Dynasty, Archaeology and Conservation: The Bourbon Rediscovery of Pompeii and Herculaneum in Eighteenth-Century Naples (2014)
Echlin, Alexander (Author)
Journal of the History of Collections
Volume: 26, no. 2
Issue: 2
Pages: 145-159
The rediscovery of the ancient sites of Pompeii and Herculaneum in the eighteenth century attracted a huge response from contemporary commentators. Many of these, as well as almost all subsequent judgements from historians, are very critical of the Bourbon excavators. Charles, King of Naples, and his team of antiquaries have been depicted as charlatans, treating ancient artefacts and the sites poorly, interested in them only in so far as they glorified their kingdom. In this article it is argued that, with an understanding of contemporary approaches to antiquity and conservation, this verdict on the Bourbons seems unduly harsh. Their archaeological methods and treatment of classical art were typical for the eighteenth century and were, in some ways, progressive. In support of this harsh judgement of Charles, Winckelmann has been portrayed as a savage critic of the excavations; in reality he was kinder to the Bourbons than historians have believed.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Echlin, Alexander;
(2014)
Dynasty, Archaeology and Conservation: The Bourbon Rediscovery of Pompeii and Herculaneum in Eighteenth-Century Naples
(/isis/citation/CBB001421839/)
Chapter
Franco Dell'Aquila;
Francesco Foschino;
Raffaele Paolicelli;
(2020)
Nuove acquisizioni sull'approvvigionamento idrico nel Materano in epoca medievale
(/isis/citation/CBB511377463/)
Article
Delft, Dirk van;
(2013)
Museum Boerhaave en het primaat van de collectie
(/isis/citation/CBB001321088/)
Article
Stanislav Strekopytov;
(2021)
Corrosive sublimate and its introduction as an insecticide for preserving natural history specimens in the eighteenth century
(/isis/citation/CBB822706431/)
Article
Ramos, Paulo Oliveira;
(2014)
The Royal Decree of 1721 and the Ephemeral Archaeological Collection of the Royal Academy of Portuguese History
(/isis/citation/CBB001421842/)
Article
Elena Canadelli;
(2016)
Marble Busts and Fish Fossils: The Catalog of the Museum of naturalia and artificialia at the University of Padua (1797)
(/isis/citation/CBB561990879/)
Chapter
Ashley J. Inglehart;
(2018)
Filippo Buonanni and the Kircher Museum
(/isis/citation/CBB074439858/)
Chapter
Maria Toscano;
(2017)
Giuseppe Saverio Poli as a Collector between Natural History and Antiquarianism
(/isis/citation/CBB463592702/)
Book
Cipriani, Curzio;
Scarpellini, Alba;
(2007)
Un contributo alla mineralogia settecentesca: la collezione di Giovanni Targioni Tozzetti
(/isis/citation/CBB001023749/)
Chapter
Pietro Di Lorenzo;
(2017)
Historical instruments in Caserta and surroundings: collections and museums
(/isis/citation/CBB941786367/)
Book
Sabrina Ferri;
(2015)
Ruins Past: Modernity in Italy, 1744-1836
(/isis/citation/CBB160123196/)
Book
Ciancio, Luca;
(2009)
Le colonne del tempo: Il “tempio di Serapide” a Pozzuoli nella storia della geologia, dell'archeologia e dell'arte (1750--1900)
(/isis/citation/CBB001021269/)
Article
Kuzybaeva, M. P.;
(2010)
Medical Instrument Collections in Russian Museums: Problems of Preservation and Study
(/isis/citation/CBB001211357/)
Article
Maria Fernanda Ferrini;
(2013)
Poeti, filosofi e 'meccanici'. Autori e opere della letteratura greca nelle "Antichità Picene" di Giuseppe Colucci
(/isis/citation/CBB220899527/)
Article
Genovese, A.;
Cocca, T.;
(2000)
Internal organization of an equine stable at Pompei
(/isis/citation/CBB000111310/)
Book
Jashemski, Wilhelmina Mary Feemster;
Meyer, Frederick G.;
(2002)
The Natural History of Pompeii: A Systematic Survey
(/isis/citation/CBB000302241/)
Book
Del Tedesco, Enza;
(2012)
Il "Giornale de’ Letterati d’Italia" trecento anni dopo. Scienza, storia, arte, identità (1710-2010)
(/isis/citation/CBB161313006/)
Book
Bertrand, Gilles;
(2008)
Le grand tour revisité: pour une archéologie du tourisme: le voyage des français en Italie (milieu XVIIIe siècle--début XIXe siècle)
(/isis/citation/CBB001231146/)
Book
Scarth, Alwyn;
(2009)
Vesuvius: A Biography
(/isis/citation/CBB001020592/)
Book
Romer, John;
Romer, Elizabeth;
(2001)
History of Archaeology: Great Excavations of the World
(/isis/citation/CBB000102080/)
Be the first to comment!