Schulz, Armin (Author)
One of the most well known methodological criticisms of evolutionary psychology is Gould's claim that the program pays too much attention to adaptations, and not enough to exaptations. Almost as well known is the standard rebuttal of that criticism: namely, that the study of exaptations in fact depends on the study of adaptations. However, as I try to show in this paper, it is premature to think that this is where this debate ends. First, the notion of exaptation that is commonly used in this debate is different from the one that Gould and Vrba originally defined. Noting this is particularly important, since, second, the standard reply to Gould's criticism only works if the criticism is framed in terms of the former notion of exaptation, and not the latter. However, third, this ultimately does not change the outcome of the debate much, as evolutionary psychologists can respond to the revamped criticism of their program by claiming that the original notion of exaptation is theoretically and empirically uninteresting. By discussing these issues further, I also seek to determine, more generally, which ways of approaching the adaptationism debate in evolutionary biology are useful, and which not.
...More
Article
Schulz, Armin;
(2013)
Exaptation, Adaptation, and Evolutionary Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB001320176/)
Book
Sterelny, Kim;
(2001)
Dawkins vs. Gould: Survival of the Fittest
(/isis/citation/CBB000631012/)
Article
Shanahan, Timothy;
(2001)
Methodological and contextual factors in the Dawkins/Gould dispute over evolutionary progress
(/isis/citation/CBB000100746/)
Article
Sansom, Roger;
(2003)
Constraining the Adaptationism Debate
(/isis/citation/CBB000340586/)
Article
Sheldon, Myrna Perez;
(2014)
Claiming Darwin: Stephen Jay Gould in Contests over Evolutionary Orthodoxy and Public Perception, 1977--2002
(/isis/citation/CBB001420097/)
Book
Joel B. Hagen;
(2021)
Life Out of Balance: Homeostasis and Adaptation in a Darwinian World
(/isis/citation/CBB148836828/)
Article
Morange, Michel;
(2008)
Cyril Norman Hinshelwood (1897--1967)---A Chemical Dynamic Vision of the Organic World
(/isis/citation/CBB001034012/)
Article
Maurizio Meloni;
(2017)
Disentangling life: Darwin, selectionism, and the postgenomic return of the environment
(/isis/citation/CBB291217176/)
Article
D. Vincent Riordan;
(2021)
The Scapegoat Mechanism in Human Evolution: An Analysis of René Girard’s Hypothesis on the Process of Hominization
(/isis/citation/CBB823341248/)
Chapter
Davis, Frederick R.;
(2009)
Papilio Dardanus: The Natural Animal from the Experimentalist's Point of View
(/isis/citation/CBB001022527/)
Article
Depew, David J.;
(2011)
Adaptation as Process: The Future of Darwinism and the Legacy of Theodosius Dobzhansky
(/isis/citation/CBB001023991/)
Book
Ruse, Michael;
Travis, Joseph;
(2009)
Evolution: The First Four Billion Years
(/isis/citation/CBB001232307/)
Article
Dietrich, Michael R.;
(2011)
Reinventing Richard Goldschmidt: Reputation, Memory, and Biography
(/isis/citation/CBB001220958/)
Book
York, Richard;
Clark, Brett;
(2011)
The Science and Humanism of Stephen Jay Gould
(/isis/citation/CBB001023118/)
Article
Ruse, Michael;
(2010)
Darwinism Then and Now: The Divide Over Form and Function
(/isis/citation/CBB001032813/)
Article
Joel B. Hagen;
(2017)
Bergmann’s Rule, Adaptation, and Thermoregulation in Arctic Animals: Conflicting Perspectives from Physiology, Evolutionary Biology, and Physical Anthropology After World War II
(/isis/citation/CBB168604501/)
Chapter
Rudge, David Wyss;
(2009)
H. B. D. Kettlewell's Research, 1934--1961: The Influence of J. W. Heslop Harrison
(/isis/citation/CBB001022528/)
Thesis
Milam, Erika Lorraine;
(2006)
Looking for a Few Good Males: Female Choice in Evolutionary Biology, 1915--1975
(/isis/citation/CBB001560598/)
Book
Borrello, Mark E.;
(2010)
Evolutionary Restraints: The Contentious History of Group Selection
(/isis/citation/CBB001033348/)
Essay Review
Smocovitis, Vassiliki Betty;
(2002)
Rogues and Rotters: A Popular View of Evolutionary Psychology
(/isis/citation/CBB000202117/)
Be the first to comment!