Cassidy, Angela (Author)
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Volume: 37, no. 3
Issue: 3
Pages: 305-325
Edition Details: Part of a Series: Experimentation in Twentieth-Century Agricultural Science
Language: English
Since wild badgers were first connected with outbreaks of bovine TB (bTB) in UK cattle herds in the early 1970s, the question of whether to cull them to control infections in cattle has been the subject of a protracted public and policy controversy. Following the recommendation of Prof. John Krebs that a “scientifically based experimental trial” be carried out to test the effectiveness of badger culling, the Randomised Badger Culling Trial (RBCT) was commissioned by Government in 1998. One of the largest field experiments ever conducted in the UK, the RBCT sought to recreate the conditions of a randomised controlled trial (RCT) across approximately 3000 km2 of the South West of England. Despite widespread expectations that the RBCT would provide the necessary evidence to resolve the controversy, its findings have instead been widely contested and reinterpreted, while arguments over badger culling have become increasingly polarised. This paper will investigate the complexities of field experimental knowledge by following the story of the RBCT from this initial proposal, through processes of research design, implementation, analysis, interpretation and reinterpretation of the findings by multiple actors. It asks what kind of experiment the RBCT actually was, and examines how it has contributed to the protracted controversy over whether to cull badgers in order to control bTB in cattle. Finally, it will explore the wider implications of this case for contemporary debates over the contribution that RCTs can make to formulating public policy.
...MoreArticle Parolini, Giuditta (2015) Charting the History of Agricultural Experiments. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences (pp. 231-241).
Similar Citations
Book
Climerio Paulo da Silva Neto;
(2023)
Materializing the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Instruments and the First Bell Tests
(/isis/citation/CBB450970370/)
Book
Oury, Jean-Paul;
(2006)
La querelle des OGM
(/isis/citation/CBB000772829/)
Article
Theunissen, Bert;
(2008)
Een mooie koe is een goede koe. Wetenschappers en practici over de Nederlandse rundveefokkerij, 1900--1950
(/isis/citation/CBB000950343/)
Article
Slavin, Philip;
(2012)
The Great Bovine Pestilence and Its Economic and Environmental Consequences in England and Wales, 1318--50
(/isis/citation/CBB001320059/)
Article
Grasseni, Cristina;
(2007)
Managing Cows: An Ethnography of Breeding Practices and Uses of Reproductive Technology in Contemporary Dairy Farming in Lombardy (Italy)
(/isis/citation/CBB000701057/)
Article
Theunissen, Bert;
(2012)
Breeding for Nobility or for Production? Cultures of Dairy Cattle Breeding in the Netherlands, 1945--1995
(/isis/citation/CBB001250836/)
Article
Fernando Collantes;
(2019)
Why did the industrial diet triumph? The massification of dairy consumption in Spain, 1965–90
(/isis/citation/CBB245733911/)
Chapter
Grasseni, Cristina;
(2007)
Good Looking: Learning to Be a Cattle Breeder
(/isis/citation/CBB000953727/)
Article
Andreas Folkers;
Sven Opitz;
(June 2022)
Low-carbon cows: From microbial metabolism to the symbiotic planet
(/isis/citation/CBB874316885/)
Article
Bloomfield, Brian P.;
Doolin, Bill;
(February 2011)
Imagination and technoscientific innovations: Governance of transgenic cows in New Zealand
(/isis/citation/CBB278621475/)
Book
Wittering, Shirley;
(2013)
Ecology and Enclosure: The Effect of Enclosure on Society, Farming and the Environment in South Cambridgeshire, 1798--1850
(/isis/citation/CBB001420312/)
Article
García-Sancho, Miguel;
(2015)
Animal Breeding in the Age of Biotechnology: The Investigative Pathway behind the Cloning of Dolly the Sheep
(/isis/citation/CBB001510361/)
Article
Gabriela Soto Laveaga;
(2022)
Rogue Seeds in Disturbed Fields
(/isis/citation/CBB467097261/)
Article
Silva, Indianara;
Freire, Olival, Jr.;
(2013)
The Concept of the Photon in Question: The Controversy Surrounding the HBT Effect circa 1956--1958
(/isis/citation/CBB001213268/)
Article
Weber, Marcel;
(2002)
Incommensurability and Theory Comparison in Experimental Biology
(/isis/citation/CBB000200251/)
Article
García, Pío;
(2015)
Computer Simulations and Experiments: In Vivo-In Vitro Conditions in Biochemistry Source
(/isis/citation/CBB001551376/)
Article
Maite P. Salazar;
Daniel Valenzuela;
Manuel Tironi;
Rodrigo A. Gutiérrez;
(2019)
The ambivalent regulator: The construction of a regulatory style for genetically modified crops in Chile
(/isis/citation/CBB036000701/)
Book
Abby J. Kinchy;
(2012)
Seeds, science, and struggle: The global politics of transgenic crops
(/isis/citation/CBB028923196/)
Article
Heller, Chaia;
(2002)
From Scientific Risk to Paysan Savoir-Faire: Peasant Expertise in the French and Global Debate over GM Crops
(/isis/citation/CBB000200027/)
Thesis
Heller, Chaia L.;
(2005)
From Scientific Risk to Paysan Savoir-Faire: Divergent Rationalities of Science and Society in the French Debate over GM Crops
(/isis/citation/CBB001561883/)
Be the first to comment!