General readers enjoy counterfactual histories, what if scenarios that rewrite history. Academic historians seldom write explicit counterfactuals, despite their value in isolating the causes and contingencies that shaped events. Surprisingly, historians of technology have ignored this analytic tool, even though firms and engineers commonly considered alternative designs and actions while developing a product or technology. This article provides a constrained counterfactual, comparing two designs for bridges across the Mississippi River at St. Louis, both proposed in 1867: the Eads Bridge, and the Boomer/Post bridge. It covers three topics: exploring the conventional narratives on the Eads Bridge (completed in 1874); comparing the Eads design to that of the Boomer/Post alternative; and offering a counterfactual service life for that proposed crossing. The article seeks to isolate why James Eads's design and his company succeeded, and to show the analytic value of counterfactuals for historians of technology.
...More
Chapter
Cravo, Télio;
(2014)
Scientific Instruments, Booksellers and Engineers in Imperial Brazil: Building Bridges and Roads in Minas Gerais, 1835--1889
(/isis/citation/CBB001420899/)
Article
John K. Brown;
(2014)
A Different Counterfactual Perspective on the Eads Bridge
(/isis/citation/CBB744995097/)
Thesis
Jackson, Robert W.;
(1997)
James Eads, the St. Louis bridge, and the complexities of capitalism
(/isis/citation/CBB001566165/)
Book
Scott, Quinta;
Miller, Howard S.;
(1979)
The Eads Bridge. Photographic essay by Scott, Quinta. Historical appraisal by Miller, Howard S.
(/isis/citation/CBB000002147/)
Article
Robert W. Jackson;
(2005)
Extant Approach Spans of the Dunleith and Dubuque Bridge
(/isis/citation/CBB281968075/)
Book
Allen, Barry;
(2008)
Artifice and Design: Art and Technology in Human Experience
(/isis/citation/CBB000800290/)
Article
Petroski, Henry;
(1989)
Failure as a unifying theme in design
(/isis/citation/CBB001180733/)
Article
Yonca Hürol;
Cemil Atakara;
(2006)
Ethics behind the Duality between Structure and Ornamentation
(/isis/citation/CBB537733082/)
Article
Emory L. Kemp;
(1993)
The Introduction of Cast and Wrought Iron in Bridge Building
(/isis/citation/CBB212245887/)
Article
Larry D. Lankton;
(1978)
Valley Crossings on the Old Croton Aqueduct
(/isis/citation/CBB935781340/)
Article
Hayward, Alan C. G.;
(2014)
The Construction of Railway Bridges Then and Now
(/isis/citation/CBB001201527/)
Article
Eric DeLony;
(1993)
Surviving Cast- and Wrought-Iron Bridges in America
(/isis/citation/CBB483397256/)
Article
Michael Mende;
(1997)
Biographical Note: Johann Wilhelm Schwedler (1823-94)
(/isis/citation/CBB024389533/)
Book
Billington, David P.;
Billington, David P., Jr.;
(2006)
Power, Speed, and Form: Engineers and the Making of the Twentieth Century
(/isis/citation/CBB000772760/)
Article
Hayward, Alan C. G.;
(2011)
Train Loads on Bridges 1825 to 2010
(/isis/citation/CBB001231611/)
Chapter
Francesco Lensi;
(2010)
I primi ponti metallici della Toscana
(/isis/citation/CBB573100036/)
Article
Andrew C Smith;
(2022)
Isambard K Brunel’s Swivel Bridge of 1849: an overview
(/isis/citation/CBB435416860/)
Article
Sutherland, James;
(2009)
The Birth of Prestressing? Iron Bridges for Railways, 1830 to 1850
(/isis/citation/CBB001231648/)
Article
Barbosa, Lidiany Silva;
(2011)
Os provedores da técnica: os engenheiros provinciais e a edificação da infraestrutura viária de Minas Gerais
(/isis/citation/CBB001420544/)
Book
Hadland, Tony;
Lessing, Hans-Erhard;
(2014)
Bicycle Design: An Illustrated History
(/isis/citation/CBB001551528/)
Be the first to comment!