Defining a Discovery: Priority and Methodological Controversy in Early Nineteenth-Century Anatomy (2014)
Berkowitz, Carin (Author)
Notes and Records: The Royal Society Journal of the History of Science
Volume: 68, no. 4
Issue: 4
Pages: 357-372
In the early nineteenth century, Charles Bell and François Magendie engaged in a decades-long priority dispute over the discovery of the roots of motor and sensory nerves. The constantly recalibrated arguments of its participants illuminate changes in the life sciences during that period. When Bell first wrote about the nerves in 1811, surgeon-anatomists ran small schools out of their homes, natural theology was in vogue, exchanges between British and French medical practitioners were limited by the Napoleonic Wars, and British practitioners typically rejected experimental physiology and vivisection. By the end of Magendie's career, medical science was produced in the laboratory, taught through artfully produced performances of the sort at which Magendie excelled, and disseminated through journals. It is not entirely clear which historical character, Bell or Magendie, `won' the dispute, nor that they even had clear and consistent positions in it, but what is clear is that one style of science had won out over the other, and over the course of the dispute, pedagogy lost pride of place in medical science.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Berkowitz, Carin;
(2006)
Disputed Discovery: Vivisection and Experiment in the 19th Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000771702/)
Article
Lisner, Wiebke;
(2009)
Experimente am lebendigen Leib: Zur Frage der Vivisektion in deutschen und britischen medizinischen Wochenschriften 1919--1939
(/isis/citation/CBB001220576/)
Article
Mayer, Jed;
(2008)
The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Laboratory Animals
(/isis/citation/CBB001030099/)
Article
Feller, David Allan;
(2009)
Dog Fight: Darwin as Animal Advocate in the Antivivisection Controversy of 1875
(/isis/citation/CBB000954233/)
Thesis
Stelmackowich, Cindy Lee;
(2010)
Bodies of Knowledge: Nineteenth Century Anatomical Atlases, 1800--1860
(/isis/citation/CBB001562744/)
Article
Carmela Morabito;
(2017)
David Ferrier’s Experimental Localization of Cerebral Functions and the Anti-Vivisection Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB823414183/)
Book
Carin Berkowitz;
(2015)
Charles Bell and the Anatomy of Reform
(/isis/citation/CBB321165855/)
Article
Berkowitz, Carin;
(2014)
Charles Bell's Seeing Hand: Teaching Anatomy to the Senses in Britain, 1750--1840
(/isis/citation/CBB001551591/)
Chapter
Milburn, Colin;
(2008)
Wissenschaft aus der Hölle: Jack the Ripper und die viktorianische Vivisektion
(/isis/citation/CBB001024352/)
Chapter
Marsden, Simon;
(2007)
Dr. Moreau's Crimes: H. G. Wells and the Victorian Vivisection Controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB001035836/)
Article
Boddice, Rob;
(2011)
Vivisecting Major: A Victorian Gentleman Scientist Defends Animal Experimentation, 1876--1885
(/isis/citation/CBB001034548/)
Article
Feller, David A.;
(2009)
Dog Fight: Darwin as Animal Advocate in the Anti-Vivisection Controversy of 1875
(/isis/citation/CBB001030028/)
Article
Jørgensen, C. Barker;
(2003)
Aspects of the History of the Nerves: Bell's Theory, the Bell-Magendie Law and Controversy, and Two Forgotten Works by P. W. Lund and D. F. Eschricht
(/isis/citation/CBB000410011/)
Article
Cunningham, Andrew;
(2002)
The Pen and the Sword: Recovering the Disciplinary Identity of Physiology and Anatomy before 1800: I: Old Physiology---The Pen
(/isis/citation/CBB000770678/)
Book
Broghammer, Herbert;
(2000)
Experimentelle Physiologie und mikroskopische Anatomie in der Nachromantik: Rudolf Peter Heinrich Heidenhain (1834-1897)
(/isis/citation/CBB000600358/)
Book
Cranefield, Paul F.;
(1974)
The way in and the way out: François Magendie, Charles Bell, and the roots of the spinal nerves. With a facsimile of Charles Bell's annotated copy of his Ideas of a new anatomy of the brain
(/isis/citation/CBB000012668/)
Article
Gallistel, C. R.;
(1981)
Bell, Magendie, and the proposals to restrict the use of animals in neurobehavioral research
(/isis/citation/CBB000015787/)
Article
Rice, Gillian;
(1987)
The Bell-Magendie-Walker controversy
(/isis/citation/CBB000050512/)
Chapter
Julius Rocca;
(2016)
Anatomy and Physiology
(/isis/citation/CBB558199636/)
Book
Elwick, James;
(2007)
Styles of Reasoning in the British Life Sciences: Shared Assumptions, 1820--1858
(/isis/citation/CBB000773747/)
Be the first to comment!