IsisCB Explore

Article ID: CBB001551169

Sugar in Mid-twentieth-century Australia: A Bittersweet Tale of Behaviour, Economics, Politics and Dental Health (2015)

Akers, H. F. (Author)
Foley, M. A. (Author)
Ford, P. J. (Author)
Ryan, L. P. (Author)

Historical Records of Australian Science
Volume: 26, no. 1
Issue: 1
Pages: 20-35

Outside Links

PubMed

WorldCat

Google Scholar

JSTOR

Academia.edu

Dental hygiene Dentistry Public health Economics Medicine and politics Sugar and sugar industry 20th century, late Australia

History is replete with debates between health professionals with concerns about practices and products and others who either challenge scientific evidence or believe that the greatest public good is achieved through maintenance of the status quo. This paper provides a 1950s socio-scientific perspective on a recurring problem for health professionals. It analyses dentists' promotion of oral health by discouraging sugar consumption and the sugar industry's defence of its staple product. Despite scientific evidence in support of its case, the dental profession lacked influence with government and large sections of the Australian community. The division of powers within the Australian Constitution, together with the cause, nature and ubiquity of caries and Australians' tolerance of the disease, were relevant to the outcome. In contrast, the sugar industry was a powerful force. Sugar was a pillar of the Australian and Queensland economies. The industry contributed to the history of Queensland and to Queenslanders' collective psyche, and enjoyed access to centralized authority in decision-making. The timing of the debate was also relevant. Under Prime Minister Robert Menzies, the Australian Government was more concerned with promoting industry and initiative than oral health. This was a one-sided contest. Patterns of food consumption evolve from interactions between availability, culture and choice. Food and associated etiquettes provide far more than health, nutrients and enjoyment. They contribute to economic and social development, national and regional identity and the incidence of disease. The growing, milling and processing of sugarcane and the incorporation of sugar into the Australian diet is a case study that illuminates the interface between health professionals, corporations, society and the state. Today, for a variety of reasons, health professionals recommend limits for daily intake of sugar. Calls for dietary reform are not new and invariably arouse opposition. The issue came to the fore between 1945 and 1960, when dentists contended that the consumption of sugar either caused or contributed to a major health problem, namely dental caries (tooth decay). Representatives of the sugar industry defended their staple product against these claims, which emerged at a critical time for the industry. With hindsight, these exchanges can be seen as a precursor to more diverse and recurring debates relating to contemporary health campaigns. This paper documents and analyses the contemporaneous scientific and socio-political backgrounds underpinning these engagements

...More

Citation URI

https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001551169/

Citations Indexes

Similar Citations

Article Catherine Carstairs; (2015)
The Environmental Critique of Water Fluoridation (/isis/citation/CBB164063111/)

Article Millstein, Charles B.; (2008)
Technology Transfer: Kuwait---A Quarter-Century of Progress (/isis/citation/CBB001210506/)

Article Queiroz, Maria Goretti; Dourado, Luiz Fernandes; (2009)
O ensino da odontologia no Brasil: uma leitura com base nas recomendações e nos encontros internacionais da década de 1960 (/isis/citation/CBB000932985/)

Book Marshall J. Becker; Jean MacIntosh Turfa; (2017)
The Etruscans and the History of Dentistry: The Golden Smile through the Ages (/isis/citation/CBB426588616/)

Article Baltacioglu, Ali; Baltacioglu, Ismail Hakki; (2009/2010)
Türkiye'de Dis Hekimligi Egitim ve Ögretimi (1908--1933) (/isis/citation/CBB001220723/)

Article Marloes Rijkelijkhuizen; Reina de Raat; (2016)
‘Konstige tanden’. Gebitsprothesen van bot en ivoor in Nederlandse collecties (/isis/citation/CBB150505213/)

Article Chernin, David; Shklar, Gerald; (2003)
Levi Spear Parmly: Father of Dental Hygiene and Children's Dentistry in America (/isis/citation/CBB000932357/)

Article Jay, Stephen J.; Christen, Arden G.; (2006)
Leroy E. Burney, MD, MPH: Quiet Champion of American Dentistry and Dental Research at Mid-Century (/isis/citation/CBB001210480/)

Chapter Hoffmann, Susanne; (2011)
Dental Care as a Daily Routine: Popularization and Practice of Prophylactic Dental Hygiene in the German Speaking World, c. 1890--1930 (/isis/citation/CBB001250525/)

Book Goc, Nicolá; (2013)
Women, Infanticide, and the Press, 1822--1922: News Narratives in England and Australia (/isis/citation/CBB001550896/)

Article Cameron-Smith, Alexander; (2010)
Australian Imperialism and International Health in the Pacific Islands (/isis/citation/CBB001030875/)

Book K. Pienaar; (2016)
Politics in the Making of HIV/AIDS in South Africa (/isis/citation/CBB593288041/)

Book Andrew Lakoff; (2017)
Unprepared: Global Health in a Time of Emergency (/isis/citation/CBB434578273/)

Thesis John Robert Whitehurst; (2019)
Health Politics in Cold War America, 1953-1988 (/isis/citation/CBB215678564/)

Article Virginia Berridge; (2022)
The Many Endings of Recent Epidemics: HIV/AIDS, Swine Flu 2009, and Policy (/isis/citation/CBB473200788/)

Book Erika Dyck; Maureen Lux; (2020)
Challenging Choices: Canada's Population Control in the 1970s (/isis/citation/CBB928803182/)

Article Anne Hagen Berg; Stuart S. Blume; (2020)
Reasonable Grounds? The Delayed Introduction of MMR Vaccine in Denmark and the Netherlands, 1977–87 (/isis/citation/CBB482754558/)

Thesis Jones, Ruth J. E.; (2000)
Canada and the United States: An historical and neo-institutional study of public housing and health policies (/isis/citation/CBB001562189/)

Article Sethna, Christabelle; (2006)
The Evolution of the Birth Control Handbook: From Student Peer-Education Manual to Feminist Self-Empowerment Text, 1968--1975 (/isis/citation/CBB000930222/)

Book Moreno, Jonathan D.; Berger, Sam; (2010)
Progress in Bioethics: Science, Policy, and Politics (/isis/citation/CBB001031401/)

Comments

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}