Article ID: CBB001321003

The Experimentalist as Humanist: Robert Boyle on the History of Philosophy (2014)

unapi

Historians of science have neglected early modern natural philosophers' varied attitudes to the history of philosophy, often preferring to use loose labels such as `Epicureanism' to describe the survival of ancient doctrines. This is methodologically inappropriate: reifying such philosophical movements tells us little about the complex ways in which early modern natural philosophers approached the history of their own discipline. As this article shows, a central figure of early modern natural philosophy, Robert Boyle, invested great intellectual energy into his depiction of the history of philosophy. Boyle's historical worldview was mediated through an array of textual traditions: classical, patristic, humanist and contemporary. Drawing extensively on his manuscript notes, this is examined for three topics. First, from his turn to natural philosophy in the late 1640s, Boyle combined a sceptical attitude towards philosophy's potential -- stemming from humanist historicisations of the `speculative' heritage of Greek philosophy -- with a belief in natural philosophy's efficacy as a spiritual exercise, as performed by ancient `priests of nature'. Second, Boyle's attitude to the history of matter theory was far more complex than any simple comparison with `ancient atomism' can convey. Unlike many of his contemporaries, Boyle held Epicurus to be a speculative and reductionist philosopher, leading him to posit a different lineage for a non-reductionist corpuscularianism which depended on exploitation of non-standard historiographical traditions. Appreciating this allows us to make an intervention in the ongoing debate about the relationship between corpuscularianism, chymistry and experiment in Boyle's philosophy. Third, Boyle's historicisation of supposedly anthropomorphic philosophies in his famous Free Enquiry (1686) exploited recent theological historiography, most importantly Samuel Parker's combination of the history of idolatry with the history of Greek philosophy, which itself relied on developments in continental sacred history. It was this historicisation, rather than any philosophical realities, which led to the positing of the mechanical philosophy as more compatible than Aristotelianism with Christian doctrine.

...More
Citation URI
https://data.isiscb.org/isis/citation/CBB001321003/

Similar Citations

Article Paul F. Grendler; (2014)
Jesuit Schools in Europe. A Historiographical Essay (/isis/citation/CBB687166731/)

Book Ott, Walter R.; (2009)
Causation and Laws of Nature in Early Modern Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB001033000/)

Book Stefano Caroti; Vittoria Perrone Compagni; (2012)
Nuovi maestri e antichi testi: umanesimo e Rinascimento alle origini del pensiero moderno (/isis/citation/CBB873381482/)

Article Richard Yeo; (2018)
Hippocrates’ Complaint and the Scientific Ethos in Early Modern England (/isis/citation/CBB238799968/)

Book Blum, Paul Richard; (2012)
Studies on Early Modern Aristotelianism (/isis/citation/CBB001201594/)

Chapter Cook, Margaret G.; (2001)
Divine Artifice and Natural Mechanism: Robert Boyle's Mechanical Philosophy of Nature (/isis/citation/CBB000101139/)

Article Michael Wintroub; (2019)
The Pharmakon of ‘If’: Working with Steven Shapin's A Social History of Truth (/isis/citation/CBB323045277/)

Chapter Sophie Roux; (2013)
Was There a Cartesian Experimentalism in 1660s France? (/isis/citation/CBB498349264/)

Chapter Tammy Nyden; (2013)
De Volder’s Cartesian Physics and Experimental Pedagogy (/isis/citation/CBB172484763/)

Article Stefano Dominici; Gary D. Rosenberg; (2021)
Introduction: Nicolaus Steno and earth science in early modern Italy (/isis/citation/CBB445450656/)

Book Cohen, H. Floris; (2010)
How Modern Science Came Into the World: Four Civilizations, One 17th-Century Breakthrough (/isis/citation/CBB001200539/)

Essay Review Irene Fosi; (2007)
Attorno ai Lincei: scienze, scienziati e corte romana nel primo Seicento (/isis/citation/CBB986701036/)

Chapter Anna Laura Puliafito Bleuel; (2012)
Strategie retoriche? Metafora ed esempio nella filosofia naturale di Francesco Patrizi (/isis/citation/CBB043213859/)

Chapter Smith, Pamela H.; (2000)
Vital spirits: Redemption, artisanship, and the new philosophy in early modern Europe (/isis/citation/CBB000110508/)

Book Francesco Andrietti; Dario Generali; (2002)
Storia e storiografia della scienza. Il caso della sistematica (/isis/citation/CBB816940264/)

Chapter Wilson, Catherine; (2010)
Some Motives and Incentives to the Study of Natural Philosophy (/isis/citation/CBB001023230/)

Authors & Contributors
Generali, Dario
Nyden, Tammy
Puliafito Bleuel, Anna Laura
Irene Fosi
Yeo, Richard R.
Wintroub, Michael
Concepts
Natural philosophy
Science and religion
Philosophy of science
Historiography
Philosophy
Humanism
Time Periods
17th century
Early modern
Renaissance
18th century
16th century
21st century
Places
Europe
Italy
England
Florence (Italy)
France
Institutions
Experimentalists
Jesuits (Society of Jesus)
School of Milan
Royal Society of London
Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei (Rome)
Comments

Be the first to comment!

{{ comment.created_by.username }} on {{ comment.created_on | date:'medium' }}

Log in or register to comment