradition. We also pointed out the way in which the two traditions were perceived around the Renaissance. The Archimedean tradition is connected with machines: its relationship with science and construction of machines should be made clear. It is enough to think that Archimedes mainly dealt with three machines: lever, pulley and screw (and a correlated principle of mechanical advantage). As underlined in the first part, our thesis is that many machines were constructed by people who ignored theory, even though, in other cases, the knowledge of the Archimedean tradition was a precious help in order to build machines. Hence, an a priori idea as to the relations between the Archimedean tradition and construction of machines cannot exist. In this second part we offer some examples of functioning machines constructed by people who ignored any physical theory, whereas, in other cases, the ignorance of some principles---such as the impossibility of a perpetuum mobile---induced the attempt to construct impossible machines. What is very interesting is that these machines did not function, of course, as a perpetuum mobile, but anyway had their functioning and were useful for certain aims, although they were constructed on an idea which is completely wrong from a theoretical point of view. We mainly focus on the Renaissance and early modern period, but we also provide examples of machines built before and after this period. We have followed a chronological order in both parts, starting from the analysis of the situation in ancient Greece. Therefore, in the first part, we have examined the relations between the Aristotelian/Euclidean and Archimedean traditions from ancient Greece to the early modern age. In this second part, we analyse the relations of Archimedean tradition/ construction of machines from ancient Greece to the 19th century, focusing on the mentioned period. We remind the reader that our aim is to prove an epistemological thesis, not to provide a complete historical endeavour. As a correlated article, the reader will find three previous paragraphs in the first above-mentioned article (Pisano & Bussotti, 2014a).

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001551787/

Similar Citations

Chapter Emilio Chirone; (2014)
Note sulla storia del disegno di macchine (/isis/citation/CBB046114968/)

Chapter Gianfrancesco Biggioggero; Edoardo Rovida; (2014)
Scuole di meccanica (/isis/citation/CBB862923043/)

Book Virginio Cantoni; Vittorio Marchis; Edoardo Rovida; (2014)
Storia della Meccanica (/isis/citation/CBB405054620/)

Article Laird, Walter Roy; (2010)
The Sources of Francesco Maurolico's Ex Heronis et aliorum spiritalibus (/isis/citation/CBB001034310/)

Book Manni, Paola; Biffi, Marco; (2011)
Glossario Leonardiano: Nomenclatura delle macchine nei codici di Madrid e Atlantico (/isis/citation/CBB001024854/)

Chapter Grafton, Anthony; (2007)
The Devil as Automaton: Giovanni Fontana and the Meanings of a Fifteenth-Century Machine (/isis/citation/CBB000774723/)

Book Rossella Paternò; Faustolo Rambelli; (2022)
L'uomo subacqueo nei manoscritti del Quattrocento (/isis/citation/CBB581777933/)

Book Andrea Bernardoni; (2020)
Leonardo ingegnere (/isis/citation/CBB332632638/)

Article Marshall, E. L.; (2009)
The Quest for Thermodynamic Efficiency: Atkinson Cycle Machines versus Otto Cycle Machines (/isis/citation/CBB001231644/)

Book Gitelman, Lisa; (1999)
Scripts, Grooves, and Writing Machines: Representing Technology in the Edison Era (/isis/citation/CBB000111814/)

Article Moon, Francis C.; (2003)
Robert Willis and Franz Reuleaux: Pioneers in the Theory of Machines (/isis/citation/CBB000470293/)

Chapter Roberto C. Garberi; (2014)
L’evoluzione della tecnologia dell’ala rotante e il contributo di Agusta Westland (/isis/citation/CBB484250053/)

Chapter Piergiorgio Laverda; (2022)
Le macchine per mietere nelle campagne italiane dell'Ottocento (/isis/citation/CBB744516847/)

Chapter Francesco Tozzi Spadoni; (2014)
Sintesi storica dello sviluppo della tecnologia tessile (/isis/citation/CBB643549977/)

Article Wally Smith; (2015)
Echnologies of Stage Magic: Simulation and Dissimulation (/isis/citation/CBB846708658/)

Chapter Attilio Selvini; Peter Dannecker; (2014)
La meccanica delle armi da fuoco portatili (/isis/citation/CBB976001827/)

Article Bromley, Allan G.; (2000)
Babbage's Analytical Engine Plans 28 and 28a-The Programmer's Interface (/isis/citation/CBB000112010/)

Authors & Contributors
Rovida, Edoardo
Moon, Francis C.
Dannecker, Peter
Spadoni, Francesco Tozzi
Selvini, Attilio
Faustolo Rambelli
Concepts
Machines
Technology
Engineering
Mechanics
Science and industry
Industry
Time Periods
19th century
Renaissance
20th century
15th century
Early modern
21st century
Places
Italy
Germany
France
Europe
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment