Homogeneity and Heterogeneity as Situational Properties: Producing---and Moving beyond?---Race in Post-Genomic Science (2014)
Shim, Janet K. (Author)
Darling, Katherine Weatherford (Author)
Lappe, Martine D (Author)
Thomson, L Katherine (Author)
Lee, Sandra Soo-Jin (Author)
Hiatt, Robert A (Author)
Ackerman, Sara L (Author)
Social Studies of Science
Volume: 44, no. 4
Issue: 4
Pages: 579-599
In this article, we explore current thinking and practices around the logics of difference in gene--environment interaction research in the post-genomic era. We find that scientists conducting gene--environment interaction research continue to invoke well-worn notions of racial difference and diversity, but use them strategically to try to examine other kinds of etiologically significant differences among populations. Scientists do this by seeing populations not as inherently homogeneous or heterogeneous, but rather by actively working to produce homogeneity along some dimensions and heterogeneity along others in their study populations. Thus we argue that homogeneity and heterogeneity are situational properties -- properties that scientists seek to achieve in their study populations, the available data, and other aspects of the research situation they are confronting, and then leverage to advance post-genomic science. Pointing to the situatedness of homogeneity and heterogeneity in gene--environment interaction research underscores the work that these properties do and the contingencies that shape decisions about research procedures. Through a focus on the situational production of homogeneity and heterogeneity more broadly, we find that gene--environment interaction research attempts to shift the logic of difference from solely racial terms as explanatory ends unto themselves, to racial and other dimensions of difference that may be important clues to the causes of complex diseases.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
María Elena Giraldo;
Eliana Arancibia Gutiérrez;
(2023)
Governance in socio-environmental research: an analysis of multi-stakeholder cooperation mechanisms in two research laboratories in Yucatan, Mexico
(/isis/citation/CBB497620424/)
Article
Noguera-Solano, Ricardo;
Ruiz-Gutierrez, Rosaura;
Rodriguez-Caso, Juan Manuel;
(2013)
Genome: Twisting Stories with DNA
(/isis/citation/CBB001213636/)
Article
Guido Barbujani;
(2017)
What Genetics Has to Say about Racial Categorization of Humans
(/isis/citation/CBB088477154/)
Book
Franco Lai;
(2020)
Antropocene: per un'antropologia dei mutamenti socioambientali
(/isis/citation/CBB555307411/)
Article
Bruce Tranter;
Libby Lester;
(2015)
Climate Patriots? Concern Over Climate Change and Other Environmental Issues in Australia
(/isis/citation/CBB974055589/)
Book
Giovanni Carrosio;
Alessandra Landi;
(2023)
Spazio, ambiente, territorio. Teorie, metodi e prospettive di ricerca in sociologia
(/isis/citation/CBB971929401/)
Book
Jüri Engelbrecht;
Erki Tammiksaar;
(2018)
Eesti teaduse 100 aastat
(/isis/citation/CBB886615491/)
Book
Gabriella Corona;
(2023)
L’Italia dell’Antropocene. Percorsi di storia ambientale tra XX e XXI secolo
(/isis/citation/CBB224244479/)
Book
Antony Adler;
(2019)
Neptune’s Laboratory: Fantasy, Fear, and Science at Sea
(/isis/citation/CBB539930107/)
Book
Philippa Levine;
(2017)
Eugenics: A Very Short Introduction
(/isis/citation/CBB212608315/)
Article
TallBear, Kim;
(August 2013)
Genomic articulations of indigeneity
(/isis/citation/CBB368828568/)
Chapter
Roberto Taramelli;
(2016)
Una nuova visione del cancro attraverso le lenti della dinamica dei sistemi
(/isis/citation/CBB225293248/)
Book
Angela Saini;
(2019)
Superior: The Return of Race Science
(/isis/citation/CBB298049329/)
Book
Petroski, Henry;
(2010)
The essential engineer: Why science alone will not solve our global problems
(/isis/citation/CBB001180709/)
Article
Céline Granjou;
Isabelle Arpin;
(November 2015)
Epistemic Commitments: Making Relevant Science in Biodiversity Studies
(/isis/citation/CBB182986827/)
Thesis
Edwards, Barrington Steven;
(2001)
W. E. B. Du Bois, empirical social research and the challenge to race, 1868-1910
(/isis/citation/CBB001562601/)
Article
Jacobson, Arne;
Kammen, Daniel;
(Winter 2005)
Science and Engineering Research That Values the Planet
(/isis/citation/CBB337716604/)
Book
Amir Teicher;
(2019)
Social Mendelism: Genetics and the Politics of Race in Germany, 1900-1948
(/isis/citation/CBB585433440/)
Article
Morana Alač;
(2023)
On body-environment continuities from a laboratory commensalism
(/isis/citation/CBB533308037/)
Article
Jennifer S. Singh;
(Marvh 2015)
Narratives of Participation in Autism Genetics Research
(/isis/citation/CBB713757349/)
Be the first to comment!