Article ID: CBB001421195

Who Killed WATERS? Mess, Method, and Forensic Explanation in the Making and Unmaking of Large-scale Science Networks (2014)

unapi

Science studies has long been concerned with the theoretical and methodological challenge of mess---the inevitable tendency of technoscientific objects and practices to spill beyond the neat analytic categories we (or their actors) construct for them. Nowhere is this challenge greater than in the messy world of large-scale collaborative science projects, particularly though not exclusively in their start-up phases. This article examines the complicated life and death of the WATERS Network, an ambitious and ultimately abandoned effort at collaborative infrastructure development among hydrologists, engineers, and social scientists studying water. We argue in particular against the forensic imagination, a particular style of accounting for failure in the messy world of large-scale network development, and against two common conceptual and empirical pitfalls that it gives rise to: defaults to formalism and defaults to the future. We argue that alternative postforensic approaches to failures like the WATERS Network can support forms of learning and accountability better attuned to the complexities of practice and policy in the real world of scientific collaboration and network formation.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001421195/

Similar Citations

Article Carroll, Patrick; (2012)
Water and Technoscientific State Formation in California (/isis/citation/CBB001250759/)

Article Cyrus C. M. Mody; (2020)
Historical Studies in Which Sciences? The Revolving Door of Engineering and Technology (/isis/citation/CBB703937785/)

Article Liana Müller; (2015)
The legal dwelling: how Norwegian research engineers domesticate construction law (/isis/citation/CBB180186297/)

Article Zehev, Tadmor; (Summer 2006)
Redefining Engineering Disciplines for the Twenty-First Century (/isis/citation/CBB623239754/)

Article Cesare S. Maffioli; (2019)
Alle origini del mito di Leonardo da Vinci ingegnere dei navigli di Milano (/isis/citation/CBB657971790/)

Book Brooke Shilling; Paul Stephenson; (2016)
Fountains and Water Culture in Byzantium (/isis/citation/CBB141984574/)

Chapter Georgia L. Irby; (2016)
Hydrology: Ocean, Rivers, and Other Waterways (/isis/citation/CBB868785107/)

Article Gertrud Haidvogl; Verena Winiwarter; Gert Dressel; Sylvia Gierlinger; Friedrich Hauer; Severin Hohensinner; Gudrun Pollack; Christina Spitzbart-Glasl; Erich Raith; (October 2018)
Urban Waters and the Development of Vienna between 1683 and 1910 (/isis/citation/CBB815340100/)

Book Dilip da Cunha; (2019)
The Invention of Rivers: Alexander's eye and Ganga's descent (/isis/citation/CBB607913795/)

Thesis Sackey, Donnie Johnson; (2013)
The Curious Case of the Asian Carp Spatial Performances and the Making of an Invasive Species (/isis/citation/CBB001567525/)

Thesis Psenka, Carolyn Elyse; (2008)
A Monumental Task: Translating Complex Knowledge in NASA's Human Space Flight Network (/isis/citation/CBB001561250/)

Article Lynch, Michael; (2012)
Self-Exemplifying Revolutions? Notes on Kuhn and Latour (/isis/citation/CBB001250754/)

Article Venturini, Tommaso; (2010)
Diving in Magma: How to Explore Controversies with Actor-Network Theory (/isis/citation/CBB001034669/)

Authors & Contributors
Zehev, Tadmor
Raith, Erich
Brooke Shilling
Wolfgang Schirmer
Liana Müller
Haidvogl, Gertrud
Concepts
Water
Hydrology
Actor-network theory
Science studies, theoretical works
Rivers
Engineering
Time Periods
21st century
20th century, late
19th century
17th century
20th century, early
18th century
Places
United States
Central Europe
Constantinople
Namibia
Istanbul (Turkey)
Milan (Italy)
Institutions
United States. Department of Energy
United States. National Aeronautics and Space Administration
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment