Wild Men In and Out of Science: Finding a Place in the Disciplinary Borderlands of Arctic Canada and Greenland (2014)
This essay compares the early twentieth-century Arctic experiences of the artist-naturalist Ernest Thompson Seton (1860--1946) in Canada and the explorer-geologist Lauge Koch (1892--1964) in Greenland during a time of transition in the history of scientific exploration. It focuses on the extraordinary careers of two uneasy contributors to this transition, from both inside and outside of the scientific profession. Seton's and Koch's careers serve as fault-lines marking important disputes over the production and construction of knowledge, and conceptions of scientific truth. Seton, internationally famous author of the `realistic' animal stories Wild Animals I Have Known (1898), endured public criticism as a `nature-faker' who anthropomorphized his animal subjects unduly. Intent on earning recognition as a modern field scientist, he travelled to Canada's Barren Grounds in 1907 to stake new claims to scientific knowledge and field methods. Koch joined the legendary Arctic explorer Knud Rasmussen's Second Thule Expedition (1916--1918) before leading Denmark's Jubilee expedition to North Greenland (1920--1923). He returned to Denmark a national hero whose further expeditions during the 1930s transformed Arctic geological fieldwork, but not without very public challenges from the Danish scientific community. The problems encountered by Seton and Koch in their efforts to establish their field practices in the disciplinary borderlands between traditional natural history and modern ecology and geology, respectively, offer insights, over several generations, into the historical transition from the older Romantic lore of the heroic individual explorer to modern infrastructures and practices. Their responses highlight larger fissures in twentieth-century reconceptions of the Arctic, of nature, and of science at large.
...MoreDescription Compares the early 20th-century Arctic experiences of the artist-naturalist Ernest Seton in Canada and the explorer-geologist Lauge Koch in Greenland.
Article Doel, Ronald E.; Urban, Wråkberg; Zeller, Suzanne (2014) Science, Environment, and the New Arctic. Journal of Historical Geography (p. 2).
Similar Citations
Book
Peter R. Dawes;
(2022)
Expedition Relics from High Arctic Greenland: Eight Decades of Exploration History, Told through 102 Objects
(/isis/citation/CBB344098059/)
Article
Guly, Henry;
(2012)
Dr. Reginald Koettlitz (1860--1916): Arctic and Antarctic Explorer
(/isis/citation/CBB001200783/)
Article
Doel, Ronald E.;
Friedman, Robert Marc;
Lajus, Julia;
Sörline, Sverker;
Wråkberg, Urban;
(2014)
Strategic Arctic Science: National Interests in Building Natural Knowledge---Interwar Era through the Cold War
(/isis/citation/CBB001450344/)
Book
Emil Bessels;
(2016)
Polaris: The Chief Scientist's Recollections of the American North Pole Expedition, 1871-73
(/isis/citation/CBB695538374/)
Book
Byrne, Angela;
(2013)
Geographies of the Romantic North: Science, Antiquarianism, and Travel, 1790--1830
(/isis/citation/CBB001452023/)
Chapter
Bocking, Stephen;
(2013)
Situated yet Mobile: Examining the Environmental History of Arctic Ecological Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001420347/)
Thesis
Stuhl, Andrew;
(2013)
Empires on Ice: Science, Nature, and the Making of the Arctic
(/isis/citation/CBB001567488/)
Article
McCorristine, Shane;
(2013)
“Involuntarily We Listen”: Hearing the Aurora Borealis in Nineteenth-Century Arctic Exploration and Science
(/isis/citation/CBB001320858/)
Article
Krzysztof Ludwik Birkenmajer;
(2017)
Polskie badania polarne (zarys) / Polish Polar Research (Outline)
(/isis/citation/CBB963951811/)
Article
MacEachern, Alan;
(2010)
J.E. Bernier's Claims to Fame
(/isis/citation/CBB001211529/)
Chapter
Ries, Christopher J.;
(2012)
Armchairs, Dogsleds, Ships, and Airplanes: Field Access, Scientific Credibility, and Geological Mapping in Northern and North-Eastern Greenland 1900--1939
(/isis/citation/CBB001210271/)
Thesis
Daniella McCahey;
(2018)
Extreme Environments and the Production of Scientific Knowledge: The History of Science in Antarctica
(/isis/citation/CBB933911142/)
Article
Edward P.F. Rose;
(2019)
Lawrence Rickard Wager (1904-1965): A distinguished geologist who helped to pioneer aerial photographic interpretation for allied forces in World War II
(/isis/citation/CBB693801613/)
Book
John R. Bockstoce;
(2018)
White Fox and Icy Seas in the Western Arctic: The Fur Trade, Transportation, and Change in the Early Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB031576298/)
Article
Froggatt, Peter;
Walker, Brian M.;
(2012)
From Precocious Fame to Mature Obscurity: David Walker (1837--1917) MD, LRSCIi, Surgeon and Naturalist to the Fox Arctic Expedition of 1857--59
(/isis/citation/CBB001200784/)
Article
Bathsheba Demuth;
(2019)
The Walrus and the Bureaucrat: Energy, Ecology, and Making the State in the Russian and American Arctic, 1870–1950
(/isis/citation/CBB042440470/)
Book
Mikanovskij, Evgenij Evgenjevič;
IAnshin, Aleksandr Leonidovich;
(2000)
Al'fred Vegener 1880--1930
(/isis/citation/CBB000358295/)
Article
Guly, H. R.;
(2013)
Scurvy and Other Vitamin Deficiencies during the Heroic Age of Antarctic Exploration
(/isis/citation/CBB001200831/)
Chapter
Yusoff, Kathryn;
(2010)
Configuring the Field: Photography in Early Twentieth-Century Antarctic Exploration
(/isis/citation/CBB001031363/)
Article
Vanessa Heggie;
(2019)
Blood, Race and Indigenous Peoples in Twentieth Century Extreme Physiology
(/isis/citation/CBB404527790/)
Be the first to comment!