Book ID: CBB001422097

Science, Ideology, and the Media: The Cyril Burt Scandal (1991)


Fletcher, Ronald (Author)

Transaction Publishers

Publication Date: 1991
Publication Date: 1991
Physical Details: xxviii + 419 pp.; ill.; bibl.; index
Language: English

In 1976, five years after his death, serious charges were leveled against the distinguished British scientist Sir Cyril Burt. His research on the nature of intelligence was challenged as fraudulent by a number of respected commentators, among them Leon Kamin, Oliver Gillie, Ann and Alan Clarke, and Leslie Hearnshaw. The evidence they marshaled, and the charges themselves are examined here in scrupulous detail. Written as a straightforward defense of Burt, this volume also tells a second story: the intrusion of the mass media into science, the power of the new media, and the success of this invasion, which threatens to replace intellectual authority. Convinced that a great injustice had been done, Fletcher examines each of the charges in detail, subjecting each of Burt's detractors to a symbolic cross-examination. He exposes carelessness and errors of interpretation, and reveals areas of evidence the critics failed to take into account. Each interrogation ends with a list of questions that call for clear public answer. Fletcher's closing argument calls for the restoration of Burt's reputation, so that justice is done. The broader significance of this case study goes far beyond the Burt controversy itself, and has implications for the conduct of science in an increasingly contentious social environment. Fletcher describes how ideology, in alliance with a receptive popular journalism and the media, is able to establish itself as a powerful third force in scientific discourse. The Burt Affair demonstrates what happens when the media establish a viewpoint that permeates not only the scientific community, but also entrenches that perspective so thoroughly in public understanding that its assumptions are not even questioned.

Citation URI

Similar Citations

Article Oliver Hochadel; Miquel Carandell Baruzzi; Clara Florensa; (2016)
Introduction: Scuffles, Scoops and Scams: The Construction of Prehistoric Knowledge in Newspapers (/isis/citation/CBB861425684/)

Article Maddalena Cataldi; (2016)
Inventing the Menton Man. Rivière's Discovery as Reflected in the French Media (/isis/citation/CBB346994538/)

Article Keller, Evelyn Fox; (2011)
What Are Climate Scientists to Do? (/isis/citation/CBB001220693/)

Article Boyd, Amanda D.; Paveglio, Travis B.; (2014)
Front Page or “Buried” beneath the Fold? Media Coverage of Carbon Capture and Storage (/isis/citation/CBB001420073/)

Book Luca Tambolo; (2024)
Il mondo su misura. Introduzione al negazionismo scientifico (/isis/citation/CBB203135051/)

Article Tucker, William H.; (1994)
Fact and fiction in the discovery of Sir Cyril Burt's flaws (/isis/citation/CBB000060192/)

Book Liz Sevcenko; (2022)
Public History for a Post-Truth Era: Fighting Denial through Memory Movements (/isis/citation/CBB650942848/)

Essay Review Mark P. Silverman; (2017)
Scientific Controversies: Authentic and Contrived (/isis/citation/CBB701452514/)

Article Matthew Hayes; Noah Morritt; (2020)
Michael W. Burke-Gaffney and the UFO Debate in Atlantic Canada, 1947-1969 (/isis/citation/CBB417665220/)

Article Oliver Hochadel; (2016)
One Skull and Many Headlines: The Role of the Press in the Steinau Hoax of 1911 (/isis/citation/CBB378365985/)

Essay Review Tverdek, Edward; (2003)
Fool Me Once (/isis/citation/CBB000340762/)

Article Osborne, R.T.; (1990)
Cyril Burt's invariant kinship correlations: Another look (/isis/citation/CBB000035995/)

Book Walsh, Lynda; (2006)
Sins against Science: The Scientific Media Hoaxes of Poe, Twain, and Others (/isis/citation/CBB000931055/)

Article Laura Valls Plana; (2016)
A Mammoth in the Park: Palaeontology, Press and Popular Culture in Barcelona (1870–1910) (/isis/citation/CBB628845058/)

Book Price, Katy; (2012)
Loving Faster Than Light: Romance and Readers in Einstein's Universe (/isis/citation/CBB001250414/)

Article González-Silva, Matiana; Herran, Néstor; (2009)
Ideology, Elitism and Social Commitment: Alternative Images of Science in Two fin de siècle Barcelona Newspapers (/isis/citation/CBB000932326/)

Authors & Contributors
Hochadel, Oliver
Noah Morritt
Mikihito Tanaka
Cataldi, Maddalena
Tambolo, Luca
Liz Sevcenko
Centaurus: International Magazine of the History of Mathematics, Science, and Technology
Spontaneous Generations
Scientia Canadensis: Journal of the History of Canadian Science, Technology, and Medicine
Science Communication
Science as Culture
Science and Society
Codice Edizioni
University of Chicago Press
State University of New York Press
Taylor & Francis
Public understanding of science
Mass media
Controversies and disputes
Science and society
Methods of communication; media
Burt, Cyril Lodowic
Sokal, Alan D.
Poe, Edgar Allan
Kamin, Leon
Gore, Albert
Einstein, Albert
Time Periods
21st century
20th century
20th century, early
19th century
20th century, late
Barcelona (Spain)
United States

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment