Socio-Technological Disasters and Engineering Expertise in Victorian Britain: The Holmfirth and Sheffield Floods of 1852 and 1864 (2014)
Socio-technological disasters; Floods; Environment; Engineers; Experts Urban and environmental historians are becoming increasingly interested in the social construction of expertise in the management and control of natural resources. Experts are often depicted as disinterested, neutral and objective professionals, sufficiently qualified to gauge an independent perspective on a given problem. Yet what happens when an expert's judgment is called into question by other professional experts? The micro-analysis of socio-technological disasters offers one way to interrogate the construction and challenge of professional expertise at both the empirical and conceptual levels. Taking a comparative approach towards the study of two major reservoir failures involving considerable death and destruction in the United Kingdom -- Holmfirth in 1852 and Sheffield in 1864 -- this paper draws on the under-utilised research of the sociologist Barry Turner and others on the social aetiology of disasters as a route into revealing and accounting for the contested nature of expertise within the Victorian engineering professions. It is based on extensive archival research, including the written records of local and central government, private waterworks' proprietors, the printed press and the records of public inquiry. The cases reveal remarkable continuities in administrative and professional knowledge regarding the explanation of socio-technological disasters, as well as the widespread use of outside experts to interrogate the supposed failings of interested parties.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Escobar, Maria Paula;
Demeritt, David;
(2014)
Flooding and the Framing of Risk in British Broadsheets, 1985--2010
(/isis/citation/CBB001420076/)
Article
Galloway, James A.;
(2013)
Coastal Flooding and Socioeconomic Change in Eastern England in the Later Middle Ages
(/isis/citation/CBB001421392/)
Article
Baecher, Gregory;
Bensi, Michelle;
Reilly, Allison;
Phillips, Brian;
Link, Lewis (Ed);
Knight, Sandra;
Galloway, Gerald D.;
(Summer 2019)
Resiliently Engineered Flood and Hurricane Infrastructure: Principles to Guide the Next Generation of Engineers
(/isis/citation/CBB715018066/)
Book
Todd M. Kerstetter;
(2018)
Flood on the tracks : Living, dying, and the nature of disaster in the Elkhorn River Basin
(/isis/citation/CBB826077353/)
Article
Garden, Donald A.;
(2008)
El Niño, Irrigation Dams and Stopbanks: Examining the Repercussions of the 1876--78 El Niño in Australia and New Zealand
(/isis/citation/CBB000931787/)
Book
Ted Steinberg;
Cindy Ermus;
(2018)
Environmental Disaster in the Gulf South: Two Centuries of Catastrophe, Risk, and Resilience
(/isis/citation/CBB920508154/)
Article
Ewen, Shane;
(2014)
Sheffield's Great Flood of 1864: Engineering Failure and the Municipalisation of Water
(/isis/citation/CBB001421408/)
Article
O'Rourke, T.D.;
(Spring 2007)
Critical Infrastructure, Interdependencies, and Resilience
(/isis/citation/CBB600770004/)
Book
Whayne, Jeannie M.;
(2011)
Delta Empire: Lee Wilson and the Transformation of Agriculture in the New South
(/isis/citation/CBB001200642/)
Book
Karena Kalmbach;
(2021)
The Meanings of a Disaster : Chernobyl and its afterlives in Britain and France
(/isis/citation/CBB315358422/)
Book
Andy Horowitz;
(2020)
Katrina: A History, 1915–2015
(/isis/citation/CBB905816380/)
Article
Catherine Devitt;
Eoin O’Neill;
(2016)
The Framing of Two Major Flood Episodes in the Irish Print News Media: Implications for Societal Adaptation to Living with Flood Risk
(/isis/citation/CBB154893835/)
Article
Elisabetta Novello;
James C. McCann;
(July 2017)
The Building of the Terra Firma: The Political Ecology of Land Reclamation in the Veneto from the Sixteenth through the Twenty-first Century
(/isis/citation/CBB322729907/)
Chapter
Francesco Luzzini;
(2016)
L’Itale Terre a vagheggiare inteso. La regolazione dell’Adige nel XVIII secolo: tra storia e scienza
(/isis/citation/CBB384914552/)
Chapter
Stefano Piazza;
(2021)
Come studiare la storia delle politiche pubbliche sulle acque
(/isis/citation/CBB686723309/)
Book
Carl Middleton;
Elmhirst, Rebecca;
Suphāng Čhanthawānit;
(2019)
Living with floods in a mobile Southeast Asia : A political ecology of vulnerability, migration and environmental change
(/isis/citation/CBB794913693/)
Book
Lucia Masotti;
(2019)
Acque di terraferma : il Padovano : ricerca e progettazione territoriale per la mitigazione del rischio idraulico; (Inland waters: Padua Province: Territorial research and planning for the mitigation of hydraulic risk)
(/isis/citation/CBB560165506/)
Book
Paolo Sorcinelli;
Mihran Tchaprassian;
(2014)
L'alluvione. L'Italia e il Polesine nel 1951
(/isis/citation/CBB934705874/)
Chapter
Leonardo Raito;
(2021)
La gestione del sistema idrico in Polesine. Dall'Ato al Consiglio di Bacino
(/isis/citation/CBB814421528/)
Article
Zhang Jian;
Man, Zhimin;
(2015)
Water Level Measurement and Flood Precautions along the Yellow River in the Qing Dynasty
(/isis/citation/CBB318578788/)
Be the first to comment!