Two Problems in Aristarchus's Treatise On the sizes and distances of the sun and moon (2014)
The book of Aristarchus of Samos, On the distances and sizes of the sun and moon, is one of the few pre-Ptolemaic astronomical works that have come down to us in complete or nearly complete form. The simplicity and cleverness of the basic ideas behind the calculations are often obscured in the reading of the treatise by the complexity of the calculations and reasoning. Part of the complexity could be explained by the lack of trigonometry and part by the fact that Aristarchus appears unwilling to make some simplifications that could be simply taken for granted. But an important part of the complexities is due to some unnecessary inconsistencies, as recently discovered by Berggren and Sidoli (Arch Hist Exact Sci 61:213--254, 2007). In the first part of this paper, I will try to show that some of these inconsistencies are just apparent. But the complexity of the calculations and reasoning is not the only reason that could disturb a reader of the treatise. The great inaccuracy---even for the measurement methods and instruments available at those times---of one of the three input values of the treatise is really astonishing. In the sixth and last hypothesis, Aristarchus states that the moon's apparent size is equal to 2 , while the correct value is one-fourth of that. Some attempts have been made in order to explain such a big value, but all of them have problems. In the second part of this paper, I will propose a new speculative but plausible explanation of the origin of this value.
...MoreSimilar Citations
Article
Carman, Christián C.;
(2009)
Rounding Numbers: Ptolemy's Calculation of the Earth--Sun Distance
(/isis/citation/CBB000932077/)
Article
Berggren, J. L.;
Sidoli, Nathan;
(2007)
Aristarchus's On the Sizes and Distances of the Sun and the Moon: Greek and Arabic Texts
(/isis/citation/CBB000771559/)
Book
Samos, Aristarco de;
Commandino, Federico;
Massa Esteve, María Rosa;
(2007)
Sobre los tamaños y las distancias del sol y la luna
(/isis/citation/CBB000930384/)
Article
Steele, J. M.;
(2007)
Celestial Measurement in Babylonian Astronomy
(/isis/citation/CBB000772410/)
Article
Brack-Bernsen, Lis;
Hunger, Hermann;
(2008)
BM 42282+42294 and the Goal-Year Method
(/isis/citation/CBB000931524/)
Article
Britton, John P.;
(2007)
Studies in Babylonian Lunar Theory: Part I. Empirical Elements for Modeling Lunar and Solar Anomalies
(/isis/citation/CBB000771461/)
Article
Christián C. Carman;
(2019)
A Possible Date for Ptolemy’s Development of a Model for the Second Lunar Anomaly
(/isis/citation/CBB205575975/)
Article
Marie-Noëlle Ribas;
(2018)
Aristote, père de l’astrophysique scientifique
(/isis/citation/CBB311581277/)
Article
Metz, Don;
(2009)
William Wales and the 1769 Transit of Venus: Puzzle Solving and the Determination of the Astronomical Unit
(/isis/citation/CBB001032846/)
Article
Deng, Ke-hui;
(2006)
A comparative study of problems relating to the observation and calculation of the solar year in ancient China and ancient Greece.
(/isis/citation/CBB000701109/)
Article
Paolo Colona;
(2016)
The Myth of Ixion: An Astronomical Interpretation
(/isis/citation/CBB931838778/)
Article
Yavetz, Ido;
(2003)
On Simplicius' Testimony Regarding Eudoxan Lunar Theory
(/isis/citation/CBB000740734/)
Article
Jones, Alexander;
(2000)
Studies in the Astronomy of the Roman Period IV: Solar Tables Based on a Non-Hipparchian Model
(/isis/citation/CBB000111298/)
Book
Swerdlow, N. M.;
(2000)
Ancient Astronomy and Celestial Divination
(/isis/citation/CBB000110580/)
Article
Mercier, Raymond;
(2007)
The Standard Scheme of the Moon and Its Mean Quantities
(/isis/citation/CBB000771560/)
Article
Sidoli, Nathan;
(2005)
Heron's Dioptra 35 and Analemma Methods: An Astronomical Determination of the Distance between Two Cities
(/isis/citation/CBB000651416/)
Chapter
Kollerstrom, Nicholas;
(2001)
On the Measurement of Celestial Longitude in Antiquity
(/isis/citation/CBB000102762/)
Article
Christián C. Carman;
(2018)
The First Copernican Was Copernicus: The Difference Between Pre-Copernican and Copernican Heliocentrism
(/isis/citation/CBB076879380/)
Article
Gail Higginbottom;
A. César González-García;
Benito Vilas-Estévez;
Víctor López-López;
Felipe Criado-Boado;
(2023)
Landscape, orientation and celestial phenomena on the ‘Coast of Death’ of NW Iberia
(/isis/citation/CBB045599609/)
Article
Benítez, Sixto Ramón Giménez;
Alejandro Martín López;
Granada, Anahi;
(2006)
The Sun and the Moon as Marks of Time and Space among the Mocovíes of the Argentinian Chaco
(/isis/citation/CBB001252027/)
Be the first to comment!